The media tour promises me this is a ‘policy’ book.

Given I’ve taken issue with Barnaby’s policy stands in the past (particularly his claimed powers to control commodity prices) I thought I’d give this a read & try to engage with the content.

Will thread observations here👇
First observation is that this is the first policy tome I’ve read that’s plastic sealed.
Barnaby seems to be having a crack at people airport bookstores for thinking above their station in this par - which is a weird set up for this comment about the quality of regional public schools...
Disclosure - I went to state schools in regional Australia growing up and have also been known to shop in airport book stores.

I’m not sure where that leaves me in Barnaby’s class system.
I am of course now waiting in anticipation for the chapter where Barnaby recents from his support for cutting billions from needs based school funding in Australia - and the impact of this on “Turdsville State”.
Getting the identity politics in early here - regional schools aren’t adequately funded because Australia doesn’t care about “poor whites” apparently.

1. The kids doing it toughest at the regional state schools I went to were largely indigenous.
2. The ABC was a way of life where I grew up because it was the ONLY media organisation that covered the issues affecting rural and regional Australia in depth.

3. Haven’t Barnaby and the Nats represented these areas for decades? What have they been doing?
🤔
No.
I don’t even know what to do with this. We forget April, yet we desire it. #desireforapril
Barnaby says the town of Danglemah means ‘long-tailed goanna’ ‘to his best deduction’ but ‘that part of the Aboriginal language and history is lost’.

Given that he doesn’t seem to have asked any local indigenous people about this, can anyone fact check this?
Despite bagging the ABC pages earlier, Barnaby recalls that the ABC was the only television station that broadcast to his childhood home.
The relative social status of the people Barnaby writes about suffuses every page of this book - he’s truly obsessed with the idea that everyone (in RARA as well as the cities) is looking down on anyone who doesn’t earn as much as they do.
He claims solidarity with “A white tribe from a small country village”
A lot of talk about the importance of connection with place and the land (which I feel too).

But no mention of any indigenous Australians from those areas yet or what it might mean to them.
“Poor white village” references coming every seven pages so far
Barnaby’s primary school teacher at Woolbrook was a communist. No joke.
Apparently not all forms of multiculturalism are a problem for Barnaby.
Time for another black rat
A lot of stories about cars that Barnaby had that broke down.

None as good as the time I wrote off my Holden Sandman when I hit a kangaroo outside Goondiwindi at 4 in the morning.
That’s disappointing- only one paragraph on Barnaby’s failed period as Shadow Finance Minister for OL Tony Abbott.

No repetitions of his crazy predictions that Australia would default on its debt (despite it more than doubling since then).
He does see his time as Shadow Finance Minister being subject to a ‘media jihad’ though - which he intimates was encouraged Joe Hockey.
Conservatism according to Barnaby:

✅ “stability over desire”
✅ “maintaining the social contract of manners”
✅ “moderation”
✅ “self-discipline”

❌ “boring”
❌ “puritanical”
❌ “does not have to mean right wing”
Barnaby is unhappy with the quality of schools in rural and regional Australia but the only option he offers for improving them is funding private schools for ‘choice’ and ‘competition’.
Barnaby thinks private land tenure shouldn’t be impinged on by environmental regulations like land clearing bans and water management laws.
The point of this par on Australian educational standards is somewhat undermined by the editing.
Barnaby wants more Australians to study science - but he explicitly makes it clear that he does not want people studying climate change. Just science that has “immediate benefit or return from the land”.
Barnaby wants to use Canberra as “a template of how we can build other cities elsewhere”.

Wants a city of 100k between Darwin and Townsville and a ‘large city’ on our North-West Coast.
“Canberra only exists because people live there and most of them live there in their house.”
Without going into the weeds of the economics of FDI, there is at least one significant distinguishing factor between US, Japanese or Chinese interests purchasing Australian agricultural land and European colonisation of Hong Kong, India and Belgium....
Tapped the mat last night 3/4 though, but back this morning with a few more observations...
Genuine question - obviously the pejoratives Barnaby cites here aren’t equivalents to the n word, nor is the structural disadvantage of people in RARA analogous to that experienced by POC.

But as a factual matter are people from RARA ‘pilloried’ in the way Barnaby describes?
Barnaby says our nation is ‘failing’ disadvantaged people and ‘what a govt can do is create and architecture that promotes opportunities’ - agreed!

But he continually frames this as an issue for ‘white people in the country’..
Yet another “Poor white towns” reference - in my experience of RARA you don’t have to look too hard to find indigenous Australians in these communities.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Tim Watts MP

Tim Watts MP Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @TimWattsMP

Nov 8, 2021
Scott Morrison's short-term political interests have changed, so now he's claiming to have changed his position on electric vehicles.

He's visiting Toyota Altona in my electorate today to whitewash his record of lies & scaremongering on EVs

Here's the inconvenient history:
While he denies it now, in the last election Scott Morrison did say that electric vehicles would be the end of the weekend:
As always, this was just Scott Morrison pretending to be something that he isn't. People who know cars know that the instant torque offered by electric vehicles offers plenty of opportunity for excitement on the weekend. He's just a fake, fake, fake. theconversation.com/heres-why-elec…
Read 5 tweets
Nov 8, 2021
Today Scott Morrison is visiting Victoria for the first time in 173 days.

Extraordinarily he’s chosen to come to Toyota Altona in my electorate for a media event to do a backflip on his scaremongering about electric vehicles being the ‘end of the weekend’ in Australia.
It's the same Toyota Altona site where the policies of the Abbott-Turnbull-Morrison Govt cost 2500 jobs.

It’s just across the road from the Altona refinery where over 300 jobs were lost this year.

It’s just up the road from the Willy Shipyards, where 1500 jobs were lost.
Scott Morrison abandoned Victoria during the pandemic. But the policies of the Abbott-Turnbull-Morrison government have left us abandoned for 8 long years years.

This government has done nothing to fight for secure jobs in our community. We’ve seen the consequences first hand.
Read 4 tweets
Aug 27, 2021
In a cracking story, The @canberratimes has obtained a damning report on Scott Morrison’s bungled CovidSAFE App.

The Doherty model, & the PM’s reopening plan, relies heavily on ‘optimal testing, tracing, isolation & quarantine’.

Given that, this report is a must read 🧵👇
Some highlights of the report’s findings.

The report was finalised in March 2021, so doesn’t include the Delta out breaks.

But it’s clear that the CovidSAFE app was completely useless to contact tracers in the Victorian second wave.

It didn’t find a single close contact.
This was shortly after Scott Morrison described the CovidSAFE app as providing ‘protection’ like ‘putting on sunscreen’.
Read 12 tweets
Mar 27, 2021
Things that Scott Morrison HASN’T sacked MPs for - a thread:
Read 11 tweets
Mar 27, 2021
After 8 long years of Coalition government has decimated their front bench, this is what we are left with - Stuart Robert as the Minister with responsibility or cyber security.

A thread of the Master of Disaster’s tech policy highlights 🧵👇
That’s A LOT Of Internet

theguardian.com/australia-news…
That’s EVEN MORE Internet itnews.com.au/news/covidsafe…
Read 9 tweets
Mar 26, 2021
What is going on inside the Morrison Government on cyber security policy? The short answer is after eight years it’s a complete mess. The long answer is too long for a tweet, but I spoke on it in Parliament this week 👇🧵
parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/genpd…
The Morrison Govt has been so engulfed by its own sleaze and scandals it’s been distracted from this important national security issue in the face of the Hafnium and SolarWinds campaigns.
When the Exchange vulnerability became public:
-The Defence Min. was on leave
-The Acting Defence Min., also the Min. for Women, was in hiding from the media.
-The Asst Defence Min. still hadn't received his charter letter 3 months after his appointment.
theaustralian.com.au/nation/politic…
Read 7 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(