Thread by @ncdave4life

@Veritatem2021 @mentalmal1 @Willard1951 @IanHugh07940666 @alison_pannell @richietrailer @glinch72 @WillWat6 @CallidusDominus @3GHtweets @MAGA_Translator @TWTThisIsNow @KCTaz @0Sundance @AristotleMrs @TheDisproof @Ceist8 @TullimonstrumC @Jaisans @glehman11 @drochir_thonnuk @JimBowersclimb @AlexVickeryHowe @atherton_chris @ItsTheAtmospher @Climatehope2 @DGinCheshire @BointonGiles @Mark_A_Lunn @AuroriaTwittori @RushhourP @MartinJBern @EthonRaptor @Anvndarnamn5 @gstrandberg1 @Jakegsm @ammocrypta @EricWil06256732 @DTGvmd @wille99 @PaulDFarrar @Data79504085 @Hji45519156 @Valja46Zhark5 @paulp1232 @ShroedingerBird @J0aquIm_B4rb0s4 @Sky48115666 @BradPKeyes @DoesThisW0rk 1/7》
Proof that the CO2 increase is 100% manmade has nothing to do isotopes, because carbon is constantly being swapped between "reservoirs," which dilutes atmospheric isotopic signatures.

We have good data (I'm using 2021) showing, beyond serious dispute, that since 1958:

@Veritatem2021 @mentalmal1 @Willard1951 @IanHugh07940666 @alison_pannell @richietrailer @glinch72 @WillWat6 @CallidusDominus @3GHtweets @MAGA_Translator @TWTThisIsNow @KCTaz @0Sundance @AristotleMrs @TheDisproof @Ceist8 @TullimonstrumC @Jaisans @glehman11 @drochir_thonnuk @JimBowersclimb @AlexVickeryHowe @atherton_chris @ItsTheAtmospher @Climatehope2 @DGinCheshire @BointonGiles @Mark_A_Lunn @AuroriaTwittori @RushhourP @MartinJBern @EthonRaptor @Anvndarnamn5 @gstrandberg1 @Jakegsm @ammocrypta @EricWil06256732 @DTGvmd @wille99 @PaulDFarrar @Data79504085 @Hji45519156 @Valja46Zhark5 @paulp1232 @ShroedingerBird @J0aquIm_B4rb0s4 @Sky48115666 @BradPKeyes @DoesThisW0rk 2/7》
● Mankind has added about 1440 Gt (180 ppmv) of CO2 to the atmosphere. We know that because we know, quite closely, how much coal, oil & natural gas has been burned, and how much concrete has been manufactured, and how much CO2 that produces:
sealevel.info/global.1751_20…

@Veritatem2021 @mentalmal1 @Willard1951 @IanHugh07940666 @alison_pannell @richietrailer @glinch72 @WillWat6 @CallidusDominus @3GHtweets @MAGA_Translator @TWTThisIsNow @KCTaz @0Sundance @AristotleMrs @TheDisproof @Ceist8 @TullimonstrumC @Jaisans @glehman11 @drochir_thonnuk @JimBowersclimb @AlexVickeryHowe @atherton_chris @ItsTheAtmospher @Climatehope2 @DGinCheshire @BointonGiles @Mark_A_Lunn @AuroriaTwittori @RushhourP @MartinJBern @EthonRaptor @Anvndarnamn5 @gstrandberg1 @Jakegsm @ammocrypta @EricWil06256732 @DTGvmd @wille99 @PaulDFarrar @Data79504085 @Hji45519156 @Valja46Zhark5 @paulp1232 @ShroedingerBird @J0aquIm_B4rb0s4 @Sky48115666 @BradPKeyes @DoesThisW0rk 3/7》
● The amount of CO2 in the atmosphere has increased by only about 808 Gt (101 ppmv). That's from precise measurements taken at Mauna Loa since 1958 (and also confirmed for more recent years with precise measurements taken in other places).
sealevel.info/co2.html

@Veritatem2021 @mentalmal1 @Willard1951 @IanHugh07940666 @alison_pannell @richietrailer @glinch72 @WillWat6 @CallidusDominus @3GHtweets @MAGA_Translator @TWTThisIsNow @KCTaz @0Sundance @AristotleMrs @TheDisproof @Ceist8 @TullimonstrumC @Jaisans @glehman11 @drochir_thonnuk @JimBowersclimb @AlexVickeryHowe @atherton_chris @ItsTheAtmospher @Climatehope2 @DGinCheshire @BointonGiles @Mark_A_Lunn @AuroriaTwittori @RushhourP @MartinJBern @EthonRaptor @Anvndarnamn5 @gstrandberg1 @Jakegsm @ammocrypta @EricWil06256732 @DTGvmd @wille99 @PaulDFarrar @Data79504085 @Hji45519156 @Valja46Zhark5 @paulp1232 @ShroedingerBird @J0aquIm_B4rb0s4 @Sky48115666 @BradPKeyes @DoesThisW0rk 4/7》
The difference is (1440 - 808) = 632 Gt = 79 ppmv CO2. That's the net sum of all the non-anthropogenic CO2 fluxes, in both directions: a net 𝙧𝙚𝙢𝙤𝙫𝙖𝙡 of 79 ppmv of CO2 from the atmosphere, by nature. ("Non-anthropogenic" is what we call "nature.")

@Veritatem2021 @mentalmal1 @Willard1951 @IanHugh07940666 @alison_pannell @richietrailer @glinch72 @WillWat6 @CallidusDominus @3GHtweets @MAGA_Translator @TWTThisIsNow @KCTaz @0Sundance @AristotleMrs @TheDisproof @Ceist8 @TullimonstrumC @Jaisans @glehman11 @drochir_thonnuk @JimBowersclimb @AlexVickeryHowe @atherton_chris @ItsTheAtmospher @Climatehope2 @DGinCheshire @BointonGiles @Mark_A_Lunn @AuroriaTwittori @RushhourP @MartinJBern @EthonRaptor @Anvndarnamn5 @gstrandberg1 @Jakegsm @ammocrypta @EricWil06256732 @DTGvmd @wille99 @PaulDFarrar @Data79504085 @Hji45519156 @Valja46Zhark5 @paulp1232 @ShroedingerBird @J0aquIm_B4rb0s4 @Sky48115666 @BradPKeyes @DoesThisW0rk 5/7》

Mankind added 180 ppmv of CO2 to the atmosphere.

But the measured increase is only 101 ppmv.

So nature removed (180 - 101) = 79 ppmv.

@Veritatem2021 @mentalmal1 @Willard1951 @IanHugh07940666 @alison_pannell @richietrailer @glinch72 @WillWat6 @CallidusDominus @3GHtweets @MAGA_Translator @TWTThisIsNow @KCTaz @0Sundance @AristotleMrs @TheDisproof @Ceist8 @TullimonstrumC @Jaisans @glehman11 @drochir_thonnuk @JimBowersclimb @AlexVickeryHowe @atherton_chris @ItsTheAtmospher @Climatehope2 @DGinCheshire @BointonGiles @Mark_A_Lunn @AuroriaTwittori @RushhourP @MartinJBern @EthonRaptor @Anvndarnamn5 @gstrandberg1 @Jakegsm @ammocrypta @EricWil06256732 @DTGvmd @wille99 @PaulDFarrar @Data79504085 @Hji45519156 @Valja46Zhark5 @paulp1232 @ShroedingerBird @J0aquIm_B4rb0s4 @Sky48115666 @BradPKeyes @DoesThisW0rk 6/7》
∴ Nature has reduced (not increased!) the amount of CO2 in the atmosphere by a net sum of 79 ppmv since 1958. That means claims that nature is responsible for any part of the increase in atmospheric CO2 concentration since 1958 are wrong.

@Veritatem2021 @mentalmal1 @Willard1951 @IanHugh07940666 @alison_pannell @richietrailer @glinch72 @WillWat6 @CallidusDominus @3GHtweets @MAGA_Translator @TWTThisIsNow @KCTaz @0Sundance @AristotleMrs @TheDisproof @Ceist8 @TullimonstrumC @Jaisans @glehman11 @drochir_thonnuk @JimBowersclimb @AlexVickeryHowe @atherton_chris @ItsTheAtmospher @Climatehope2 @DGinCheshire @BointonGiles @Mark_A_Lunn @AuroriaTwittori @RushhourP @MartinJBern @EthonRaptor @Anvndarnamn5 @gstrandberg1 @Jakegsm @ammocrypta @EricWil06256732 @DTGvmd @wille99 @PaulDFarrar @Data79504085 @Hji45519156 @Valja46Zhark5 @paulp1232 @ShroedingerBird @J0aquIm_B4rb0s4 7/7》
𝐐: That's the answer to this question: "What has caused the 101 ppmv measured increase in the amount of CO2 in the atmosphere since 1958?"

𝐀: The short answer is: It was caused entirely by human CO2 emissions.

@threadreaderapp @rattibha @threaddotblue unroll