Foundation For Freedom Online Profile picture
Protecting digital liberties. Telling the story of online censorship. Fighting to win back the Golden Age of the Internet. Posts by @MikeBenzCyber.

Nov 10, 2022, 16 tweets

DHS censorship machine targeted 22 million tweets, used 120 speech flaggers, scrubbed 15 platforms, and throttled dozens of "emerging election narratives" using a chat app.

#DHSLeaks was just the tip of an iceberg. Full report here:

foundationforfreedomonline.com/11-9-22.html

2. Here is a highly disturbing fact that is not widely to the American public: The same DHS cyber agency in charge of securing elections is also in charge of censoring elections.

3. CISA has kept a very low profile by appearing to the outside world as just a boring cybersecurity bureau. A place where even the professional hackers are tasked with humdrum IT maintenance jobs.

4. In the summer of 2020, CISA pulled off a trick. By classifying "election misinformation" as threat to "election security," its police powers extended from the tech side of elections to anyone simply *talking* about elections.

5. But CISA had a problem. It's called the First Amendment. The US government is not allowed to sandblast millions of voters off the civilian Internet because of their speech about elections.

CISA needed private sector partners to do dirty work. And that's where EIP stepped in:

6. CISA "lacked the funding and the legal authorizations" to do grand-scale censorship and get away with it. So CISA partnered with EIP, who "filled the gap of the things that the government could not do themselves."

7. EIP bills itself euphemistically as a "disinfo research” collective, but it's important to understand EIP does more than “research”: they manually flag posts, throttle narratives, and pressure platforms at every level.

That is active censorship, not passive research:

8. CISA -- your federal government -- is not just partnering with a few zealous individuals. The scale here is institutional. For the 2020 election alone, EIP had 120 people staffed on taking down lawful US citizen speech about an in-process US election:

9. This clip, one week after the 2020 election, shows EIP openly plotting ways to coerce tech platforms to censor additional topics beyond elections. EIP cited their power cards as "huge regulatory pressure" from government insiders and ginning up bad press:

10. EIP relies on advanced monitoring AI to map out entire networks of people who spread a narrative they want to ban out of existence. Here you can see a walkthrough of how EIP effectively stalks every chain in an election belief to censor the whole belief system at scale:

11. In this photo, DHS, EIP and the tech platforms are all coordinating systematic censorship of US citizen speech, in the heat of an election, that voiced concerns about being given sharpie markers to vote.

Look how they secretly clamped a speech ban behind the scenes:

12. Notice the redacted “Government partner” didn't even fully dispel the narrative being throttled for “misinformation.” They actually appear to somewhat confirm concerns about kicked-back ballots, but simply presume poll workers must have followed ideal procedures after that:

13. This whole seamless web of censorship was all planned months ahead of the 2020 election.

After partnering with DHS, EIP lined up all the major platforms in advance so EIP could "find disinformation and report it quickly and then collaborate with them on taking it down."

14. All of EIP's top targets of election censorship, during a hotly contested ongoing election, belonged to the exact same side of the political aisle.

CISA gave them absolute power to censor, so they censored absolutely:

15. The topics EIP censored on a day-by-day basis tracked perfectly with pre-censorship of challenges to a pending "red mirage, blue shift" scenario.

Right out gate, its #1 censorship topic was mail-in ballots, then hard-pivoted to censoring ballot counting on Election Day:

16. One of the explicit goals of their censorship activities, according to their own formal framework, was to stop people from being mobilized to put up legal challenges:

Share this Scrolly Tale with your friends.

A Scrolly Tale is a new way to read Twitter threads with a more visually immersive experience.
Discover more beautiful Scrolly Tales like this.

Keep scrolling