, 39 tweets, 10 min read
Are you learning how to edit? Confused by Premiere, Vegas, Resolve, iMovie, WMP, HitFilm, AVIDEMUX, or whatever?

Ask me questions in this thread, I'll answer them between tasks.
Bad organization. Not using bins, not labeling footage, not nesting sequences.
Like, if you watched yesterday's stream, I did the absolute bare minimum of organization and wasted a lot of time clicking on clips trying to find the thing I was looking for, way more time than it would have taken to do proper labels, tags, or sub-clips.
Spend more time up-front on organization to save time in the actual edit.
Also on the general subject of "learn the shortcuts", editing suites have *hundreds* of keyboard shortcuts, it's kinda overwhelming, but there's a core cluster, namely tools, shuttle controls, and operators, that aren't shortcuts as much as they're core controls.
Like, learning your way around shift/control/alt is pretty fundamental to using a full-suite NLE, on par with learning WASD controls if you want to play a PC shooter. It's just the way it be.
The general con is that they're all incredibly complicated with their own internal thought processes, assumptions, and vocabulary. There's a lot of differences ranging from minor to huge, but they're all mostly trying to achieve the same outcomes.
The biggest argument I'd make is that the process of editing is *so* complicated that it's actually worth skipping over iMovie/WMM entirely straight to Resolve/Premiere/FCPX.
Basically if you're starting from zero where all these words are new and the UI is completely alien, it's really not that much harder to learn your way around a full suite.
Blender *has* a video editor, but technically so does Photoshop. It's very much bare functionality that's more for the convenience of Blender artists than a tool you would otherwise use for video editing.
This is where it comes down to what you want to do. If you already know Blender and are comfortable with it and that's where a lot of your footage is coming from, it works. But I wouldn't recommend someone otherwise learn Blender specifically for use as a NLE.
Work at 24 or 30fps and let Resolve/Premiere/FCP handle the conversions. There's a lot of potential asterisks on this question, but assuming you've just got a mix of camcorder, cell phone, and webcam footage, just toss it all in a 30fps timeline.
That's just broad advice assuming you don't have some other, specific outcome in mind and just don't want your video to look weird.
Expect to spend a day setting up keybindings and/or learning new ones. Resolve combines the slip and ripple tools into a single trim tool that has context functionality based on positioning. Adjusting to a non-modular UI. Lots of tiny things.
Founder's advantage. Enterprise-scale support for both hardware and software. Networking systems for integrating dozens of workstations into a single unified project file. Basically a ton of stuff that a solo editor self-instructing would never think about
Because the old version under Sony was a very bad deal in terms of what you got for what you paid, and reputations are hard to shake.
There aren't any, but OpenShot and Shotcut are probably the least-unusable. AVIDEMUX has some niche functionality due to being so bad that it ignores I-frame integrity if you want to break video files on purpose.
Open source UX is just too consistently bad to recommend for something like video editing that relies so heavily on UX, and they don't have the features to make it worth the trade off, so I can't really give any of them the thumbs up for anything other than philosophical reasons.
I mean, at a certain point anything is usable, and the tool you have is better than the tool you don't. We used to make movies by literally taping strips of film together, so as long as a program will let you attach clips to one another you can make it work.
DaVinci Resolve has a free version that's only missing tools like Frame io integration, stereoscopic video, or 4k+ workflow. I used it for years before I hit a thing I wanted from the Studio version.
Don't be vague about what you want to see or how you want it to flow. Be familiar with the footage so you're not asking for things that don't exist. Have a sense for when a request is going to take hours and should be a note instead of a live demo.
Either slow the credits down, use static cards instead of a scroll, or (sorry, but it's true) use less compression.
Speaking of compression, if you’re looking to get into video editing, you’re going to need some hardware, that’s just a reality, but the first thing you should be looking at is hard drives. Storage is right above electricity in the editor’s hierarchy of needs.
You don’t need something extravagant, but you need to get past the point where a 2GB export feels absurd, where every video means deleting the previous.
FCPX's Magnetic Timeline is so particular that there's definitely an adjustment going to any other NLE, but the new Cut page in Resolve functions a lot like it, which might ease that transition.
Nothing in the rulebook says they can't 🤷‍♂️
Audio Sync Tools:
Resolve > Premiere >>> Final Cut

They all also have, or are paired with, tools that can help fix drift, but this is actually more of a problem that should be solved at the source.
The most common culprit of drift is a camera that uses variable frame rate (VFR) to reduce bitrate (like smartphones) and it causes hell with external audio. If you can't avoid using said camera then consider looping the audio directly into the phone's mic in when shooting.
It also might just be as simple as a mismatched sample rate, in which case match your audio recorder (and project settings) to the camera's sample rate.

Standard is 48kHz but some cameras use 44.1kHz.

In this case you can also "fix" existing audio by converting it to match.
It's not a jump so much as it's starting over. AE is a compositor and frame renderer which seems like it ought to be just a special kind of video editing tool but is really an entirely separate toolkit.
It's taking one sequence or timeline and putting it inside another. It's a way to isolate particularly complicated elements that can be difficult to move around, especially if they need to be reused or intercut with other things.
This is what intermediate codecs were made for. DNxHD, ProRes, Cineform, DPX, or Uncompressed.
Not at all, pre-rendering assets is super common. I definitely had a phase where I was over-reliant on "only render once" and render times definitely needlessly suffered since the interactions are often multiplicative and not additive.
Dynamic Link is super rad, but a .PSD that would take 30 seconds to rasterize as an uncompressed .TGA with alpha might take Premiere 10 minutes to render.
A lot of people are asking this, but the answer is I don't know, because the answer is too personal. Some people self-teach well just by opening a program and trying to Do A Thing. Many don't. Lots need guided instruction.
It also depends on how far you want to go, if you just want to be proficient with making a video or if you want to be the kind of person who cares about timecode and deliverable packages.
Honestly the general interface of NLEs has barely changed since the AVID/1 in 1989
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh.

Enjoying this thread?

Keep Current with Dan Olson (me)

Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

Twitter may remove this content at anytime, convert it as a PDF, save and print for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video

1) Follow Thread Reader App on Twitter so you can easily mention us!

2) Go to a Twitter thread (series of Tweets by the same owner) and mention us with a keyword "unroll" @threadreaderapp unroll

You can practice here first or read more on our help page!

Follow Us on Twitter!

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!

This site is made by just three indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3.00/month or $30.00/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!