She was very specific about the date and time. It was 9/28, between 4 and 6pm.
It was not Paddock. She was mistaken.
It was at the point that the man selling illegal gun stuff in a dark parking lot became uncooperative that Paddock started spouting stuff that, stereotypically, one might imagine people who sell illegal gun stuff in dark parking lots might embrace
Which option is more likely? A) That the introvert who is so secretive and reserved that not even his friends know his politics suddenly opened up to a complete stranger in a dark parking lot who had just refused his request.