My Authors
Read all threads
Lack of research and scholarly attention has led important personality dynamics once captured by the schizoid diagnosis to be overlooked. Once an immensely important construct, schizoid personality disorder is at risk of becoming diagnostically irrelevant. [THREAD] 1/
Many have argued that this is the result of the emergence of avoidant personality disorder (AVPD), a similar yet theoretically distinct syndrome (see e.g., Ahktar, 1987; Livesley et al., 1985). 2/
Schizoid and avoidant personality disorders have been categorized as separate types because different motivations are thought to underlie their social isolation. 3/
According to the current DSM (DSM-5, APA, 2013), individuals with schizoid personality disorder reportedly do not desire relationships because of deficits in their capacity to relate meaningfully with others 4/
whereas individuals with avoidant personality disorder reportedly desire relationships but fear rejection, shame, and humiliation. 5/
This conception leaves two abnormal, maladaptive sub-types of introversion: schizoid withdrawal and avoidant withdrawal: 6/
* (1) Social withdrawal based on anxious-fearfulness is considered avoidant
* (2) Social withdrawal based on apathy, anhedonia, and indifference as well as a preference for solitude is considered schizoid. 7/
Isolated, detached, and withdrawn individuals were not always viewed as separable on the basis of sensitivity to evaluation of others or the potential—or lack-thereof—for positive emotional experience in social interaction. In fact, quite the opposite was true. 8/
Hypersensitivity and detachment were viewed as going together (in parallel and interval) in abnormal, maladaptive introversion. 9/
"Like a mollusk without a shell--that is the surface. Or else the surface is just nothing; we see a man who stands in our way like a question mark [...] there are schizoid men, with whom we can live for ten years and yet we may not say for certain we know them"
-E. Kretschmer 10/
The debate about the validity of the schizoid-avoidant distinction centers on whether the different behavioral manifestations described by Kretschmer above 11/
as timid, flat, or hostile coupled with the internal experience of hypersensitivity and tendency to escape into one's thoughts reflect different types of disorders or whether they are subtypes of a common syndrome, such as abnormal, maladaptive introversion. 12/
There has always been an interest within clinical psychology and psychiatry in understanding isolated, detached, and withdrawn individuals (for a review, see Livesley et al., 1985): 13/
* a) There was Kraepelin who described "seclusiveness" as an introversion-based schizophrenia-spectrum personality type
* (b) Bleuler who coined the term "schizoid" to refer to Kraepelin's construct 14/
* c) Hoch who preferred the term "the shut-in personality"; and
* (d) Kretschmer who highlighted the internal sensitivity of schizoids despite outward displays of coldness. 15/
Given the historical importance of schizoid personality disorder for research on schizophrenia-spectrum pathology, psychodynamic theory (e.g., Klein, Guntrip, and McWilliams), and personality disorders, it is surprising how little research there is evaluating the distinction 16/
between avoidant personality disorder and schizoid personality disorder.
In light of impressively constructed and researched arguments that such a distinction rendered schizoid personality disorder an invalid construct and its proposed removal, 17/
it seems responsible to evaluate the validity of its distinction from avoidant personality disorder. The existence of isolated, detached, and withdrawn individuals who lack affiliative motivation, prefer solitude, do not experience pleasure from friendships and family, 18/
and are indifferent to external judgments would provide empirical support for the validity of post DSM-III schizoid personality disorder, suggesting it should not be removed.19/
Do such characters like Daniel Day Lewis in There Will Be Blood who utters the line "There are times when I look at people and I see nothing worth liking. I want to earn enough money that I can get away from everyone" exist without inner sensitivity? 20/
Winarick & Bornstein (2015) found that schizoid personality disorder and avoidant personality disorder items show unique patterns of correlations with theoretically relevant traits in many expected ways. 21/
Items tapping the need to belong and attachment anxiety were uniquely significantly correlated with avoidant personality disorder items. Items tapping social anhedonia and low empathy were uniquely correlated with schizoid personality disorder. 22/
This finding supports the validity of the DSM differential diagnosis. However, both schizoid personality disorder and avoidant personality disorder items were significantly correlated with rejection sensitivity (small r for the schizoid personality disorder link) 23/
and internalized shame (large r for schizoid personality disorder and avoidant personality disorder) items. 24/
This finding suggests that schizoid personality disorder items are linked with hypersensitivity,inconsistent with post DSM-III definitions but consistent with Meehl's schizotypy (Meehl, 1962),dimensional trait theorists, aspects of psychodynamic theory,& descriptive psychiatry25/
Below is a figure representing the correlation clusters for schizoid personality disorder and avoidant personality disorder, respectively - without the rejection sensitivity-schizoid personality disorder correlation included. 26/
There is considerable overlap but also clear contrasts (avoidant personality disorder on the right; schizoid personality disorder on the left 👀☝️). 27/
Where will all the schizoids go? They will be diagnosed as avoidant or schizotypal.

If the dearth of research on schizoid personality disorder continues, then there is a good chance the DSM-5 proposal will get realized, and schizoid personality disorder will be removed. 28/
Yet the proposal also calls for re-coupling social anhedonia with anxious/hypersensitivity by moving the schizoid personality disorder symptom over to avoidant personality disorder.
29/
The long reign of the label schizoid as a diagnosis will come to an end but the schizoid construct will live on, sort of. 30/30 [END]
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh.

Enjoying this thread?

Keep Current with Daniel J. Winarick, PhD.

Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

Twitter may remove this content at anytime, convert it as a PDF, save and print for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video

1) Follow Thread Reader App on Twitter so you can easily mention us!

2) Go to a Twitter thread (series of Tweets by the same owner) and mention us with a keyword "unroll" @threadreaderapp unroll

You can practice here first or read more on our help page!

Follow Us on Twitter!

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just three indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3.00/month or $30.00/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!