While hundreds of thousands were killed, enslaved, or fled, a significant Jewish population never left. They shifted from Judea north to the Galilee, where Jewish scholars compiled the Mishna and the Jerusalem Talmud—the very foundations of Rabbinic Judaism.
Over the next 1,500 years, through Byzantine rule, Arab conquests, Crusades & Ottoman rule, indigenous Jews remained, dressed like their neighbors, spoke Arabic as their primary language, understood local laws & fiercely maintained their Jewish identity and religious practices.
They came to be known as the Musta'arabim (meaning "those who live among the Arabs" or "Arabized Jews"). When waves of Sephardic Jews arrived after the Spanish Expulsion in 1492, they documented encountering this well-established, native Jewish population.
There are documented Jewish families whose lineages in the region are unbroken, stretching back to antiquity. Historically, these families lived in ancient agricultural villages in the Galilee (Peki'in, Kafr Yasif, Alma, etc) & holy centers (Jerusalem, Hebron, Safed, Tiberias)
The most famous & indisputable example is the Zinati family of Peki'in, a village in northern Israel. The Zinati family has documented roots in Peki'in that trace directly back to the Second Temple period recognized as the Jewish family who never left the land since ancient times
In the 1920s & 30s, Yitzhak Ben-Zvi (who became Israel’s second president, a dedicated historian) traveled to remote Galilean villages. He extensively interviewed and documented the genealogies of the Zinati family and others, confirming their ancient, unbroken ties to the land.
Margalit Zinati, born in 1927, became a famous historical figure in Israel as the literal "last guardian" of this unbroken line, living her entire life in Peki'in maintaining the village's ancient synagogue.
Several Sephardic and Rabbinic families who arrived shortly after the Spanish Expulsion (Meyuhas, Eliachar, and Mani families) have meticulously preserved family trees showing over 500 years of continuous residence in cities like Jerusalem and Hebron
the chain of Jewish physical presence in the land of Israel was never broken. Small, highly resilient communities & families successfully endured centuries of shifting empires, restrictive laws, & conflicts were indigenous Musta'arab populations who had been there for centuries
Share this Scrolly Tale with your friends.
A Scrolly Tale is a new way to read Twitter threads with a more visually immersive experience.
Discover more beautiful Scrolly Tales like this.