Thread by @ncdave4life

@glinch72 @AristotleMrs @JohnDublin10 @TWTThisIsNow @ammocrypta @FChecker76 @Willard1951 @geoguy_usa104 @Stephen90045069 @NonlinearDarren @Climatehope2 @flyonthewall182 @GregTruman4 @Jaisans @GregCoo85844909 @25_cycle @BrknMan @don85375 @ZSRenn @1tsakeeper @LizHersch1 @KCTaz @JustThi30117912 @gregchoat @Anvndarnamn5 @B_Bolshevik100 @NickMcGinley1 @RobMeekel @cieloyla @EthonRaptor @BradPKeyes @JSegor @Mark_A_Lunn @BridgetHolmstro @jwickers @0Sundance @PeterMayfitz @omahas @TonyBoloni8 @TheDisproof @DanCady @dan613 @Keeper_86 @Jamz129 @CallMeBlaise1 @ostinado @IngersolRobert @CarrudoDon @DK25769559 1/9. Good grief, do you mean you're one of the suckers who takes that "climatefeedback" climate industry propaganda site seriously??

rattibha.com/thread/1416826…

@glinch72 @AristotleMrs @JohnDublin10 @TWTThisIsNow @ammocrypta @FChecker76 @Willard1951 @geoguy_usa104 @Stephen90045069 @NonlinearDarren @Climatehope2 @flyonthewall182 @GregTruman4 @Jaisans @GregCoo85844909 @25_cycle @BrknMan @don85375 @ZSRenn @1tsakeeper @LizHersch1 @KCTaz @JustThi30117912 @gregchoat @Anvndarnamn5 @B_Bolshevik100 @NickMcGinley1 @RobMeekel @cieloyla @EthonRaptor @BradPKeyes @JSegor @Mark_A_Lunn @BridgetHolmstro @jwickers @0Sundance @PeterMayfitz @omahas @TonyBoloni8 @TheDisproof @DanCady @dan613 @Keeper_86 @Jamz129 @CallMeBlaise1 @ostinado @IngersolRobert @CarrudoDon @DK25769559 2/9. Their article is nonsense. For instance they said that Lindzen's statement that “there is no evidence that CO2 emissions are the dominant factor” in climate change is false.

@glinch72 @AristotleMrs @JohnDublin10 @TWTThisIsNow @ammocrypta @FChecker76 @Willard1951 @geoguy_usa104 @Stephen90045069 @NonlinearDarren @Climatehope2 @flyonthewall182 @GregTruman4 @Jaisans @GregCoo85844909 @25_cycle @BrknMan @don85375 @ZSRenn @1tsakeeper @LizHersch1 @KCTaz @JustThi30117912 @gregchoat @Anvndarnamn5 @B_Bolshevik100 @NickMcGinley1 @RobMeekel @cieloyla @EthonRaptor @BradPKeyes @JSegor @Mark_A_Lunn @BridgetHolmstro @jwickers @0Sundance @PeterMayfitz @omahas @TonyBoloni8 @TheDisproof @DanCady @dan613 @Keeper_86 @Jamz129 @CallMeBlaise1 @ostinado @IngersolRobert @CarrudoDon @DK25769559 3/9. Immediately after calling that statement false they PROVED that it's TRUE!

Remarkably, they apparently don't even realize it.

@glinch72 @AristotleMrs @JohnDublin10 @TWTThisIsNow @ammocrypta @FChecker76 @Willard1951 @geoguy_usa104 @Stephen90045069 @NonlinearDarren @Climatehope2 @flyonthewall182 @GregTruman4 @Jaisans @GregCoo85844909 @25_cycle @BrknMan @don85375 @ZSRenn @1tsakeeper @LizHersch1 @KCTaz @JustThi30117912 @gregchoat @Anvndarnamn5 @B_Bolshevik100 @NickMcGinley1 @RobMeekel @cieloyla @EthonRaptor @BradPKeyes @JSegor @Mark_A_Lunn @BridgetHolmstro @jwickers @0Sundance @PeterMayfitz @omahas @TonyBoloni8 @TheDisproof @DanCady @dan613 @Keeper_86 @Jamz129 @CallMeBlaise1 @ostinado @IngersolRobert @CarrudoDon @DK25769559 4/9. They claimed, "Human-caused increases in CO2 emissions have been the primary driver of climate change."

But then they admitted, "Atmospheric concentrations of CO2 are higher today than they have been in at least the past 800,000 years."

@glinch72 @AristotleMrs @JohnDublin10 @TWTThisIsNow @ammocrypta @FChecker76 @Willard1951 @geoguy_usa104 @Stephen90045069 @NonlinearDarren @Climatehope2 @flyonthewall182 @GregTruman4 @Jaisans @GregCoo85844909 @25_cycle @BrknMan @don85375 @ZSRenn @1tsakeeper @LizHersch1 @KCTaz @JustThi30117912 @gregchoat @Anvndarnamn5 @B_Bolshevik100 @NickMcGinley1 @RobMeekel @cieloyla @EthonRaptor @BradPKeyes @JSegor @Mark_A_Lunn @BridgetHolmstro @jwickers @0Sundance @PeterMayfitz @omahas @TonyBoloni8 @TheDisproof @DanCady @dan613 @Keeper_86 @Jamz129 @CallMeBlaise1 @ostinado @IngersolRobert @CarrudoDon @DK25769559 5/9. That 2nd statement is true: CO2 level is much higher today than it has been in the last 800K years.

But that big increase in CO2 level has been accompanied by only a small increase in temperature. It's so slight it's hard to measure:

woodfortrees.org/plot/gistemp-d…

@glinch72 @AristotleMrs @JohnDublin10 @TWTThisIsNow @ammocrypta @FChecker76 @Willard1951 @geoguy_usa104 @Stephen90045069 @NonlinearDarren @Climatehope2 @flyonthewall182 @GregTruman4 @Jaisans @GregCoo85844909 @25_cycle @BrknMan @don85375 @ZSRenn @1tsakeeper @LizHersch1 @KCTaz @JustThi30117912 @gregchoat @Anvndarnamn5 @B_Bolshevik100 @NickMcGinley1 @RobMeekel @cieloyla @EthonRaptor @BradPKeyes @JSegor @Mark_A_Lunn @BridgetHolmstro @jwickers @0Sundance @PeterMayfitz @omahas @TonyBoloni8 @TheDisproof @DanCady @dan613 @Keeper_86 @Jamz129 @CallMeBlaise1 @ostinado @IngersolRobert @CarrudoDon @DK25769559 6/9. At times during those 800K yrs, avg global temps were substantially warmer than now. Other times temps swung by an est. 5 - 8 °C, as ice sheets advanced & retreated. Yet those big climate changes varied CO2 levels only ≈90 ppmv: much less than the last 60 yrs' CO2 rise.

@glinch72 @AristotleMrs @JohnDublin10 @TWTThisIsNow @ammocrypta @FChecker76 @Willard1951 @geoguy_usa104 @Stephen90045069 @NonlinearDarren @Climatehope2 @flyonthewall182 @GregTruman4 @Jaisans @GregCoo85844909 @25_cycle @BrknMan @don85375 @ZSRenn @1tsakeeper @LizHersch1 @KCTaz @JustThi30117912 @gregchoat @Anvndarnamn5 @B_Bolshevik100 @NickMcGinley1 @RobMeekel @cieloyla @EthonRaptor @BradPKeyes @JSegor @Mark_A_Lunn @BridgetHolmstro @jwickers @0Sundance @PeterMayfitz @omahas @TonyBoloni8 @TheDisproof @DanCady @dan613 @Keeper_86 @Jamz129 @CallMeBlaise1 @ostinado @IngersolRobert @CarrudoDon @DK25769559 7/9. Ice core records also show that temperatures have, in the past, often changed much more rapidly and dramatically than they have over the last century. Yet those dramatic temperature changes were accompanied by only very slight CO2 level changes.

nature.com/scitable/knowl…

@glinch72 @AristotleMrs @JohnDublin10 @TWTThisIsNow @ammocrypta @FChecker76 @Willard1951 @geoguy_usa104 @Stephen90045069 @NonlinearDarren @Climatehope2 @flyonthewall182 @GregTruman4 @Jaisans @GregCoo85844909 @25_cycle @BrknMan @don85375 @ZSRenn @1tsakeeper @LizHersch1 @KCTaz @JustThi30117912 @gregchoat @Anvndarnamn5 @B_Bolshevik100 @NickMcGinley1 @RobMeekel @cieloyla @EthonRaptor @BradPKeyes @JSegor @Mark_A_Lunn @BridgetHolmstro @jwickers @0Sundance @PeterMayfitz @omahas @TonyBoloni8 @TheDisproof @DanCady @dan613 @Keeper_86 @Jamz129 @CallMeBlaise1 @ostinado @IngersolRobert @CarrudoDon @DK25769559 8/9. Obviously, CO2 is not the main driver of climate change, over the long term. We aren't sure what caused the Dansgaard–Oeschger events, but it certainly wasn't CO2.
Whatever it was, it caused MUCH more dramatic climate change than our CO2 emissions have.

@glinch72 @AristotleMrs @JohnDublin10 @TWTThisIsNow @ammocrypta @FChecker76 @Willard1951 @geoguy_usa104 @Stephen90045069 @NonlinearDarren @Climatehope2 @flyonthewall182 @GregTruman4 @Jaisans @GregCoo85844909 @25_cycle @BrknMan @don85375 @ZSRenn @1tsakeeper @LizHersch1 @KCTaz @JustThi30117912 @gregchoat @Anvndarnamn5 @B_Bolshevik100 @NickMcGinley1 @RobMeekel @cieloyla @EthonRaptor @BradPKeyes @JSegor @Mark_A_Lunn @BridgetHolmstro @jwickers @0Sundance @PeterMayfitz @omahas @TonyBoloni8 @TheDisproof @DanCady @dan613 @Keeper_86 @Jamz129 @CallMeBlaise1 @ostinado @IngersolRobert 9/9. Remarkably, the "climatefeedback" propagandists apparently don't even realize that they proved Lindzen's point.

@rattibha @threadreaderapp @threader_app please unroll or compile this.