The extra borrowing for states linked to central govt approval seems harsh, but is clearly a way to encourage states to come up with reforms on labour/land etc. Seems a good move, assuming @narendramodi govt is clearly very reform-focussed itself
All those talking of very little stimulus need to keep in mind what would have happened without govt intervention @sanjeevsanyal@SubramanianKri@nsitharaman as tax collections and divestment collapsed. So you need to look at the extra spending that will now happen ...1/2
New spend:
Rs 4.2 lakh cr: GoI borrowing
Rs 4 lakh cr: New state govt borrowing
Rs 1.5-2 lakh cr new spend announced over 5 sessions by @nsitharaman
Anyone expecting more asking for the moon
Total centre+state deficit will rise 3-4% of GDP anyway
Debt will rise to 80% this year
Snakes and ladders is a good way to explain the challenges for @narendramodi
So far, Modi has tended to go along more with the snakes and provided less ladders for industry ... will he now change? Over the past 5 days, @nsitharaman has offered hope of a change in heart, but 🤞
a video link
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
This is why negotiating with the farmers was always going to be an uphill task
They commit to one thing and then enough of them break rank and then push another demand
This is a hydra-headed monster we're dealing with and it is feeding upon the sympathy that many are giving it
Any blackmailer with force now has a copy book on how to cripple a government, Dear Supreme Court and others
Happy Republic Day!
What all the worthies who defended the farmers and blamed @narendramodi for 'rushing' the Bills without any discussion need to ask themselves is whether the blackmail by PamperedPunjab farmers would have stopped if there was more discussion in Parliament?
Now that Supreme Court will suspend @narendramodi farm laws till a panel it sets up decides the way forward, what are other laws -- including tax ones -- we can get suspended?
Just keep in mind that, to be successful, we need to b able to gherao capital, so need tractors, etc
If agitating Punjab farmers don't go back home once SC suspends @narendramodi farm laws,will SC ask its police to force them out of Delhi? Oh wait, SC doesn't have its own police force!
& if farmers or govt don't agree to panel reccos? Will India be run by SC's panels now? #THINK
Supreme Court setting a dangerous precedent in wanting to put new farm laws in abeyance says @sarthakray
Disgruntled groups, with enough clout to gherao Delhi, can now challenge any law and get it kept in abeyance financialexpress.com/opinion/suprem…
Apart from fact that late @arunjaitley had said court/arbitration awards would be respected as solutions to the @INCIndia retro-tax, Cairn case was examined by govt on many occasions prior to late #PranabMukherjee's retro tax, and issue of tax dues never raised
Delhi HC ruled against this last year,but taxman said Swiss firm Xstrata’s arbitration award against Dalmia Bharat was a 'windfall gain', as in lotteries, betting etc Was taxman admitting enforcing arbitration awards in India is a matter of luck, a lottery?
Unfortunate that India has challenged @VodafoneGroup arbitration award.
Confirms India has no respect for global arbitration & that contracts have ZERO sanctity @narendramodi
And why did late @arunjaitley promise that he would go by what courts/tribunals ruled on the cases?
MASSIVE WIN for @CairnEnergy though the markets seem to be confusing this with @CairnOilandGas which is a @VedantaLimited firm and had bought CairnEnergy's India business
Now to see if @narendramodi govt will pay $1.2bn damages
India's CREDIBILITY at stake
As in the @VodafoneGroup case, in the @CairnEnergy case too, the award was unanimous
that means even the arbitrator that the Indian government nominated voted against India
Apart from fact that late @arunjaitley had said court/arbitration awards would b respected as solutions 2 @INCIndia retro-tax, Cairn case was examined by govt on many occasions prior to late #PranabMukherjee's retro tax, and issue of tax dues never raised
The @capt_amarinder@RahulGandhi farmer agitation is about politics,not farmer rights!
Punjab is HUGELY pampered--almost all wheat/rice brought to market is procured at MSP versus 10-20% for UP and even less for others.Yet, state agri GDP growth collapsing financialexpress.com/opinion/this-i…
.@narendramodi be fair to ALL states, DIVIDE annual FCI-spend equally
Why should Punjab get so much FCI money when UP or other states produce more?
This is not a farmers' agitation, it is a Punjab agitation, critical to @INCIndia survival @capt_amarinder can be next Cong chief✋
.@capt_amarinder@INCIndia@RahulGandhi DELIBERATELY distorted @narendramodi farm laws to suggest MSP being abolished
If any violence takes place,the CM is to blame
Even by the standards of politicians, this is a new low
BTW, MSP is KILLING Punjab, look at water table, salinity