The following is a summary of @FrJohnBehr's excellent keynote address at #OxPats19, entitled "The Gospel of John in the Second Century".
@FrJohnBehr 1. He began by identifying a series of key historical notes about the development of Christianity, especially with respect to annual commemoration of Pascha vs. the Sunday commemoration of the Eucharist via John's Gospel.
@FrJohnBehr 1a. For example, it is only from the "school" of the Johanine Gospel that we have evidence for the annual commemoration of Pascha, a commemoration that treats, crucifixion, death, resurrection (and even Pentacost) as a single event.
@FrJohnBehr 1b. By contrast, the earliest evidence we have the weekly commemoration of the Eucharist (even that on a Sunday), does not connect that ritual act to a commemoration of the Resurrection.
@FrJohnBehr 1c. It is Ireneaus, who first locates the annual commemoration of Pascha on a Sunday.
@FrJohnBehr 2. The second major theme of the talk focused on the presentation of John himself in the Gospel and subsequent writings within its school, especially the suggestion that he was a "priest."
@FrJohnBehr 2a. Fr. Behr thinks the connection likely stems from the way that the Gospel presents the restoration of the Temple of Jerusalem with the body of Christ. Thus, for the school of John, John is the high priest of the new temple of God in Christ.
@FrJohnBehr 3. The third major theme (which I have heard him discuss before) lies in the Gospel's presentation of what it mean to be (or more accurately become) human.
@FrJohnBehr 3a. To be human, he argues, "begins" with following alongside the passion of Christ, to be an imitator of it. The beginning of [true] life, lies in martyria.
@FrJohnBehr 3b. For Fr. Behr, we know this because of the centrality of the claim from the Cross in John's Gospel "it is finished." This is the completion/fulfillment of the work of the creation of humanity in Genesis.
@FrJohnBehr 3c. To understand this (and Fr. Behr's work more generally), you have to follow his hermeneutical approach that reads the whole of scripture through passion/death/resurrction, rather than diachronically from Genesis through Acts.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
I don't think I'll ever understand why Orthodox Christians in the modern world are so attached to a pagan calendar that is astronomically incorrect.
A short thread on the dating of Easter.
Contrary to popular belief--the formula for dating Easter is the same for all Christians. According to the Council of Nicaea, Easter is to be celebrated on the first Sunday after the first full moon, after the first day of Spring.
Both Eastern Christians and Western Christians use the same formula--and, no, it doesn't have anything to do with the date of Passover (even though almost every Orthodox Christian will tell you that it does . . .).
To be sure, the rise of anti-Semitic discourse & violence within some pockets of American Orthodoxy mirrors broader US and global trends. Nevertheless, I’d propose that our Holy Week hymns play an unnecessary contributing factor. It was not always this way. A thread:
(1) The oldest surviving Christian hymns (there are approximately 1000) focus almost exclusively on the death and resurrection of Christ. Those hymns consistently position either the whole of humanity or the singers themselves as the party guilty of Christ’s crucifixion.
(2) In other words, none of the earliest hymns accuse the Jews (or the Romans for that matter) as being responsible for the death of Christ—the hymns accuse Christians themselves.
We've been asked why Public Orthodoxy posts pieces on racism in American Orthodoxy--the presumption being that it isn't really a problem (or that it is only a small problem among a few converts in certain parts of the country) and that we should focus on things that matter more.
I agree that it is not a dominant trait of American Orthodoxy, but I would argue that it is on the rise and in more places than one might realize.
Case in point: the 26-year-old arrested in NJ yesterday for throwing a Molotov cocktail at a synagogue was a Greek American, raised in the church.
It is generally well known that the hymnography of the modern Orthodox Church is a fusion of hymns composed largely at two monasteries Mar Saba in Palestine and Studios in Constantinople, with other sources like cathedrals of the Anastasi and Hagia Sophia, and Mt. Athos.
I've been researching the development of the hymns for the Feast of the Exaltation of the Cross (Sept. 14) and, I must say, it is really interesting how different the Constantinopolitan hymns are from the Palestinian ones.
We know from a 10th-century manuscript what hymns were sung in Hagia Sophia for the Feast. It lists six hymns. Only three of those hymns are still sung the others fell out of usage.
I've just completed teaching my "Byzantine Christianity" course, which fulfills an undergraduate core requirement @FordhamNYC. I've probably taught this course more than 30 times and I've learned a number of things along the way. A few recommendations for others:
1. Whatever themes/events you select, you can easily identify themes and issues that are directly relevant to our current world and this will always surprise students who had no idea that these issues originate in context of early Christianity/Byzantium.
1a. For example, juxtapose American Church/State separation to Justinian's notion of diarchy; connect tax-exemption for religion institutions to Constantine; complicate the narrative of Christianity & colonialism by pointing to the Crusader colonization of Byzantium.
Today is the feast of St. Gregory the Theologian (Nazianzen) in the Orthodox Church. A short thread on one of my favorite Church Fathers.
Perhaps, the reason that I appreciate Gregory so much is because there are so many aspects of his life and work that remain relevant for contemporary society.
1. He pioneered the reformulation of the criteria for spiritual leadership in the wake of the legalization of Christianity, strongly criticizing those who attempted to teach others when they lacked advanced education and/or ascetic detachment.