Well, there goes my day. 239 pages of federal document...

Let's discuss with #bioengineered hashtag. Start without me, I have a meeting soon.

[PDF] bit.ly/2QGH9gE
Pet food not included in label rule: "Therefore, although pet food and animal feed are “food” under the FDCA, such foods for animals are not covered by this regulation, pursuant to the amended Act. " pg 8. #bioengineered
"Other examples of “food” under the FDCA include dietary supplements, processing aids, and enzymes." pg 8. #bioengineered Oh, processing aids...does that mean enzymes like in cheese making...?
Pg 9. Multi-ingredient stuff has special rules. I will never understand this. #bioengineered
pg 11: must have DNA, I think? "foods with undetectable modified genetic material are not bioengineered foods" #bioengineered
pg 12: "For refined foods that are derived from bioengineered crops, no disclosure is required if the food does not contain detectable modified genetic material." So cheese prolly wouldn't...still digesting... #bioengineered
We have a list. We're checkin' it twice. We're gonna find out who is...wait, what section? #bioengineered
pg 21. "The following foods comprise the List of #Bioengineered Foods: alfalfa, apple (ArcticTM varieties), canola, corn, cotton, eggplant (BARI Bt Begun varieties), papaya (ringspot virus-resistant varieties), pineapple (pink flesh)..." Where can I get #GMO pineapple??
Pg 30. Yeasts, enzymes, microbes. #bioengineered
pg. 39 #Bioengineered Threshold will be 5%.
Ok, meeting over, getting back to this now. pg 49. I think this says QR codes and phone numbers are OK. And you can get texts about #bioengineered food. You cannot use "may be..." language.
pg 62: #bioengineered label can be done voluntarily, if desired.
#bioengineered pg 67: Enforcement. "records audits and examinations, hearings, and public disclosure of the summary of the results of audits, examinations, and similar activities". I think this means it's not via lawsuits and recalls, just paper pushing. But IANAL.
pg 70: mandatory compliance begins January 1 2022. #bioengineered
pg 77: #bioengineered Can't tell if something is BE if there's no DNA. Aligned with other countries, sugar and refined oils exempted from labels. And I heard heads asplode.
Pg 79: we're telling you again this has nothing to do with health claims, all the "food, including that produced through bioengineering, meets all relevant Federal health, safety, and environmental standards" #bioengineered
pg 81: I think this says it's not adding #CRISPR and editing to the definitions. #Bioengineered
Pg 87: #Bioengineered No, we're not calling them #GMO. Buh-bye. [editorial comment]
pg 92. #Bioengineered Nah, we aren't touching "found in nature" either.
I have to do something else, so I'm stopping again at page 100 for a while. Back later.
pg 103: #Bioengineered #CRISPR /talens again. No, we still don't distinguish on the tech used, but on the ultimate product.
pg 111. No, we aren't going after undetectable DNA. [this whole section is a series of comment/responses that are kind of tedious and repetitive in many ways. Zzzzzzzzzz 💤] #Bioengineered
pg 113: Animals fed with #bioengineered foods are not subject to BE labels.
pg 115: No, if an animal was treated with a #GMO pharmaceutical [say, a vaccine like Organic Consumers hates] it's still not #bioengineered.
pg 117. Grafting non-BE stuff to BE-modified rootstocks does not trigger #bioengineered labeling, "because they do not contain modified genetic material".
pg 118. Hipster food trucks are now listed in with "restaurants" and are all exempt from #bioengineered labeling. [Ok, it might not have said hipster...]
pg 126. Nope, @nonGMOProject and the other schemers not getting a free pass, and they better not mislead anybody. We can only give National Organic Program stuff a pass. #Bioengineered
pg 127. Mutagenesis is conventional breeding. #Bioengineered
#Bioengineered Let's say it loud for those in the back: "NBFDS is a marketing standard and not related to health or safety," pg 128. (NBFDS = National Bioengineered Food Disclosure Standard, btw)
pg 135. Oh, did we mention this is a marketing thing? No, we are going for the 0.9% threshold because it doesn't matter, and would be onerous and costly. #Bioengineered
pg 141. "Water and salt do not contain DNA and would therefore, as individual
ingredients under Alternative 1-A, never trigger disclosure." Things you have to say. #Bioengineered
pg 142. Nah, we aren't doing PCR. It's all paperwork.
pg 143. #Bioengineered Nope, we aren't calling 'em #GMO, and we'll teach you to like it.
pg 146. Did we mention we still aren't using #GMO, and we'll teach you to like it? #Bioengineered
pg 148. Yeah, we heard you didn't like any of the labels. We changed the wording so it says #Bioengineered. Enjoy! [ps you can get the labels here ams.usda.gov/rules-regulati… ]
pg 151. Yeah, we heard you hate the QR codes too. Too bad, we have to. But there are other routes. Phone numbers and texts. #Bioengineered
There are several pages of discussion of text messages. pg 156+. 💤📱#Bioengineered
pg 160. Another section relating to small biz and the burdens of this. There have been several section, but biz sizes aren't my area of focus so I haven't mentioned that so far. But they are in there, several sections. #Bioengineered
pg 163. Another section on bulk foods. Like small biz, this is just not something I'm focused on, so it's there--just haven't commented on it... 💤
pg 170+ is record keeping. 💤But that leads to enforcement issues (pg 175)--what happens if there's a challenge? 5 days to get paperwork together. No fines. No recalls. But we'll put your name up on the wall for people to point at and laugh. Or something.
pg 181. Date and rationale explained. Jan 2022 for mandatory labeling. #Bioengineered
pg 187+ starts the RIA, Regulatory Impact Analysis. Lots of back-and-forth about how (or how not) to calculate costs along the chain from farmers to consumers. I am now too bored to care. #Bioengineered
pg 196 starts the federal paperwork reduction notice stuff... for many pages. Lots more on record keeping. This may be of interest to farmers and grocers, but 💤#Bioengineered
pg 206 has a Civil Rights Review section. I'm mildly impressed this administration still does that... Mostly about phones and data plans. They think the phone number solves this. #Bioengineered
pg 208: Cost estimate for the label program. This is an expensive escapade, for this: "The NBFDS is not expected to have any benefits to human health or the environment." Your tax dollars at work. #Bioengineered
pg 215-end, seems to start the official text of the regs. I'll assume the legal eagles will check on this. And I'm out. /fin
@threadreaderapp please unroll the tedium
Missing some Tweet in this thread?
You can try to force a refresh.

Like this thread? Get email updates or save it to PDF!

Subscribe to Dr. mem_somerville | Wossamotta U
Profile picture

Get real-time email alerts when new unrolls are available from this author!

This content may be removed anytime!

Twitter may remove this content at anytime, convert it as a PDF, save and print for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video

1) Follow Thread Reader App on Twitter so you can easily mention us!

2) Go to a Twitter thread (series of Tweets by the same owner) and mention us with a keyword "unroll" @threadreaderapp unroll

You can practice here first or read more on our help page!

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just three indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member and get exclusive features!

Premium member ($30.00/year)

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!