Thread by @ncdave4life

@Tokyo_Tom @JoeTheAtheist @insane_voice @OscarsWild1 @Jamz129 @Schtickery @Gladfly1 @DawnTJ90 @EthonRaptor @ClimatePoet @Kenneth72712993 @HVACPerformance @maya_phd @heisenburgal2o3 @eloarefab @GillesnFio @swcrisis @FrankWi74044551 @DonWils13730132 @KCTaz @TheDisproof @Achilles_1985 @ROosten @AtomsksSanakan @stevethib @horrdorr @Albert_Redstone @PolAnimalAus @WadeKendall4 @JsharkJill @NikolovScience @tracemetalclean @CymaticWave @PierreTherrie14 @Tangomitteckel @foresaken1 @Vieux_Rhone @dvibrationz @pinangodan @AOECOIN @FactFascist @Bananenrijperij @KGrumpallo @FrankChanged @ElQuesoSabio @Creamih8 @Vulgar_wit @MATTP1949 @whyofweb @KnowYourGreen1 Agronomists (real scientists) MEASURE crop yields under varying conditions. They've done thousands of studies, and published thousands of excellent peer-reviewed papers with the results, showing the large BENEFITS of eCO2, in stark contrast to garbage modelling studies you cite.

@Tokyo_Tom @JoeTheAtheist @insane_voice @OscarsWild1 @Jamz129 @Schtickery @Gladfly1 @DawnTJ90 @EthonRaptor @ClimatePoet @Kenneth72712993 @HVACPerformance @maya_phd @heisenburgal2o3 @eloarefab @GillesnFio @swcrisis @FrankWi74044551 @DonWils13730132 @KCTaz @TheDisproof @Achilles_1985 @ROosten @AtomsksSanakan @stevethib @horrdorr @Albert_Redstone @PolAnimalAus @WadeKendall4 @JsharkJill @NikolovScience @tracemetalclean @CymaticWave @PierreTherrie14 @Tangomitteckel @foresaken1 @Vieux_Rhone @dvibrationz @pinangodan @AOECOIN @FactFascist @Bananenrijperij @KGrumpallo @FrankChanged @ElQuesoSabio @Creamih8 @Vulgar_wit @MATTP1949 @whyofweb @KnowYourGreen1 All fruits, vegetables, nuts & trees benefit greatly from eCO2. So do all major grains:
co2science.org/data/plant_gro…

@Tokyo_Tom @JoeTheAtheist @insane_voice @OscarsWild1 @Jamz129 @Schtickery @Gladfly1 @DawnTJ90 @EthonRaptor @ClimatePoet @Kenneth72712993 @HVACPerformance @maya_phd @heisenburgal2o3 @eloarefab @GillesnFio @swcrisis @FrankWi74044551 @DonWils13730132 @KCTaz @TheDisproof @Achilles_1985 @ROosten @AtomsksSanakan @stevethib @horrdorr @Albert_Redstone @PolAnimalAus @WadeKendall4 @JsharkJill @NikolovScience @tracemetalclean @CymaticWave @PierreTherrie14 @Tangomitteckel @foresaken1 @Vieux_Rhone @dvibrationz @pinangodan @AOECOIN @FactFascist @Bananenrijperij @KGrumpallo @FrankChanged @ElQuesoSabio @Creamih8 @Vulgar_wit @MATTP1949 @whyofweb @KnowYourGreen1 The Indian subcontinent used to regularly be ravaged by famine. Now they have food surpluses every year thanks, in major part, to eCO2.

@Tokyo_Tom @JoeTheAtheist @insane_voice @OscarsWild1 @Jamz129 @Schtickery @Gladfly1 @DawnTJ90 @EthonRaptor @ClimatePoet @Kenneth72712993 @HVACPerformance @maya_phd @heisenburgal2o3 @eloarefab @GillesnFio @swcrisis @FrankWi74044551 @DonWils13730132 @KCTaz @TheDisproof @Achilles_1985 @ROosten @AtomsksSanakan @stevethib @horrdorr @Albert_Redstone @PolAnimalAus @WadeKendall4 @JsharkJill @NikolovScience @tracemetalclean @CymaticWave @PierreTherrie14 @Tangomitteckel @foresaken1 @Vieux_Rhone @dvibrationz @pinangodan @AOECOIN @FactFascist @Bananenrijperij @KGrumpallo @FrankChanged @ElQuesoSabio @Creamih8 @Vulgar_wit @MATTP1949 @whyofweb Studies MEASURING the effects of eCO2 show EXACTLY the opposite of that Lobell propaganda piece in @sciencemag. Wheat benefits enormously from eCO2; here's a study:
ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/26929390

@Tokyo_Tom @JoeTheAtheist @insane_voice @OscarsWild1 @Jamz129 @Schtickery @Gladfly1 @DawnTJ90 @EthonRaptor @ClimatePoet @Kenneth72712993 @HVACPerformance @maya_phd @heisenburgal2o3 @eloarefab @GillesnFio @swcrisis @FrankWi74044551 @DonWils13730132 @KCTaz @TheDisproof @Achilles_1985 @ROosten @AtomsksSanakan @stevethib @horrdorr @Albert_Redstone @PolAnimalAus @WadeKendall4 @JsharkJill @NikolovScience @tracemetalclean @CymaticWave @PierreTherrie14 @Tangomitteckel @foresaken1 @Vieux_Rhone @dvibrationz @pinangodan @AOECOIN @FactFascist @Bananenrijperij @KGrumpallo @FrankChanged @ElQuesoSabio @Creamih8 @Vulgar_wit @MATTP1949 @whyofweb @sciencemag Wheat and corn are both grown from Texas & Louisiana to North Dakota & Canada. Fretting over a potential growing zone shift of 50-70 miles is ludicrous.

@Tokyo_Tom @JoeTheAtheist @insane_voice @OscarsWild1 @Jamz129 @Schtickery @Gladfly1 @DawnTJ90 @EthonRaptor @ClimatePoet @Kenneth72712993 @HVACPerformance @maya_phd @heisenburgal2o3 @eloarefab @GillesnFio @swcrisis @FrankWi74044551 @DonWils13730132 @KCTaz @TheDisproof @Achilles_1985 @ROosten @AtomsksSanakan @stevethib @horrdorr @Albert_Redstone @PolAnimalAus @WadeKendall4 @JsharkJill @NikolovScience @tracemetalclean @CymaticWave @PierreTherrie14 @Tangomitteckel @foresaken1 @Vieux_Rhone @dvibrationz @pinangodan @AOECOIN @FactFascist @Bananenrijperij @KGrumpallo @FrankChanged @ElQuesoSabio @Creamih8 @Vulgar_wit @MATTP1949 @whyofweb @sciencemag Even though corn (maize) is a C4 crop, studies show it still benefits greatly from eCO2:

sciencedirect.com/science/articl…
Chun, et al, 2010. Effect of elevated carbon dioxide and water stress on gas exchange and water use efficiency in corn. Agricultural and Forest Meteorology, 2011.

@Tokyo_Tom @JoeTheAtheist @insane_voice @OscarsWild1 @Jamz129 @Schtickery @Gladfly1 @DawnTJ90 @EthonRaptor @ClimatePoet @Kenneth72712993 @HVACPerformance @maya_phd @heisenburgal2o3 @eloarefab @GillesnFio @swcrisis @FrankWi74044551 @DonWils13730132 @KCTaz @TheDisproof @Achilles_1985 @ROosten @AtomsksSanakan @stevethib @horrdorr @Albert_Redstone @PolAnimalAus @WadeKendall4 @JsharkJill @NikolovScience @tracemetalclean @CymaticWave @PierreTherrie14 @Tangomitteckel @foresaken1 @Vieux_Rhone @dvibrationz @pinangodan @AOECOIN @FactFascist @Bananenrijperij @KGrumpallo @FrankChanged @ElQuesoSabio @Creamih8 @Vulgar_wit @MATTP1949 @whyofweb @sciencemag Here's another study showing the benefits of eCO2 for corn/maize:
tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.108…
Effect of Elevated [CO2] on Assimilation, Allocation of Nitrogen and Phosphorus by Maize (Zea Mays L.)
Xiaojin Xie, Renying Li, Yaohong Zhang, Shuanghe Shen & Yunxuan Bao

@Tokyo_Tom @JoeTheAtheist @insane_voice @OscarsWild1 @Jamz129 @Schtickery @Gladfly1 @DawnTJ90 @EthonRaptor @ClimatePoet @Kenneth72712993 @HVACPerformance @maya_phd @heisenburgal2o3 @eloarefab @GillesnFio @swcrisis @FrankWi74044551 @DonWils13730132 @KCTaz @TheDisproof @Achilles_1985 @ROosten @AtomsksSanakan @stevethib @horrdorr @Albert_Redstone @PolAnimalAus @WadeKendall4 @JsharkJill @NikolovScience @tracemetalclean @CymaticWave @PierreTherrie14 @Tangomitteckel @foresaken1 @Vieux_Rhone @dvibrationz @pinangodan @AOECOIN @FactFascist @Bananenrijperij @KGrumpallo @FrankChanged @ElQuesoSabio @Creamih8 @Vulgar_wit @MATTP1949 @whyofweb @sciencemag Soybeans also benefit very dramatically from elevated CO2:

@Tokyo_Tom @JoeTheAtheist @insane_voice @OscarsWild1 @Jamz129 @Schtickery @Gladfly1 @DawnTJ90 @EthonRaptor @ClimatePoet @Kenneth72712993 @HVACPerformance @maya_phd @heisenburgal2o3 @eloarefab @GillesnFio @swcrisis @FrankWi74044551 @DonWils13730132 @KCTaz @TheDisproof @Achilles_1985 @ROosten @AtomsksSanakan @stevethib @horrdorr @Albert_Redstone @PolAnimalAus @WadeKendall4 @JsharkJill @NikolovScience @tracemetalclean @CymaticWave @PierreTherrie14 @Tangomitteckel @foresaken1 @Vieux_Rhone @dvibrationz @pinangodan @AOECOIN @FactFascist @Bananenrijperij @KGrumpallo @FrankChanged @ElQuesoSabio @Creamih8 @Vulgar_wit @MATTP1949 @whyofweb @sciencemag Rice is C3. Like all C3 crops it benefits dramatically from eCO2. Here's a FACE (Free Air CO2 Enrichment) study of rice:
europepmc.org/abstract/med/2…
They compared 380 ppmv CO2 to 550 ppmv & found a 30% grain yield improvement (tho FACE studies typically underestimate the benefits):

@Tokyo_Tom @JoeTheAtheist @insane_voice @OscarsWild1 @Jamz129 @Schtickery @Gladfly1 @DawnTJ90 @EthonRaptor @ClimatePoet @Kenneth72712993 @HVACPerformance @maya_phd @heisenburgal2o3 @eloarefab @GillesnFio @swcrisis @FrankWi74044551 @DonWils13730132 @KCTaz @TheDisproof @Achilles_1985 @ROosten @AtomsksSanakan @stevethib @horrdorr @Albert_Redstone @PolAnimalAus @WadeKendall4 @JsharkJill @NikolovScience @tracemetalclean @CymaticWave @PierreTherrie14 @Tangomitteckel @foresaken1 @Vieux_Rhone @dvibrationz @pinangodan @AOECOIN @FactFascist @Bananenrijperij @KGrumpallo @FrankChanged @ElQuesoSabio @Creamih8 @Vulgar_wit @MATTP1949 @whyofweb @sciencemag eCO2 is highly beneficial for nearly all crops. Here's a USDA survey paper:
naldc.nal.usda.gov/download/53689…
Final sentence: "Thus, it appears from the analysis of the prior data that agricultural yields will increase overall by about 33% with a doubling of the earth’s C02 concentration."

@Tokyo_Tom @JoeTheAtheist @insane_voice @OscarsWild1 @Jamz129 @Schtickery @Gladfly1 @DawnTJ90 @EthonRaptor @ClimatePoet @Kenneth72712993 @HVACPerformance @maya_phd @heisenburgal2o3 @eloarefab @GillesnFio @swcrisis @FrankWi74044551 @DonWils13730132 @KCTaz @TheDisproof @Achilles_1985 @ROosten @AtomsksSanakan @stevethib @horrdorr @Albert_Redstone @PolAnimalAus @WadeKendall4 @JsharkJill @NikolovScience @tracemetalclean @CymaticWave @PierreTherrie14 @Tangomitteckel @foresaken1 @Vieux_Rhone @dvibrationz @pinangodan @AOECOIN @FactFascist @Bananenrijperij @KGrumpallo @FrankChanged @ElQuesoSabio @Creamih8 @Vulgar_wit @MATTP1949 @whyofweb @threadreaderapp unroll it, please.