Thread by @ginacostag_

Final interview.
They ask: “Why are you leaving your current job?”
Your mind blanks.

You say: “My manager is toxic.”
Interview ends. No offer.

Here's what they actually want to hear:

What they’re really asking

Not “Is your manager toxic?”

They’re asking:
- Are you leaving for the right reasons?
- Will you be hard to manage?
- Do you take accountability?
- Are you running from something… or moving toward something?
- Will you bring drama here?

They’re screening for emotional maturity, judgment, and how you handle conflict.

The rule:

Never trash your current job. Even if it’s true.

Because the interviewer hears:
- “They might say this about us later.”
- “They can’t handle feedback.”
- “They escalate instead of navigating.”
- “They’re focused on blame.”

You can be honest without being explosive.

The winning framework (simple)

A strong answer hits 4 points:

1. Gratitude (signals professionalism)
2. What you learned / delivered (signals competence)
3. Why it’s time to move on (neutral, forward-looking)
4. Why this role (shows intention, not desperation)

Think: past → progress → pull toward next

High-impact templates you can copy:

Option 1: “Growth & scope”

“I’m grateful for what I’ve learned in my current role, especially around [skill/area]. Over time, I’ve realized I’m ready for a position with more focus on [X], and more opportunity to [lead/build/own]. When I saw this role, it matched exactly the direction I want to grow in, so I decided to explore it seriously.”

Option 2: “Misalignment (without blame)”

“I’ve done good work in my current position and learned a lot, but the role has shifted in a direction that’s less aligned with where I want to take my career, more toward [A] and less toward [B]. I’m looking for a role where I can spend most of my time on [B], which is why this opportunity stood out.”

Option 3: “Looking for better environment (coded, mature)”

“I’m proud of what I’ve accomplished where I am, and I’m leaving because I’m looking for an environment with strong communication, clear priorities, and high accountability. I do my best work when expectations are clear and feedback is direct. From what I’ve seen, your team seems to operate that way.”

Option 4: “Stalled progression”

“I’ve grown a lot in the role, but the next step internally isn’t clear right now, the scope and progression I’m looking for just isn’t available in the near term. I’m ready for a role where I can [own X / lead Y / build Z], and that’s what I’m excited about here.”

Option 5: “Reorg / strategy change”

“After some changes in the organization, my role is becoming more focused on [new focus], and less on [what you want]. I’m looking for a role that’s consistently centered on [what you want], which is why I’m exploring opportunities like this.”

Option 6: “Values”

“I want to work somewhere that prioritizes [quality/customer outcomes/ownership/craft/learning]. I’ve learned a lot in my current role, but I’m ready to move to a team where those values are more central day-to-day. What attracted me here is [specific thing about role/team].”

If they push: “So what’s wrong with your current job?”

Use this line:

“It’s simply a fit and timing decision, I’m looking for [X], and this role aligns strongly with that.”

Then redirect to:
- the role you want
- the impact you’ll make
- what you’re excited to build

How to reference a toxic manager (without saying it)

These are “safe translations”:

Instead of “My manager is toxic” say:

- “I’m looking for a team with clearer communication and expectations.”
- “I’m seeking a more consistent feedback culture.”
- “I do best with alignment on priorities and decision-making.”
- “I’m looking for an environment with strong collaboration and accountability.”

You’re telling the truth, just in language that sounds stable and hireable.

The best version (the one that wins offers)

This is the structure that lands well almost anywhere:

“I’ve learned a lot in my current role and I’m proud of what I’ve delivered, especially [1–2 wins]. At this point, I’m ready to focus more on [what you want next], and there isn’t a clear path to that scope where I am. This role stood out because [specific reason], and I’m excited about the chance to contribute by [how you’ll add value].”

Don’t say “my manager is toxic”, even if it’s true.

It puts the spotlight on conflict.

You’re not just answering “why are you leaving?”
You’re proving you can handle pressure without making it messy.

So don’t talk about your manager. Talk about your direction:

“I’ve learned a lot here and I’m proud of what I’ve done.
Now I’m looking for new challenges, bigger projects, and more scope,
this role aligns with how I want to grow.”

Future-focused = hireable.

Get FREE AI Guides ↓
joinhorizon.ai/subscribe?utm_…

That's a wrap!

Follow @ginacostag_ for more threads like this

Was this helpful? 💜Like/RT the first tweet to show your support!👇