Thread by @karmousaG

1 Hi guys so let me start by saying I'm.mot a lawyer and will wait like you for Punchys in depth analysis of today. I'll share the notes I took and could catch. Estate said we are here for a motion to compel. HBO then spoke and said this is a question that's down to language

2. They said this is. Not infinite that we are barred about saying something bad about Mj. The judge interrupts and says that is for the arbiter to decide. They are saying we breached the no disparagement. The judge cuts in and says insulting Mj a disparagement is a disparagement

3. Judge says there is a provision that states that you shall.not disparage singer. hBo then says you have tot look at the totalit#y and this is about a concert why are they mentioning the dangerous tour. Judge again says it does t get around disparagement and again says

5 The judge says again an arbitrator should decide not you. Estate now says we didn't just sue for ND we also sued because of the way they went about it. The contract makes it clear that they have to get our permission and that HBO produced it.

So I skipped 4 while. numbering please forgive me I'm on the train but will go straight to 6 which didn't even send. So I'll send it again.

6. Estate talking still The biggest problem is also how they went about it and Sandbagged us. Confidentiality states laws are irrefutable under the 1st amendment and they are arbitrable or can be arbitrated. hbo position precludes 1st amendment and doesn't apply here.

7. HBO now speaks and they say the doc was released and we aren't arguing i if the allegations are true or boot but that this issue was a public concern. The judge then says these allegations have been around fthey are aren't new and Mj is dead what's the concern?

8. If he weee alive you can't call him a pedophile you signed the contract and the judge asked about HBO was not as big as it was and brought light to them being a baby back then land you signed a contract.

9. Judge asked estate about the company optimum and they said we have been around since the 80s 1983 I. Believe he said don't quote me here. Judge asked HBO did you file an anti slap motion? HBO says no. The judge goes back to the provision of the contract when signed

10. hBo says they want to create a perpetual silence brings up the concern again and judge said may what concern. Then judge said you didn't file an anit slap. Estate says giving them a way out is not fair. Judge says if it's a slap concern llet them file it.

Esstarw says that 1st amendemwnr is for a arbitrator to decide and hey should rule on this. Anti slap they must write one by aug 15 there is a replybon the 5 and will meet again spent 19 I believe. Hope this helps you guys -:)))

Guys Jonathon S estate lawyer says please tell the fans I tried today but we will have another round in Sept