@StefJamieSan @Petergrmathews @tim_dunkerton Number one rule: don't listen to loud atmospheric physicists such as Dunkerton. They tend to mess things up
realclimate.org/index.php/arch…
@StefJamieSan @Petergrmathews @tim_dunkerton Too much fun, winning is not boring at all.
Improved over Lindzen, yet not even close to admitting that lunar cycles w/annual drive the EXACT synching of QBO. And that's what's important for predictions.
@StefJamieSan @Petergrmathews @tim_dunkerton Doesn't matter, as doubling down on an incorrect model just exposes its faults. A better model should explain the anomalous points as well.
@StefJamieSan @Petergrmathews @tim_dunkerton No one complains about the overfitting performed for next week's solar eclipse. It's whether it works or not.
@StefJamieSan @Petergrmathews @tim_dunkerton Only the draconic cycles impact a wavenumber=0 behavior, and those cycles don't impact LOD. Yes, they impact Chandler wobble. This is masterful geophysics described on the recent blog post:
geoenergymath.com/2024/03/25/pro…
@StefJamieSan @Petergrmathews @tim_dunkerton Doesn't seem to understand that LOD is a solid body response, not a fluid. The solid body is not uniform, featuring continents & mountain ranges, providing spatially resolved moments of inertia for the lunar gravity to torque on. Let ChatGPT teach you:
chat.openai.com/share/8bad18e1…
@StefJamieSan @Petergrmathews @tim_dunkerton He complains when he isn't precise enough. Solid body is different than solid body response.
@StefJamieSan @Petergrmathews @tim_dunkerton So now he wants to know how to solve Laplace's Tidal Equations on an equatorial waveguide, where the Coriolis force vanishes. The interface properties of a topological insulator emerge -- ask Marston of APS about the viability of such a behavior
@StefJamieSan @Petergrmathews @tim_dunkerton Hough functions are simply dispersion relationships on a sphere -- they've nothing to do with what gets selected. A wave incident at a right angle to the equator will generate an infinite phase speed wave along the waveguide, much like a boundary Kelvin wave along a shoreline.
@StefJamieSan @Petergrmathews @tim_dunkerton Now the connection to a solid body response. Solid is rigid so torque at any longitude will ripple through as a wavenumber=0. However, for a compressible fluid like air, every longitudinal line must act in UNISON for a WN=0, thus the nodal alignment independent of longitude.
@StefJamieSan @Petergrmathews @tim_dunkerton As I said, only a nodal wave such as the semiannual solar crossing or the draconic/nodal lunar crossing can generate a UNIFORM shear stress across the equatorial plane. If SAO sets the behavior, then the QBO must also exist for lunar forcing. No moon, then no QBO, only SAO.
@StefJamieSan @Petergrmathews @tim_dunkerton No controlled experiment to validate any of this Dunkerton spew. Instead, as Lindzen said, the onus is on the reviewing team to demonstrate that a draconic period of 27.2122 days CAN'T support the QBO cycle. Should be simple for you to debunk, after all it's just arithmetic ;)
@StefJamieSan @Petergrmathews @tim_dunkerton Yes, I don't claim that as a discovery, but Dunkerton has now admitted that long period nodal forces drive these oscillations. Seasonal nodal for SAO and lunar nodal for QBO. No going back at this point.
Share this Scrolly Tale with your friends.
A Scrolly Tale is a new way to read Twitter threads with a more visually immersive experience.
Discover more beautiful Scrolly Tales like this.