Thread by @ncdave4life

@thinks_about_it @mel_wright123 @Willard1951 @Gordon_DHG @rdqBlueRidge @robhon_ @AGWIsHappening @IceAge2150 @Gladfly1 @ScienceBlog3 @MartinJBern @TWTThisIsNow @Moderna5G_666 @Canadianworker2 @RushhourP @AristotleMrs @insane_voice @Narvuntien @RidaAller @Nockit1 @Tempora23227548 @JohnGiuliano7 @GeraldKutney @TheDisproof @BL4CKsH33P6 @Climatehope2 @25_cycle @Ceist8 @crankyfucker @cjtjgeol @1Astroturf @claude_roumain @sapp_erlot @Michael71718318 @Robert76907841 @ejwwest @CloneDwarf @WinWithScience @Hedendom @Barbarajdurkin @RoyPentland @TinTincognito @Robin_Hagues @JohnnyD93941059 @USCriticalMess @MikeDel21893959 @Michael_D_Crow @gptnshl @Tony__Heller @JoeShaw111 1/17》Wang et al (2020), "Recent global decline of CO2 fertilization effects on vegetation photosynthesis" Science 370(6522), pp.1295-1300.
doi:10.1126/science.abb7772 is junk science. You need to read the comments on it. Here's one:

science.org/doi/10.1126/sc…

@thinks_about_it @mel_wright123 @Willard1951 @Gordon_DHG @rdqBlueRidge @robhon_ @AGWIsHappening @IceAge2150 @Gladfly1 @ScienceBlog3 @MartinJBern @TWTThisIsNow @Moderna5G_666 @Canadianworker2 @RushhourP @AristotleMrs @insane_voice @Narvuntien @RidaAller @Nockit1 @Tempora23227548 @JohnGiuliano7 @GeraldKutney @TheDisproof @BL4CKsH33P6 @Climatehope2 @25_cycle @Ceist8 @crankyfucker @cjtjgeol @1Astroturf @claude_roumain @sapp_erlot @Michael71718318 @Robert76907841 @ejwwest @CloneDwarf @WinWithScience @Hedendom @Barbarajdurkin @RoyPentland @TinTincognito @Robin_Hagues @JohnnyD93941059 @USCriticalMess @MikeDel21893959 @Michael_D_Crow @gptnshl @Tony__Heller @JoeShaw111 2/17》Here's another:

science.org/doi/10.1126/sc…

@thinks_about_it @mel_wright123 @Willard1951 @Gordon_DHG @rdqBlueRidge @robhon_ @AGWIsHappening @IceAge2150 @Gladfly1 @ScienceBlog3 @MartinJBern @TWTThisIsNow @Moderna5G_666 @Canadianworker2 @RushhourP @AristotleMrs @insane_voice @Narvuntien @RidaAller @Nockit1 @Tempora23227548 @JohnGiuliano7 @GeraldKutney @TheDisproof @BL4CKsH33P6 @Climatehope2 @25_cycle @Ceist8 @crankyfucker @cjtjgeol @1Astroturf @claude_roumain @sapp_erlot @Michael71718318 @Robert76907841 @ejwwest @CloneDwarf @WinWithScience @Hedendom @Barbarajdurkin @RoyPentland @TinTincognito @Robin_Hagues @JohnnyD93941059 @USCriticalMess @MikeDel21893959 @Michael_D_Crow @gptnshl @Tony__Heller @JoeShaw111 3/17》Do you know what Wang et al meant by "decline of CO2 fertilization effects"?

You probably think it means that the rate at which the terrestrial biosphere removes CO2 from the air is slowing. Right?

@thinks_about_it @mel_wright123 @Willard1951 @Gordon_DHG @rdqBlueRidge @robhon_ @AGWIsHappening @IceAge2150 @Gladfly1 @ScienceBlog3 @MartinJBern @TWTThisIsNow @Moderna5G_666 @Canadianworker2 @RushhourP @AristotleMrs @insane_voice @Narvuntien @RidaAller @Nockit1 @Tempora23227548 @JohnGiuliano7 @GeraldKutney @TheDisproof @BL4CKsH33P6 @Climatehope2 @25_cycle @Ceist8 @crankyfucker @cjtjgeol @1Astroturf @claude_roumain @sapp_erlot @Michael71718318 @Robert76907841 @ejwwest @CloneDwarf @WinWithScience @Hedendom @Barbarajdurkin @RoyPentland @TinTincognito @Robin_Hagues @JohnnyD93941059 @USCriticalMess @MikeDel21893959 @Michael_D_Crow @gptnshl @Tony__Heller @JoeShaw111 4/17》You can be forgiven for thinking that, because that's the mistake they want you to make, because the purpose of that title is not to promote understanding of the carbon cycle, but to promote the "climate emergency" scam. But that's not what it actually means.

@thinks_about_it @mel_wright123 @Willard1951 @Gordon_DHG @rdqBlueRidge @robhon_ @AGWIsHappening @IceAge2150 @Gladfly1 @ScienceBlog3 @MartinJBern @TWTThisIsNow @Moderna5G_666 @Canadianworker2 @RushhourP @AristotleMrs @insane_voice @Narvuntien @RidaAller @Nockit1 @Tempora23227548 @JohnGiuliano7 @GeraldKutney @TheDisproof @BL4CKsH33P6 @Climatehope2 @25_cycle @Ceist8 @crankyfucker @cjtjgeol @1Astroturf @claude_roumain @sapp_erlot @Michael71718318 @Robert76907841 @ejwwest @CloneDwarf @WinWithScience @Hedendom @Barbarajdurkin @RoyPentland @TinTincognito @Robin_Hagues @JohnnyD93941059 @USCriticalMess @MikeDel21893959 @Michael_D_Crow @gptnshl @Tony__Heller @JoeShaw111 5/17》What it actually means is that the rate at which plants remove CO2 from the atmosphere has continued to accelerate, but they think it accelerated by slightly less than expected.

@thinks_about_it @mel_wright123 @Willard1951 @Gordon_DHG @rdqBlueRidge @robhon_ @AGWIsHappening @IceAge2150 @Gladfly1 @ScienceBlog3 @MartinJBern @TWTThisIsNow @Moderna5G_666 @Canadianworker2 @RushhourP @AristotleMrs @insane_voice @Narvuntien @RidaAller @Nockit1 @Tempora23227548 @JohnGiuliano7 @GeraldKutney @TheDisproof @BL4CKsH33P6 @Climatehope2 @25_cycle @Ceist8 @crankyfucker @cjtjgeol @1Astroturf @claude_roumain @sapp_erlot @Michael71718318 @Robert76907841 @ejwwest @CloneDwarf @WinWithScience @Hedendom @Barbarajdurkin @RoyPentland @TinTincognito @Robin_Hagues @JohnnyD93941059 @USCriticalMess @MikeDel21893959 @Michael_D_Crow @gptnshl @Tony__Heller @JoeShaw111 6/17》Do you think I'm kidding? You can't glean that fact from the abstract, it is only to be found in the paywalled article. Email me if you want me to send you a copy.

@thinks_about_it @mel_wright123 @Willard1951 @Gordon_DHG @rdqBlueRidge @robhon_ @AGWIsHappening @IceAge2150 @Gladfly1 @ScienceBlog3 @MartinJBern @TWTThisIsNow @Moderna5G_666 @Canadianworker2 @RushhourP @AristotleMrs @insane_voice @Narvuntien @RidaAller @Nockit1 @Tempora23227548 @JohnGiuliano7 @GeraldKutney @TheDisproof @BL4CKsH33P6 @Climatehope2 @25_cycle @Ceist8 @crankyfucker @cjtjgeol @1Astroturf @claude_roumain @sapp_erlot @Michael71718318 @Robert76907841 @ejwwest @CloneDwarf @WinWithScience @Hedendom @Barbarajdurkin @RoyPentland @TinTincognito @Robin_Hagues @JohnnyD93941059 @USCriticalMess @MikeDel21893959 @Michael_D_Crow @gptnshl @Tony__Heller @JoeShaw111 7/17》It is disheartening that such drek can get published anywhere, let alone in Science Magazine. It used to be so much better.

@thinks_about_it @mel_wright123 @Willard1951 @Gordon_DHG @rdqBlueRidge @robhon_ @AGWIsHappening @IceAge2150 @Gladfly1 @ScienceBlog3 @MartinJBern @TWTThisIsNow @Moderna5G_666 @Canadianworker2 @RushhourP @AristotleMrs @insane_voice @Narvuntien @RidaAller @Nockit1 @Tempora23227548 @JohnGiuliano7 @GeraldKutney @TheDisproof @BL4CKsH33P6 @Climatehope2 @25_cycle @Ceist8 @crankyfucker @cjtjgeol @1Astroturf @claude_roumain @sapp_erlot @Michael71718318 @Robert76907841 @ejwwest @CloneDwarf @WinWithScience @Hedendom @Barbarajdurkin @RoyPentland @TinTincognito @Robin_Hagues @JohnnyD93941059 @USCriticalMess @MikeDel21893959 @Michael_D_Crow @gptnshl @Tony__Heller @JoeShaw111 8/17》The new AR6 WG1 Report has many severe problems (and WG2 & WG3 are sure to be even worse!), and the science reported by AR6 WG1 is heavily distorted by leftist politics, but even they accept that "carbon fertilization" (greening) has continued to accelerate.

@thinks_about_it @mel_wright123 @Willard1951 @Gordon_DHG @rdqBlueRidge @robhon_ @AGWIsHappening @IceAge2150 @Gladfly1 @ScienceBlog3 @MartinJBern @TWTThisIsNow @Moderna5G_666 @Canadianworker2 @RushhourP @AristotleMrs @insane_voice @Narvuntien @RidaAller @Nockit1 @Tempora23227548 @JohnGiuliano7 @GeraldKutney @TheDisproof @BL4CKsH33P6 @Climatehope2 @25_cycle @Ceist8 @crankyfucker @cjtjgeol @1Astroturf @claude_roumain @sapp_erlot @Michael71718318 @Robert76907841 @ejwwest @CloneDwarf @WinWithScience @Hedendom @Barbarajdurkin @RoyPentland @TinTincognito @Robin_Hagues @JohnnyD93941059 @USCriticalMess @MikeDel21893959 @Michael_D_Crow @gptnshl @Tony__Heller @JoeShaw111 9/17》The AR6 WG1 Report confirms that the natural negative feedbacks which remove CO2 from the atmosphere at an accelerating pace, including "carbon fertilization" (greening), have not slowed (though they "expect" it to do so eventually).
ipcc.ch/report/ar6/wg1…

@thinks_about_it @mel_wright123 @Willard1951 @Gordon_DHG @rdqBlueRidge @robhon_ @AGWIsHappening @IceAge2150 @Gladfly1 @ScienceBlog3 @MartinJBern @TWTThisIsNow @Moderna5G_666 @Canadianworker2 @RushhourP @AristotleMrs @insane_voice @Narvuntien @RidaAller @Nockit1 @Tempora23227548 @JohnGiuliano7 @GeraldKutney @TheDisproof @BL4CKsH33P6 @Climatehope2 @25_cycle @Ceist8 @crankyfucker @cjtjgeol @1Astroturf @claude_roumain @sapp_erlot @Michael71718318 @Robert76907841 @ejwwest @CloneDwarf @WinWithScience @Hedendom @Barbarajdurkin @RoyPentland @TinTincognito @Robin_Hagues @JohnnyD93941059 @USCriticalMess @MikeDel21893959 @Michael_D_Crow @gptnshl @Tony__Heller @JoeShaw111 10/17》(Actually, they should've stopped after the word "no." The rest of that sentence is just plain wrong, because carbon sinks remove CO2 which is already in the air, not some "fraction of emissions," and the last sentence is just speculation. But the word "no" is correct.)

@thinks_about_it @mel_wright123 @Willard1951 @Gordon_DHG @rdqBlueRidge @robhon_ @AGWIsHappening @IceAge2150 @Gladfly1 @ScienceBlog3 @MartinJBern @TWTThisIsNow @Moderna5G_666 @Canadianworker2 @RushhourP @AristotleMrs @insane_voice @Narvuntien @RidaAller @Nockit1 @Tempora23227548 @JohnGiuliano7 @GeraldKutney @TheDisproof @BL4CKsH33P6 @Climatehope2 @25_cycle @Ceist8 @crankyfucker @cjtjgeol @1Astroturf @claude_roumain @sapp_erlot @Michael71718318 @Robert76907841 @ejwwest @CloneDwarf @WinWithScience @Hedendom @Barbarajdurkin @RoyPentland @TinTincognito @Robin_Hagues @JohnnyD93941059 @USCriticalMess @MikeDel21893959 @Michael_D_Crow @gptnshl @Tony__Heller @JoeShaw111 11/17》Here are the AR6 WG1 figures for four decades of CO2 uptake by "carbon sinks."

Decade:
1980s ⇒ 1990s ⇒ 2000s ⇒ 2010s
Ocean sink:
1.7 ⇒ 2.0 ⇒ 2.1 ⇒ 2.5 PgC/yr
Terrestrial sink ("greening," mostly induced by carbon fertilization):
2.0 ⇒ 2.6 ⇒ 2.9 ⇒ 3.4 PgC/yr

@thinks_about_it @mel_wright123 @Willard1951 @Gordon_DHG @rdqBlueRidge @robhon_ @AGWIsHappening @IceAge2150 @Gladfly1 @ScienceBlog3 @MartinJBern @TWTThisIsNow @Moderna5G_666 @Canadianworker2 @RushhourP @AristotleMrs @insane_voice @Narvuntien @RidaAller @Nockit1 @Tempora23227548 @JohnGiuliano7 @GeraldKutney @TheDisproof @BL4CKsH33P6 @Climatehope2 @25_cycle @Ceist8 @crankyfucker @cjtjgeol @1Astroturf @claude_roumain @sapp_erlot @Michael71718318 @Robert76907841 @ejwwest @CloneDwarf @WinWithScience @Hedendom @Barbarajdurkin @RoyPentland @TinTincognito @Robin_Hagues @JohnnyD93941059 @USCriticalMess @MikeDel21893959 @Michael_D_Crow @gptnshl @Tony__Heller @JoeShaw111 12/17》The figures are copied from Table 5.1 of AR6:
ipcc.ch/report/ar6/wg1…

Here's a copy of the table, followed by just the relevant bit excerpted from it ("Carbon Flux Comparison"):
sealevel.info/AR6_WG1_Table_… (click the link to enlarge):

@thinks_about_it @mel_wright123 @Willard1951 @Gordon_DHG @rdqBlueRidge @robhon_ @AGWIsHappening @IceAge2150 @Gladfly1 @ScienceBlog3 @MartinJBern @TWTThisIsNow @Moderna5G_666 @Canadianworker2 @RushhourP @AristotleMrs @insane_voice @Narvuntien @RidaAller @Nockit1 @Tempora23227548 @JohnGiuliano7 @GeraldKutney @TheDisproof @BL4CKsH33P6 @Climatehope2 @25_cycle @Ceist8 @crankyfucker @cjtjgeol @1Astroturf @claude_roumain @sapp_erlot @Michael71718318 @Robert76907841 @ejwwest @CloneDwarf @WinWithScience @Hedendom @Barbarajdurkin @RoyPentland @TinTincognito @Robin_Hagues @JohnnyD93941059 @USCriticalMess @MikeDel21893959 @Michael_D_Crow @gptnshl @Tony__Heller @JoeShaw111 13/17》Here's a zoomed-in excerpt:
sealevel.info/AR6_WG1_Table_…

Believe it or not, some climate activists even try to spin those figures as meaning that carbon sinks are shrinking. I'm not kidding!

@thinks_about_it @mel_wright123 @Willard1951 @Gordon_DHG @rdqBlueRidge @robhon_ @AGWIsHappening @IceAge2150 @Gladfly1 @ScienceBlog3 @MartinJBern @TWTThisIsNow @Moderna5G_666 @Canadianworker2 @RushhourP @AristotleMrs @insane_voice @Narvuntien @RidaAller @Nockit1 @Tempora23227548 @JohnGiuliano7 @GeraldKutney @TheDisproof @BL4CKsH33P6 @Climatehope2 @25_cycle @Ceist8 @crankyfucker @cjtjgeol @1Astroturf @claude_roumain @sapp_erlot @Michael71718318 @Robert76907841 @ejwwest @CloneDwarf @WinWithScience @Hedendom @Barbarajdurkin @RoyPentland @TinTincognito @Robin_Hagues @JohnnyD93941059 @USCriticalMess @MikeDel21893959 @Michael_D_Crow @gptnshl @Tony__Heller @JoeShaw111 14/17》Typically they note that mankind's CO2 emissions have increased faster than natural removals, and pretend that means removal rates are in some sense slowing. (Yes, that's every bit as idiotic as it sounds.)

@thinks_about_it @mel_wright123 @Willard1951 @Gordon_DHG @rdqBlueRidge @robhon_ @AGWIsHappening @IceAge2150 @Gladfly1 @ScienceBlog3 @MartinJBern @TWTThisIsNow @Moderna5G_666 @Canadianworker2 @RushhourP @AristotleMrs @insane_voice @Narvuntien @RidaAller @Nockit1 @Tempora23227548 @JohnGiuliano7 @GeraldKutney @TheDisproof @BL4CKsH33P6 @Climatehope2 @25_cycle @Ceist8 @crankyfucker @cjtjgeol @1Astroturf @claude_roumain @sapp_erlot @Michael71718318 @Robert76907841 @ejwwest @CloneDwarf @WinWithScience @Hedendom @Barbarajdurkin @RoyPentland @TinTincognito @Robin_Hagues @JohnnyD93941059 @USCriticalMess @MikeDel21893959 @Michael_D_Crow @gptnshl @Tony__Heller @JoeShaw111 15/17》Climate activists also hype any short-term fluctuation in a statistic which supports their narrative (while resolutely ignoring the opposite fluctuations). They do it with sea-level, with polar ice extent, and with just about everything else — including CO2 removals.

@thinks_about_it @mel_wright123 @Willard1951 @Gordon_DHG @rdqBlueRidge @robhon_ @AGWIsHappening @IceAge2150 @Gladfly1 @ScienceBlog3 @MartinJBern @TWTThisIsNow @Moderna5G_666 @Canadianworker2 @RushhourP @AristotleMrs @insane_voice @Narvuntien @RidaAller @Nockit1 @Tempora23227548 @JohnGiuliano7 @GeraldKutney @TheDisproof @BL4CKsH33P6 @Climatehope2 @25_cycle @Ceist8 @crankyfucker @cjtjgeol @1Astroturf @claude_roumain @sapp_erlot @Michael71718318 @Robert76907841 @ejwwest @CloneDwarf @WinWithScience @Hedendom @Barbarajdurkin @RoyPentland @TinTincognito @Robin_Hagues @JohnnyD93941059 @USCriticalMess @MikeDel21893959 @Michael_D_Crow @gptnshl @Tony__Heller @JoeShaw111 16/17》For example, here's a graph from AR6. The blue & red captions at the top, and the flashing orange zoomed-in box, are my added annotations. (The big grey diagonal background text is a fragment of this stamp, "ACCEPTED VERSION SUBJECT TO FINAL EDITS")
sealevel.info/AR6_FAQ_5p1_Fi…

@thinks_about_it @mel_wright123 @Willard1951 @Gordon_DHG @rdqBlueRidge @robhon_ @AGWIsHappening @IceAge2150 @Gladfly1 @ScienceBlog3 @MartinJBern @TWTThisIsNow @Moderna5G_666 @Canadianworker2 @RushhourP @AristotleMrs @insane_voice @Narvuntien @RidaAller @Nockit1 @Tempora23227548 @JohnGiuliano7 @GeraldKutney @TheDisproof @BL4CKsH33P6 @Climatehope2 @25_cycle @Ceist8 @crankyfucker @cjtjgeol @1Astroturf @claude_roumain @sapp_erlot @Michael71718318 @Robert76907841 @ejwwest @CloneDwarf @WinWithScience @Hedendom @Barbarajdurkin @RoyPentland @TinTincognito @Robin_Hagues @JohnnyD93941059 @USCriticalMess @MikeDel21893959 @Michael_D_Crow @gptnshl @Tony__Heller @JoeShaw111 17/17》Climate activists are 100% about the spin, and 0% about the science.

If you want to learn about the science, instead of being misled by the spin, here's a list of high-quality resources:

@thinks_about_it @mel_wright123 @Willard1951 @Gordon_DHG @rdqBlueRidge @robhon_ @AGWIsHappening @IceAge2150 @Gladfly1 @ScienceBlog3 @MartinJBern @TWTThisIsNow @Moderna5G_666 @Canadianworker2 @RushhourP @AristotleMrs @insane_voice @Narvuntien @RidaAller @Nockit1 @Tempora23227548 @JohnGiuliano7 @GeraldKutney @TheDisproof @BL4CKsH33P6 @Climatehope2 @25_cycle @Ceist8 @crankyfucker @cjtjgeol @1Astroturf @claude_roumain @sapp_erlot @Michael71718318 @Robert76907841 @ejwwest @CloneDwarf @WinWithScience @Hedendom @Barbarajdurkin @RoyPentland @TinTincognito @Robin_Hagues @JohnnyD93941059 @USCriticalMess @MikeDel21893959 @Michael_D_Crow @gptnshl @rattibha @Rattibha (2nd try) unroll/compile