MintyHawk Profile picture
“The curious task of economics is to demonstrate to men how little they really know about what they imagine they can design” F.A. Hayek

May 24, 6 tweets

Alright, I didn't want to do this one, but I honestly cannot stand how contrived this is, so here we go.

@SeattleLGBTQ commission wants @mayorofseattle Wilson to declare a civil emergency for trans refugees fleeing red states. The case rests on a single headline number: 400,000 nationally. That number does not survive five minutes of arithmetic.

/1

Source: a MAP/NORC survey. Trans and nonbinary sample: 111 adults. 9% said they had moved due to LGBTQ politics. That's about ten people. The 400K extrapolation uses a population base roughly 2x what the Williams Institute actually publishes for trans adults. /2

Local check. Gender Justice League's own impact report: 7 relocations last year. 5 the year before. TRACTION says "500 in communication to move." Mayor Wilson, in her response: specific numbers on trans migration to Seattle have not been studied. /3

SMC 10.02 requires extraordinary measures to prevent death or injury and protect public peace. Past triggers: a confirmed COVID outbreak, a structurally failing bridge, thousands sleeping outside in a single night. The Commission itself concedes there is no local count. /4

The ask reduces to: declare the emergency, count later. Wilson, facing a $175M deficit, declined. The honest version of this letter is a budget request. The submitted version leans on a 2x-inflated headline, a survey base of ten, and a Lemkin Institute "genocide" alert standing in for evidence. /fin

h/t @LCRofWashington, appreciate your asking the question.

Share this Scrolly Tale with your friends.

A Scrolly Tale is a new way to read Twitter threads with a more visually immersive experience.
Discover more beautiful Scrolly Tales like this.

Keep scrolling