JoHn McDonnell is now suggesting Labour could put the terms of a “credible” Labour-proposed Brexit Deal to a referendum before negotiating with Brussels. Can anyone make sense of this?
Still leaves Labour proposing a form of Fantasy Brexit. Why put a notional deal to a referendum if it hasn’t been cleared by Brussels first? It is certain to change in subsequent negotiations with the 27.
Indeed, Labour would really need two new referendums. One to OK the Labour-proposed deal and another to endorse whatever comes back from Brussels
And we already know what would come back from Brussels: the Withdrawal Agreement and the Irish Backstop which Labour has voted against in the Commons repeatedly.
Everyone seems to think this is a great step forward because McDonnell says he would vote to remain. But it still leaves Labour facing both ways. I don’t known how they could explain this in an election manifesto.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
One reason the Scottish government has been sounding a little confused recently is that there has been a marked shift in policy on coronavirus - broadly from managing it to eradicating it. Thread 1/5
2/5 This is how the National Clinical Director, Jason Leitch, presented the strategy in March 18th.
3/5 This is not "herd immunity" but it reflects the consensus on SAGE that trying to eliminate the virus would simply generate a second wave. Recently, Sturgeon has been listening to the high-profile Professor of Global Public Health, @devisridhar of Edinburgh University.
This is a wilful misunderstanding. The women questioning Self-ID are not right wing homophobes. They are feminists, understandably concerned about sex based rights. They will not be silenced by cat calls of “TERF” and “cis”. This debate needs to be open
I speak as a commentator who was sued over my support for abolition of S28, in 2000, when the Sunday Herald was about the only paper calling for abolition. I was 100% for same sex marriage. But this unscientific dogma of “transwomen ARE women”, is very different.
The right of trans people to live and love as they wish free from discrimination and vilification is paramount. This should always be supported. But not at the expense of women’s rights.