So, mainly for my own sanity, here are a few thoughts to get off my chest about the whole ‘gender debate’. This might be a long thread so please feel free to scroll on by if it’s not for you. So, here goes:
Not to mention the women that will just retreat and not use facilities at all. Is this OK? My friends’ teenage daughters that don’t dare drink anything at school because they hate using the gender neutral toilets. Is this OK?
Then there’s SEXual orientation (clue there). Attraction is based on sex, not gender. The idea that it’s wrong for people to choose partners on the basis of sex is doomed to eventual failure too. In practice it’s usually homophobic AF too so, seriously, please stop doing that
My own view is women should not have to cede a single fucking millimetre of ground, when it comes to their rights. Women’s rights still need moving forward, not backward. It is outrageous that this is even being proposed in the first place
I think this is men’s problem. We’re why there are single sex spaces in the first place. We’re why some transwomen don’t feel safe in men’s spaces. Yet we are not being asked to give up anything, change anything – not even the way we think. NOTHING.
There needs to be another way, and it’s going to have to come out of men’s resources. Whether its third spaces, ‘open’ sports events etc I don’t know. But we need to talk about it. Calmly and rationally. Mainly, we need to fix why men are a threat to both women and transwomen
There IS a conflict of rights and this has to be addressed. If you want to help with that, then great. But if you’re just going to shout that women need to shut up, be kind and just put up with this shit then you are a big part of the problem.
I still think we can get to a solution. But, and I can’t believe this needs saying, it must acknowledge reality. It needs to accept that trans rights cannot just trample over women’s rights. Denying reality cannot work in the long term. It will eventually crash and burn
There is no hate here. No one is trying to erase anyone. We all want to be kind, considerate and compassionate. We need to talk. Accepting biological reality is the first step. Seriously: let’s just talk
@CEB1980 @juleandtheholos Oh, blocked. What a shame
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
The UK isn't 'TERF Island', it's 'Awareness Island'. TRA's are seemingly unwilling or unable to understand what the 'problems' they are experiencing are actually about. You really, really need to understand it 1/
What the UK has is a strong feminist movement, that largely originated within the political left / unions so understands class analysis. Highly organised & tenacious, they've raised public awareness like nowhere else on earth. 2/
So TRA's problem isn't "TERFs" as such, or even transphobia, but more that British feminists have simply informed the general British public, and in turn the wider world, about what transactivists are saying and what you actually believe 3/
Men: have you considered that maybe the "TERFs" have a point? That they're actually just reasonable women with the good faith & sincere belief being female has affected their experience of being human? That maybe they're not evil witches that need to choke to death on cocks?
Have you honestly listened to a single word any of them have to say? Why can't you form a single coherent argument against them without resorting to making stuff up, name-calling and threats of sexual violence?
Given a big part of the so called "TERFs" argument is for single sex spaces because of male sexual aggression, can you not see that you are just proving their point? I really resent you making it look like men are actually this dumb. Most of us are not
I think the gender debate is so infuriating, not just because TRA’s assertions and demands are often crazy, but because they don’t even agree *with themselves*. The whole thing is contradictions, conflation and incoherence. So I have some questions 1/
If sex is a spectrum and male / female don’t really exist, then what are you transitioning from / to? Even if intersex / DSD’s meant a third sex (it doesn’t) why is it never addressed that ALMOST NONE of you *are actually intersex*? 2/
Why don’t you ever listen to people with DSD’s? They repeatedly ask not to be used as a pawn in this. If identity and lived experience is something that always has to be respected, why do you constantly deny theirs? 3/