Bar and Bench Profile picture
Aug 22, 2019 18 tweets 10 min read Read on X
#RamMandir - #BabriMasjid: Hearing continues into day 10.

Senior Counsel Ranjit Kumar arguing today on behalf of plaintiff in suit no. 1, Gopal Singh.
#RamMandir - #BabriMasjid: Ranjit Kumar relying on certain exhibits which had been produced by him in trial court in Section 145 CrPC proceedings.
#RamMandir - #BabriMasjid: Ranjit Kumar placing reliance on am affidavit filed by one Abdul Gani as per which Mosque was erected by demolishing Ram temple but in spite of erection of said mosque the Hindus did not give up possession and were all along worshipping idol there.
#RamMandir - #BabriMasjid: Ranjit Kumar placing reliance on more such affidavits by Muslims in Section 145 proceedings.
#RamMandir - #BabriMasjid: Bench asking him whether those Muslim persons were cross examined to determine the veracity of contents of affidavits.
#RamMandir - #BabriMasjid: Ranjit Kumar admits they were not cross examined but those persons had come forward and made these statement, so an inference can be drawn

"I am not saying what they said should be taken as gospel truth. But nobody has objected to what they have said"
#RamMandir - #BabriMasjid: The persons who have made the statement have been verified.

An inference can be drawn based on what they have said in the absence of any objection, submits Ranjit Kumar.
#RamMandir - #BabriMasjid: How did these affidavits form part of the record before High Court? asks Ranjit Kumar.

They were filed in the suit which then got transferred to High Court, replies Ranjit Kumar.

#AyodhyaHearing
#RamMandir - #BabriMasjid: Bench assembles, Ranjit Kumar resumes his arguments.
#RamMandir - #BabriMasjid: Ranjit Kumar citing judgments to explain the scope of concept of 'Hindu'.
#RamMandir - #BabriMasjid: Idol worship or rituals or ceremonies may not be practised by all persons though they may be professing Hindu religion, Ranjit Kumar reading out excerpts of judgments dealing with scope of Hindu and Hinduism.
#RamMandir - #BabriMasjid: My right to worship is an unfettered right which arise due to centuries of worship that has been happening at the site, Ranjit Kumar concludes his submissions.
#RamMandir - #BabriMasjid: Senior Advocate VN Sinha resumes, reiterates that the disputed land had become part of British crown on annexation by British.

Unless the land was leased out, the land was vested with the British crown
#RamMandir - #BabriMasjid: Senior Advocate Sushil Kumar Jain now begins his second round of arguments. He had not completed his arguments earlier.
#RamMandir - #BabriMasjid: Sushil Kumat Jain reiterates on behalf of Nirmohi Akhara that it had Shebaitship.
#RamMandir - #BabriMasjid: Suit no. 4 by Muslim parties is barred by limitation since the limitation ran from 1934 and not 1949 as claimed, Sushil Kumar Jain.
#RamMandir - #BabriMasjid: Discussion now on Nirmohi Akhara's stance on whether they are claiming title or not.

Is there a contradiction in the stance taken by them earlier in HC and now?

CJI Gogoi asks Sushil Kumar Jain to respond on the same.
#RamMandir - #BabriMasjid: Bench rises for the day. Hearing to contimue tomorrow.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Bar and Bench

Bar and Bench Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @barandbench

May 15
Supreme Court hears the Kuldeep Singh Sengar case

SG Tushar Mehta: CBI appeal is listed before the Delhi High Court

Sr Adv N Hariharan: I am in the position to show that the prosecutrix is not a minor. The AIIMS board says she was not a minor. All reports are in his favour still he is in jail.

SG: The main conviction is under 376(1) IPC for remainder of his life

CJI: Prayer was only to suspend the sentence. There are issues which require consideration.Image
SG: it has to be seen whether MLA is a public servant for the POCSO

Justice Bagchi: we do not endorse the hyper technical conclusion of the high court. This is a penal legislation which protects children from sexual exploitation.. section 21 of IPC and prevention of corruption of act..

SG: MLA is in a dominant position.

CJI: HC has suspended the sentence. We have stayed by it. Now there is suspense whether order is illegal, erroneous etc. Now in this area..HC will be reluctant to hear the main appeal.
CJI: we can set aside the order. HC can decide the appeal or if it's taking time .HC can decide the application for suspension of sentence.
Read 5 tweets
May 14
Supreme Court to resume hearing today petitions challenging a 2023 law which excluded the Chief Justice of India from the selection panel to appoint the CEC and other election commissioners.

Bench: Justices Dipankar Datta and SC Sharma Image
Retd. IAS SN Shukla argues on behalf of Lok Prahari: we have challenged not only section 6,7,8 and also the appointments made there under. The basis is not just the judgement in Anoop Baranwal but proven legal infirmities based on governments own records that I have obtained through RTI.
Court: have you received a copy of the counter?

Shukla: only union of India has filed counter yesterday.

Court: have you received the copy? Please address us on merits.

Shukla: the impugned provisions are ultra vires articles 14 and 324.
Read 52 tweets
May 13
Supreme Court remarks on women empowerment and patriarchal mindset in a divorce case between an Army officer (husband) and a dentist (wife) - Thread 🧵

The couple was granted divorce by the family court and the high court on the ground of cruelty and desertion by the wife for starting her own dental clinic away from Kargil, where her husband was posted.

The wife approached the Supreme Court not disputing the divorce, but seeking expungement of findings on cruelty and desertion.

Court: In the present world, where women are making strides in leaps and bounds, merely because the husband was an Army Officer posted in a remote location, the expectation that the wife could not even think of pursuing her career in Dentistry, is indicative of regressive and feudalistic mindset.Image
Court: It must be emphasised that a well-educated and professionally qualified woman cannot be expected to be confined within the rigid boundaries of matrimonial obligations alone. Marriage does not eclipse her individuality, nor does it subjugate her identity under that of her spouse.

Court: The expectation that a woman must invariably sacrifice her career and conform to traditional notions of an obedient wife meant for cohabitation, irrespective of her own aspirations or the welfare of the child, reflects a line of reasoning that is archaic, ultra-conservative, and cannot be countenanced.
Court: What is portrayed as defiance in the impugned judgments is, in truth, an assertion of independence; what is labelled as desertion is, on a closer scrutiny, a consequence of circumstances shaped by professional commitments.
Read 4 tweets
May 12
Punjab minister Sanjeev Arora has approached Punjab and Haryana High Court against his arrest by ED in money laundering case.

A Bench of Chief Justice Sheel Nagu and Justice Sanjiv Berry is hearing the matter. Image
It is absolutely illegal. It is absolute case of political vendetta: Senior Advocate Puneet Bali, representing Arora, submits.
An absolute political orchestrate! Two FEMA raids are made. One against Shri [Ashok] Mittal; he defects, joins the ruling party, no arrest is made: Bali
Read 35 tweets
May 10
Solicitor General of India Tushar Mehta’s two books — “The Bench, the Bar and the Bizarre” and “The Lawful and the Awful” — will be launched shortly

Chief Justice of India Surya Kant will preside over the event. Union Home Minister Amit Shah will attend as Chief Guest, while Attorney General for India R Venkataramani will be the Guest of Honour @AmitShahOffice #TusharMehta @Rupa_Books #SupremeCourtImage
SG Mehta's book launched by Union Home Minister Amit Shah , CJI Kant and AG R Venkataramani Image
SG Tushar Mehta: There is a particular peculiarity in being an advocate and publishing books on the lighter side of law. It feels rather like a surgeon writing humorously about his own operation theatre.

But I have deliberately, consciously, and purposefully chosen this subject, which is not a subject of just anecdotes or legal jokes or any other humorous book which is available in the market. I have chosen a different genre.

But I must clarify at the outset what these books are not. They are not a treatise. They are not a critique of any particular subject of law. And I have not even pretended to be scholarly while writing this book, the infection which infects almost everyone on this side of the Bar.

What are these two books? It is quite simple. They are a collection of true stories. Nothing is imaginary or fictional. They are a collection of true stories.

Since I am practising in India, and intend to do so for quite a number of years hereafter, I have chosen not to include any instance of Indian sport, Indian jest, or Indian judge. I have just gathered some incidents which would be very, very interesting for all of us to learn.Image
Read 18 tweets
May 7
During mentioning, lawyer tells Calcutta HC his client's name has been excluded from voter list after SIR.

Judge: I cannot list all matters in a single day, sir ... Please wait. Come on 9th

Lawyer: He is a cancer patient.

Judge: Cancer patient? What will happen to the SIR? Is there any relation between SIR and the cancer patient?Image
Court later takes up another petition challenging another person's exclusion after SIR.

Lawyer: Despite having birth certificate, my school certificate, appointment letter, they have deleted my name.

Judge: What is your prayer?
Lawyer: Prayer is for domicile certificate.

Judge: Domicile certficate? How two prayers in one petition? If you want SIR, then I can dispose of by directing appellate tribunal to dispose off. Your appeal is pending?
Read 27 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us!

:(