Those who dismiss this move as an "inconsequential" personal initiative of an MP, miss the point here. It gives a good indication of the current spectre of political views within the central elite and apparatchiks in Moscow. That is more or less a consensus among the Tsar's Court
The entire Tsar's Court in Moscow holds or parrots opinions within this spectre. There are indeed forces which might disagree or while agreeing in principle think that the Tsar went too far. Consider the recent conflict between the Communist leadership (=Tsar's Court) and ...
... the regional Komsomol leadership (= not the Tsar's Court). The latter while agreeing in principle with the "defense of Donbass" argued that Putin went so far.
Such views exist in Russia but they don't exist or are not expressed at the Tsar's Court
If you want to find some sanity and reason among the Russian politicians you should look elsewhere than at the Tsar's Court where slavishness and conformism precede over any other considerations. There is no one at the Tsar's Court to talk with
Furthermore if you want strategic rather than tactical deescalation you must aim to dismantle the Tsar's Court as an institution. It's not enough to change Putin for a "liberal" (=radical Russian ethnonationalist who criticizes Putin's regime for not being ethnically pure enough)
The problem is not so much in Putin as in slavish obedience to the Tsar. Ergo, the problem can not be solved by changing Putin to another Tsar. The position of a Tsar simply gives so much power that all of his vices, delusions and dark sides will be amplified millionfold
The position of a Tsar gives so much power and has such a corrupting effect that anyone holding it will abuse their unconstrained power in every way possible. Ergo, it is the position of a Tsar and a political system that allows for it that must be dismantled
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Traditional Tatar literature is virtually inaccessible for modern Tatars for a similar reason. Till the 20th c we used to be a Persianate culture, so being "educated" implied a decent knowledge of Farsi (at least) and Arabic (ideally). You needed to be at least bilingual
That helped to differ the registers of language. For example, in English a word constructed on a original Germanic root would be of lowest register, with French root being higher and Latin even higher than that. Consider terms "kingly", "royal" and "regal" for example
In Tatar a word with an originally Turkic root would be considered of a lower register, while a borrowed Arabic or Farsi word - of higher. For example a Turkic word for a nightingale "Sandugach" would be viewed as mundane while a Farsi "Bulbul" - very poetic
Peter I's figure is very much misunderstood. There was hardly any other Russian ruler so widely and universally hated during his lifetime. No wonder so many of his reforms were reversed almost immediately upon his death: Navy budget cut, the capital brought back to Moscow, etc
1) Transformation of all varieties of bondage & servitude to a chattel slavery. Rapid expansion of unfree labor in industry
2) Depopulation & de-urbanization
3) Extremely arbitrary military regime, to the extent unknown since Ivan the Terrible
If there is any decent and readable narrative of how Peter's regime was perceived by his subjects in English, then I'm unaware of its existence. But you can take a Sergey Sergeyev's book, open it on this page and google translate it loveread.ec/read_book.php?…
Much of the expertise on Russia has negative value not necessarily because the experts are wrong (they may be right), but because they are right about the unimportant stuff. Lacking the deep understanding of and the deep guanxi in Russia they have no idea what to focus on
That creates an absolutely false and distorted image of Russia in the West. The analysts and the media might not be technically "wrong". They are lying by omission in most cases, not noticing or pretending not to notice a nice herd of elephants in the room. Like the Metodologiya
The impact of Metodologiya on politics & governance is well-known in Russia. Consider this very good introduction by a media I don't really like. It may not be 100% correct but it's a great intro to a topic virtually unknown in the West
Scrolling ticker in Moscow informs passerby about the forthcoming execution of POWs in Ukraine:
"TASS: The Supreme Court of the Donetsk Peoples Republic sentenced mercenaries from Great Britain and Morocco to death"
Moscow doesn't look as a wartime city. Putin is trying hard to keep an illusion of normality and business as usual. Kremlin will work hard so that Moscow wouldn't feel the hardships of war. At the same time, regime lacks resources for other cities, even for the St Petersburg
Source of the video. Btw if you are really interested in what's going on in Russia, it's a good idea to explore the Telegram. It would not be an exaggeration to say that Telegram is the most important independent media & blogging platform in modern Russia
Diversity is natural, uniformity is artificial. Whenever you see the uniformity of cultural memes, be it the linguistic map of modern France or the style of Russian icons, you may be sure it is a result of violent homogenisation. Consider this trifacial Trinity from Tobolsk
Trinities with three faces and four eyes were quite common for the Early Modern Siberia. Ecclesiastical authorities of Tobolsk issued two orders in 1748 and 1770 forbidding the use of these "Hellenic" (=pagan) images. Still they were used in churches and privately till the 20th c
Imperial authorities disapproved three facial trinity icons. When Catherine II was visiting Kazan in 1764, a local merchant brought her such an icon as a gift. She ordered to arrest him and investigate immediately. Heterodoxy in iconography would arouse suspicions in heresy
Good morning. It's time for cartoons (not a thread)
Much like the Ming to Qing transition, the Soviet to post-Soviet transition was the Golden Age of culture. Censorship was over, while much of Perestroika optimism was still alive. Today I'm gonna show you a couple of iconic cartoons that you absolutely must be aware of
"Treasure Island" by "Kyivnauchfilm". Kyivnauchfilm = Kyiv Scientific Movies. In the Soviet era this Ukrainian studio had to shoot some boring academic instruction videos. Thankfully, in Perestroika era they abandoned any false pretence of rigour and just started drawing cartoons