“Men menstruate. Some have even given birth.” If you disagree, you are “attacking trans lives,” and likely one of those deplorables who support Trump.
I’m no Trump supporter, just a biologist who knows that this “new trans reality” is a dangerous fiction. nytimes.com/2020/06/23/opi…
“The only difference between a trans woman and a cisgender woman is the sex assigned to her at birth.”
No. Really not.
Most people know this is flat out wrong.
Most people who hear this nod abjectly, eyes averted, hoping this will pass by and leave them intact.
Again, no.
The vast majority of us who call bullshit on reality-denial are not “anti-trans.”
Nature is not anarchic re: sex. We have 2 types of gametes, by which we sexually reproduce. Small and mobile -> sperm -> male. Large and sessile -> egg -> female. Where’s the anarchy?
Here are @BretWeinstein and I discussing sex and gender on our livestream Q&A today:
And here am I talking about sex and gender at the Krishnamurti Foundation in 2018:
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
#FollowTheScience is a perfect encapsulation of an anti-scientific approach to the world, shared by those who think they are modern and hip and sciencey.
“Do you know that Newspeak is the only language in the world whose vocabulary gets smaller every year?” Syme asks Winston in 1984. “Don’t you see that the whole aim of Newspeak is to narrow the range of thought?” open.substack.com/pub/naturalsel…
As I noted in the last footnote of the linked piece, the Wall Street Journal ran an op-ed that I saw after I had finished it, which includes a link to the now forbidden content. Here are a few gems:
Using more words is always more awesomer than using fewer words. What about albino people of African descent though? Where do they fit in to the acronym? Come on, guys, do better. Be better.
Breaking news! Vitamin D protective against Covid!
Some of us have been saying this for a long time, but media & public health orgs have been silent. It's like they prioritize our fear and compliance over our ability to take control of our own health. nature.com/articles/s4159…
Vaccine mandates caused job and income loss, family break-ups, injury, death.
These are mandates for vaccines, remember, that people *now* claim were never supposed to stop transmission.
You advocated for mandates, and now you would have us move on? How dare you.
There are many who are permanently harmed—physically, financially, socially—by what you and yours wrought on society, with your uninvestigated terror and rules.
This is the failure of “data-driven” in stark relief. Next time, try a hypothesis. Do actual science.
Modern activism is often performative, rehearsed, and utterly out of touch with reality. Here, I make the bold claim that men and women are, on average, different heights. That appears to have been a bridge too far.
As absurd a performance as that is by activists, the truth is worse than the fact that they are denying reality. They are not responding to what was said. They are immune to new information. They are engaged in theatre, in what I call read-only activism. open.substack.com/pub/naturalsel…
After @JamesADamore wrote his memo, common sense unraveled at google. Some employees took time off to deal with the trauma of having read that, on average, men and women vary in some ways. How many of those employees do you suppose were men? npr.org/sections/thetw…