Stinging Observations of Hon'ble Delhi High Court in the Matter of [2020] 116 taxmann.com 415 Brand Equity Treaties Ltd. v. UOI..@GST_Council @FinMinIndia..
Observations would emphasize that #LateFeesRefund is a right which is bieng demanded by Taxpayers..#Part-1
Observations would emphasize that #LateFeesRefund is a right which is bieng demanded by Taxpayers..#Part-1
#Part-2-Several taxpayers however could not meet the deadline. This was on account of several factors - predominantly being inadequacies in the network of the respondents, which failed to meet the expectations and serve the needs of taxpayers. @GST_Council @FinMinIndia
#Part-3-Thousands of taxpayers complained that there was low bandwidth & despite several attempts being made on GST Network, they were unsuccessful in filing the statutory GST TRAN-1 Form online. Scores of complaints were made on portal and it was also brought to notice of Govt.
#Part-4The upshot of this experience is that the GSTN network, indeed, is riddled with shortcomings and inadequacies. This is palpably evident from the sheer number of cases being presented before us, in relation to such technical difficulties and inadequacies. @GST_Council
#Part-5-The problems on the GSTN cannot be wished away, and have to be resolved in the right earnest. This requires sensitivity on the part of the Government which has, unfortunately, not been exhibited in adequate measure. @GST_Council @FinMinIndia
#Part-6-Referred-Bhargava Motors v. Union of India, decision dated 13th May, 2019 in WP (C) 1280/2018-The GST System is still in a 'trial and error phase' as far as its implementation is concerned. @GST_Council @FinMinIndia
#Part-7-Referred-Kusum Enterprises Pvt. Ltd. v. Union of India, 2019-
This could be presumably because of low bandwidth, given the fact that before the deadline, a large number of tax payers all over the country, were trying to submit the declaration in form TRAN-1. @GST_Council
This could be presumably because of low bandwidth, given the fact that before the deadline, a large number of tax payers all over the country, were trying to submit the declaration in form TRAN-1. @GST_Council
#Part-8-It is not fair to expect that each person who may not have been able to upload the Form GST TRAN-1 should have preserved some evidence of it - such as, by taking a screen shot. @GST_Council @FinMinIndia
#Part-9-Many registered dealers come from rural background. They may not have had presence of mind to create any record of their having tried, & failed, to upload TRAN-1. They cannot be made to suffer in this background, particularly, when systems of Repsondent were not efficient
#Part-10-It is not as if the Act completely restricts the transition of CENVAT credit in the GST regime by a particular date, and there is no rationale for curtailing the said period, except under the law of limitations. @GST_Council @FinMinIndia
#Part-11-The period of 90 days has no rationale and as noted above, extensions have been granted by the Government from time to time, largely on account of its inefficient network. @GST_Council @FinMinIndia
#Part-12-What does the phrase "technical difficulty on the common portal" imply? There is no definition to this concept and the respondent seems to contend that it should be restricted only to "technical glitches on the common portal". @GST_Council @FinMinIndia
#Part-13-Further, technical difficulties cannot be restricted only to difficulty faced by or on the part of respondent. It would include within its purview any such technical difficulties faced by the taxpayers as well, which could also be a result of the respondent's follies.
#Part-13-After all, a completely new system of accounting; reporting of turnover; claiming credit of prepaid taxes; and, payment of taxes was introduced with the implementation of the GST regime. A basket of Central and State taxes were merged into a single tax. @GST_Council
#Part-14-New forms were introduced and, as aforesaid, all of them were not even operationalised. Just like the respondents, even the taxpayers required time to adapt to the new systems, which was introduced as a completely online system. @GST_Council @FinMinIndia
#Part-15- Apart from the shortcomings in the system developed by GSTN Ltd., the assessees also faced the challenges posed by low bandwidth and lack of computer knowledge and skill to operate the system. @GST_Council @FinMinIndia
#Part-16-It is very unfair on the part of the respondents, in these circumstances, to expect that the taxpayers should have been fully geared to deal with the new system on day-one, when they themselves were completely ill-prepared, which led to creation of a complete mess.
#Part-17-The respondents cannot adopt different standards - one for themselves, and another for the taxpayers. The fractures in the system, after its launch, became visible as taxpayers started logging in closer to the deadline. @GST_Council @FinMinIndia
#Part-18-They encountered trouble filing the returns. Petitioners who are large and mega corporations - despite the aid of experts in the field, could not collate the humongous data required for submission of the statutory forms. @GST_Council @FinMinIndia
#Part-19-Courts cannot be oblivious to the fact that a large population of this country does not have access to the Internet and the filing of TRAN-1 was entirely shifted to electronic means. @GST_Council @FinMinIndia
#Part-20-The Nodal Officers often reach to the conclusion that there is no technical glitch as per their GST system laws, as there is no information stored/logged that would indicate that the taxpayers attempted to save/submit the filing of Form GST TRAN-1. @GST_Council
#Part-21-Thus, the phrase "technical difficulty" is being given a restrictive meaning which is supplied by the GST system logs.@GST_Council @FinMinIndia
#Part-22- In our view, there could be various different types of technical difficulties occurring on the common portal which may not be solely on account of the failure to upload the form. @GST_Council @FinMinIndia
#Part-23-The access to the GST portal could be hindered for myriad reasons, sometimes not resulting in the creation of a GST log-in record. Further, the difficulties may also be offline, as a result of several other restrictive factors. @GST_Council @FinMinIndia
#Part-24-It would be an erroneous approach to attach undue importance to the concept of "technical glitch" only to that which occurs on the GST Common portal, as a pre-condition, for an assessee/tax payer to be granted the benefit of Sub-Rule (1A) of Rule 117. @GST_Council
#Part-25-The government cannot turn a blind eye, as if there were no errors on GSTN portal. It cannot adopt different yardsticks while evaluating conduct of taxpayers, and its own conduct, acts and omissions.@GST_Council @FinMinIndia
Brand Equity Treaties Ltd. v. UOI (Del)
Brand Equity Treaties Ltd. v. UOI (Del)
