Thread by @CharlieHowarth1

@MonkEmma Let's debunk Emma's "debunking".

Emma claims the document is about the sensitivities of all religions and not just Islam. She implies that a Jehovah's Witness not liking competitive sport is just the same as a Muslim child not wanting to draw humans.

But is it?

@MonkEmma Do we have any evidence of Jehovah's Witnesses demanding schools give up competitive sports to accommodate them?

My religious upbringing similarly discouraged competitive sports. Did my parents ever demand the school change their curriculum to accommodate me? No, of course not

@MonkEmma Would a Muslim parent demand that the school change their lessons so as not to draw Mohammed or Jesus, or possibly any human? Almost certainly, yes.

@MonkEmma We know this because the Batley School Grammar teacher who showed children an image of Mohammed is still in hiding. Asking a child to draw Mohammed would be an even worse offence.

@MonkEmma So the purpose of the guidance document is to relativise Islamic demands for certain things by comparing them with other cultures' sensitivities.

This is a strawman, because the evidence for these other cultures demanding their sensitivities are respected is incredibly weak.