My Authors
Read all threads
Dear Muslim Brothers and Sisters,

We urge you to kindly go through this thread. Some very important points have been put together.

The Question for which the answer is below, will come later

1/n
In Holy Quran Allah(swt) says "When in doubt go to the books that have been revealed before the Quran"

i.e. to refer the previous scriptures, like Torah & Injeel to understand the previous prophecies & the history of those to whom they were revealed i.e. the "Jewish People"

2/n
Jews of the time of Isa(as) believed that a previous Israelite prophet, Elijah (Elias(as)) had ascended to heaven in a chariot of fire & before advent of the Jewish Messiah, he would descend from heaven & prepare grounds for advent of Messiah; & then the Messiah would appear

3/n
So when Isa(as) made a claim to Messiahship, the Jews asked for Elijah

When Isa(as) told them that John the Baptist (Yahya(as)) was the SAME Promised Elijah, Jews insisted that if he was Elijah, he should have descended from heavens. So they rejected both Isa(as) & Yahya(as)

4/
There are references in New Testament in which resemblance of John to Prophet Elijah(as) has been mentioned

Here Isa(as) confirmed the fact that Elijah would not return, & that the appearance of Yahya(as) was nothing but the fulfillment of the prophesied coming of Elijah(as)

5/
Clearly One Particular Prophet was expected to RETURN – whereas another individual appears in the place of that same Prophet, but similar in spirit & qualities. But, he is rejected by the majority!

The Jews are still awaiting the same Elijah(as) to return from the heavens.

6/
Why was the coming of a new Prophet – John, referred to as coming of the old Prophet - Elijah ?

"METAPHORS"

So, the coming of an individual bearing the qualities and attributes of a person from the past is called by the earlier person's NAME, it is a METAPHOR.

7/
Example:

In a local football match, when a player tackles the opponents, the commentator screams "Here comes Maradona !"

Does it mean, the legend from Argentina has come to play this local match?

The commentator speaks volumes about his qualities, by calling him Maradona.

8/
HISTORY REPEATS ITSELF

Similarly, today majority of MUSLIMS believe Isa(as) has been taken up to the Heavens Alive with his physical body & has been living there for 2000+ yrs

They are waiting for him to fly down physically with help of 2 angels & to land on a white minaret

9/
In 1889, when Hazrat Ahmad(as) claimed to be Messiah promised to come within Islam, majority of Muslims rejected him

Hazrat Ahmad(as) claimed to be the Messiah in the same spirit & qualities of Isa(as)

Just as Yahya(as) had appeared in same spirit & qualities of Elijah(as)

10/
Now that you have read the ANSWER, here's the QUESTION:

Prophet Muhammad(saw) prophesied the coming of Isa(as) Ibn Maryam. So how did Mirza Ghulam Ahmad Saheb of Qadian become Isa(as) ?

The answer to this is the Thread you have been reading so far ☝️

11/
Why specifically Hazrat Ahmad(as) and why not anybody else ?

Answer: "The TIMING"

In His own words, the Promised Messiah Hazrat Mirza Ghulam Ahmad(as), wrote:

"It was the time for the appearance of the Messiah; if I hadn't come, someone else would have surely come."

12/
How is Hazrat Mirza Ghulam Ahmad(as) similar to Hazrat Isa(as)?

Here is a list of the many similarities between the TWO MESSIAHS…

13/
Similarity of the Law-bearing Prophets – Musa(as) & Muhammad(saw):

In the Torah, Allah(swt) promised the Jews, He would send a Prophet like Musa(as), who would come from among their brethren

In the Quran, Allah(swt) says He has sent Muhammad(saw) just as He sent Musa(as)

14/
The title of "MESSIAH" – the Saviour.

Isa(as) was the Messiah promised to come within the Jewish People.

Hazrat Ahmad(as) was the Messiah Promised to come within the Muslim Community.

15/
The timing of their Appearance:

Isa(as) appeared ~14 centuries after Musa(as) within his Ummat as a subordinate Prophet

Hazrat Ahmad(as) appeared in the 14th Century after Prophet Muhammad(saw) within his Ummat as a subordinate Prophet

16/
Non-Law Bearing Sub-Ordinate Prophets:

Being subordinate Prophet to Musa(as), Isa(as) did not change anything from Sharia of Musa(as) / Torah

Being subordinate Prophet to Hazrat Muhammad(saw), Hazrat Ahmad(as) did not change anything from Sharia of Muhammad(saw) / Quran

17/
Astronomical Signs:

A special star, known as the ‘Star of Bethlehem’ [Matthew 2:1-9], appeared in the sky after the birth of Isa(as). This ‘star’ is thought by some to be "Halley’s Comet"

In 1835 Halley’s Comet re-appeared i.e. at the time of the birth of Hazrat Ahmad(as).

18/
Similar beliefs & expectations from their Ummats:

Jews believed Prophet Elijah(as) flew up to the Heavens physically and expected Him to come down physically.

Muslims believed Prophet Isa(as) flew up to the Heavens physically and expected Him to come down physically.

19/
Isa(as) explained that the same Elijah would not come, but John (Yahya(as)) had come in the spirit, capacity and likeness of Elijah(as)

Hazrat Ahmad(as) explained that the same Isa(as) would not come, but he himself had come in the spirit, capacity and likeness of Isa(as)

20/
Jews and Muslims expected a bloody Messiah to come, who would wage wars, eliminate the non-believers and bring victory to them.

But both the Messiahs (Isa(as) and Ahmad(as)) turned out to be peaceful and brought a message of Love and Forgiveness

21/
The Jews were divided into 71 sects; then Isa(as) appeared and formed the 72nd sect: that of Rightful Believers

The Muslims were divided into 72 sects; then Hazrat Ahmad(as) appeared and formed the 73rd sect: that of Rightful Believers

22/
Under Foreign Rule:

The place of appearance of Hazrat Isa(as), Palestine, was under the foreign rule of the Roman Empire.

The place of appearance of Hazrat Ahmad(as), India, was under the foreign rule of the British Empire.

23/
Accursed Death:

Jews who disbelieved, falsely claimed Hazrat Isa(as) died an accursed death on the Cross, because he was a FALSE Messiah, Na’udhubillah.

Muslims who disbelieve, falsely claim Hazrat Ahmad(as) died an accursed death, as he was a FALSE Messiah, Na’udhubillah.

24/
Persecution for their Faith:

Followers of both Isa(as) and Hazrat Ahmad(as) have been boycotted, persecuted, prosecuted, penalized and even martyred for their Faith.

25/
Waiting Endlessly:

The Jews, apart from the followers of Isa(as), are still desperately waiting for their Messiah to appear.

The Muslims, apart from the followers of Hazrat Ahmad(as), are still desperately waiting for their Messiah to appear.

26/
Why can't the same Isa(as) Ibn Maryam return ?

Continue reading this thread:

27/
Isa(as) is clearly dead, as per logic, the Holy Quran and Hadiths.

The dead don't return to this life!

Kindly read this very informative Thread by @Faran_Rabbani Sb to see ALL the Proofs:
Difference in Appearance:

The Holy Prophet Muhammad(saw) has described the physical characteristics of Isa(as) who came 2000+ years ago and those of the awaited Messiah to come in the future, differently!

29/
Messenger only for Bani Israil:

In Bible [Matthew 15:24], it says Isa(as) was a Jewish Prophet sent for the 12 Tribes of the Israelites only

In Holy Quran [As-Saff 61:7], it says Isa(as) himself told the Bani Israil (Children of Israel) that he is a Messenger sent for them

30/
Request of Musa(as):

Allah(swt) rejected the request of Musa(as), who wanted to be a Prophet Or Follower within the Ummat of Holy Prophet Muhammad(saw), saying that "the Prophet of this Ummah would be from among themselves."

Then, how can Isa(as) come in the Muslim Ummah ?

31/
The Holy Prophet Muhammad(saw) has clearly stated that the coming Messiah would be from AMONG the Muslim Ummat itself.

i.e. NOT from the Ummats of any earlier Prophets, like Bani Israil.

32/
The Messiah and the Imam Mahdi Promised to come, are one and the same individual.

Watch this:


33/
Even today, Jews are still awaiting the same Prophet Elijah & their Messiah to appear

Similarly, Muslims of today, are waiting eagerly for their Messiah to come, but with their own list of expectations.

This also fulfills the prophecy that the Muslims would resemble Jews.

34/
Conclusion:

This is what the Promised Messiah, Hazrat Mirza Ghulam Ahmad(as) of Qadian, wrote about those who are still waiting for Prophet Isa(as) of Bani Israel to come to the rescue of the Muslims:

35/
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh.

Enjoying this thread?

Keep Current with Shahid Badruddin

Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

Twitter may remove this content at anytime, convert it as a PDF, save and print for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video

1) Follow Thread Reader App on Twitter so you can easily mention us!

2) Go to a Twitter thread (series of Tweets by the same owner) and mention us with a keyword "unroll" @threadreaderapp unroll

You can practice here first or read more on our help page!

Follow Us on Twitter!

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3.00/month or $30.00/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!