My Authors
Read all threads
The Bellflowers (Campanula, Campanulaceae) are coming into their own right now. Because there are so many of them (18 spp. in Stace, and many more in specialist collections) they can be a bit daunting. ImageImageImage
The two commonest natives are C. rotundifolia (Harebell in England, Bluebell in Scotland, left) of acid grassland and C. glomerata (Clustered Bellflower, right) of chalk and limestone grassland. ImageImage
The 2 most likely to be seen on walls and pavements in town are “posh” and “port”: C. poscharskyana (Trailing, left) has pale blue star-shaped flowers and larger, pale green leaves; C. portenschlagiana (Adria, right) has dark blue bell-shaped flowers and small dark green leaves ImageImage
The first question has to do with the sepals. Is the calyx simple (with 5 lobes, left) or complicated (right, 5 calyx lobes alternating with 5 reflexed, sepal-like appendages, right) ? ImageImage
The 2 spp. with a complex, 10-part calyx are easy to tell apart: fat bells or slim foxgloves ? C. medium (Canterbury-bells, left) has 5 stigma lobes and cuneate leaves; C. alliariifolia (Cornish Bellflower, right) has 3 stigmas and lower leaves cordate. Petal colours vary a lot. ImageImage
The main part of the key starts with a question that is really difficult to understand on first acquaintance. It has to do with the capsule. This is the swollen bit underneath the calyx. Image
You could easily go wrong here, so seek out the oldest flowers on the plant. You need to locate the ‘capsule pores’. When ripe, these are the openings that release the seeds. The pores are either at the base of the capsule (left) or in the upper (apical) half (right). ImageImage
Let’s start with the species that have the pores at the top pf the capsule (i.e. in the apical half). If you don’t have any mature fruits, this is going to be a tricky decision. But not one to get wrong if you can possibly help it. Image
Look carefully at the edge of the calyx lobes (x10). If they are serrate, you have Campanula lactiflora (Milky Bellflower, left, the commonest cultivar of which is the beautiful, pale ‘Loddon Anna’). If not, it’s something else (right). ImageImage
An easy one now, based on flower size. The species with big flowers (>3cm) is the narrow-leaved Campanula persicifolia (Peach-leaved Bellflower, left) commonly self-sown in villages and towns. Smaller flowers, with stigmas less than half as long as the style, is something else. ImageImage
The last two in this group are dainty plants separated on their roots and basal leaves. Campanula rapunculus (Rampion Bellflower, left) has a thick tap-root, narrow inflorescence and petiolate basal leaves. C. patula (Spreading Bellflower, right) has an open panicle & thin roots ImageImage
Now for the species with pores near the base of the capsule. Image
The first species in this group is easy and really distinctive. This is the chalk down-land native Campanula glomerata (Clustered Bellflower, left) which has sessile flowers, lacking a distinct pedicel. Plants with pedicels are something else. ImageImage
Next, measure carefully the width of the calyx teeth. Are they very narrow, linear to filiform (<1mm wide at the base (left)? Or are they wider, ovate, lanceolate or triangular, more than 1mm wide at the base (right) ImageImage
There are 3 species with filiform calyx teeth. The familiar acid-grassland native Campanula rotundifolia has round basal leaves (hence the Latin name) but the stem leaves are linear and untoothed (left). Toothed, broader stem leaves (right) are something else. ImageImage
The other 2 species are easily distinguished by the way they hold their flower buds. Campanula rhomboidalis (Broad-leaved Harebell, left) holds its flower buds erect. C. cochleariifolia (Fairy’s-thimble, right) has its flower buds hanging down (pendent). ImageImage
Now for the species with rather broader (i.e. not filiform) calyx teeth. The first decision is whether your plant is short or tall (>50cm), decumbent (left) or erect (right). This is usually as easy as it sounds. ImageImage
First, the 4 decumbent species (stems prostrate with the tip turned upwards). If the diameter at the apex is much less than the length of the flower, you have the common and abundant dark (Oxford) blue Adria Bellflower (“port” = C. portenschlagiana). Otherwise something else. ImageImage
There are 3 species with bell-shaped flowers where the diameter at the apex is equal to or greater than the length. The small-flowered plant (<20mm across, calyx teeth <6mm) is Campanula garganica (Adriatic Bellflower, left). Larger flowers are something else (right). ImageImage
Finally amongst the decumbent species is the commonest of all: the plant with pale (Cambridge) blue flowers, shaped like stars, so common on walls in town: Trailing Bellflower (“posh” = C. poscharskyana). And see below. ImageImage
The other decumbent species is Campanula fragilis (Italian Bellflower, right), has much wider petals (10mm at base, rather than 5mm) Image
The last group are the tall (>50cm) erect species. There are 4 of them. The only hairless one is Campanula pyramidalis (Chimney Bellflower, pictured). It has erect (not pendant) capsules, and a dense pyramidal or cylindrical inflorescence. Hairy plants are something else. ImageImage
The most famous (infamous in fact) of the tall hairy species is Campanula rapunculoides (Creeping Bellflower). Christopher Lloyd calls it ‘the ultimate Trojan horse’. Graham Stuart Thomas says it is ‘the most prolific of ineradicable weeds’. Calyx teeth spreading or reflexed. ImageImage
The last 2 tall species don’t have rhizomes and are much less invasive. A hispid plant with sharply angled stems and cordate leaves is Campanula trachelium (Nettle-leaved Bellflower, L). A softly hairy or glabrous plant with cuneate leaves is C. latifolia (Giant Bellflower, R) ImageImage
So that's Campanula. There are 4 tall species and 4 decumbent ones in the group that has slightly wider calyx lobes, and 3 with filiform calyx teeth. There are 4 species with apical capsule pores (including Peach-leaved, below), and 2 with complicated, 10-lobed calyces. Image
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh.

Keep Current with Mick Crawley

Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

Twitter may remove this content at anytime, convert it as a PDF, save and print for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video

1) Follow Thread Reader App on Twitter so you can easily mention us!

2) Go to a Twitter thread (series of Tweets by the same owner) and mention us with a keyword "unroll" @threadreaderapp unroll

You can practice here first or read more on our help page!

Follow Us on Twitter!

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3.00/month or $30.00/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!