In November 2019, we made two pieces on detransitioning – for @BBCNewsnight and @BBCfileon4. They featured ‘Debbie, ’ who began transitioning to a man at the age of 44.
She had been given testosterone at her first appointment, and completed a full surgical transition over a number of years. She changed her name legally to Lee. When we spoke, Debbie had taken the decision, after 17 years, to stop her testosterone injections.
She wanted to detransition and posed the question, “how the hell do I go back to being the Debbie that I was?” Speaking then, Debbie was unsure about what the long-term implications may be for her and talked about the possibility of reversing some of her surgery.
She was being seen by one of the NHS’s Gender Identity Clinics, but said they were not sure how to help.
Today, Debbie, now preferring to be called Lee again, is pictured along with four more detransitioning or detransitioned women in @BareReality ‘s piece for the Sunday Times
Lee is quoted as saying, “I thought I would detransition, but I’ve decided I can’t physically do it. My body can’t take it. I’m not sure I’d survive all the surgeries. I’d be battling my body for the rest of my life. I have to accept my body the way it is now.”
“On the outside people see a little bloke. Inside I’m a traumatised little girl. But I’m more accepting of myself for the first time ever.”
I hope they can find happiness and peace.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
CASE RESUMES: High Court is deciding whether to allow JR by Keira Bell (KB) against Health Secretary (WS) & NHSE in arguing it was "irrational" not to ban cross-sex hormones (CSH) along with puberty blockers (PB). Gov has announced new working group is looking at a pos ban now
Mr Steel for the government is resuming. S argues PB prescribed to v specific groups for specific reasons e.g young children for precocious puberty; adults for certain cancers - so relatively clear division by age group.
Anyone in puberty wld most likely be receiving them for gender dysphoria so easy for pharmacist to tell. This is not case with CSH - used for many reasons, and not so easy to tell why someone might be receiving them. Makes a S.62 order more difficult
BREAKING. The Government has established a Working Group to look at whether prescription of cross-sex hormones (CSH) will, like puberty blockers, should be banned to under 18s, outside of NHS (ie private & overseas providers). The group is expected to report back in July.
The news came during a hearing at the High Court today. Former Tavistock patient, Keira Bell (KB) had sought Judicial Review against Health Sec Wes Streeting and NHS England about decision to allow the prescribing of CSH, despite evidential concerns about safety for children
Arguing on behalf of Ms Bell, Zoe Gannon (ZG) explained that Streeting (WS) himself had described what happened at the Tavistock GIDS as a “scandal”, “where children suffering from gender-related distress were treated on the NHS” based on evidence which was “at best, weak”.
🧵A father is bringing legal action against the NHS after his 16-year old was given cross-sex hormones by Brighton-based GP Sam Hall. I first revealed Hall & WellBN's practice of prescribing hormones, allegedly after a single appointment, back in March... telegraph.co.uk/news/2024/12/2…
Court documents in this case claim child 'O' was prescribed oestrogen in October “without any diagnostic process compatible with the Cass Report nor NHS England’s clinical commissioning policies”. When I wrote about Hall in Time to Think, NHSE were already aware of the situation.
Cases I write about were extremely similar to that of 'O', whose father is now pursuing legal action. 16 year old 'Charlotte', who has severe autism and ADHD was allegedly prescribed testosterone 48 hours after meeting Dr Hall.
NEW: A damning letter from Dr Hilary Cass to NHS England bosses, detailing serious concerns about adult gender clinics has been published. NHSE haven't drawn attention to it, instead releasing an update on implementation of Cass’s recommendations for children’s gender services.🧵
The most common concern of staff at clinics was “the very limited time for assessment and the expectation that patients would be put on hormones by their second visit.” First appointments wld often be with someone “not necessarily clinically trained”.
Majority of patient presentations “were extremely complex, with a mix of trauma, abuse, mental health diagnoses, past forensic history, ASD and ADHD, & therefore this limited assessment was inadequate." These issues weren't taken into account in decisions to prescribe hormones.
BREAKING: The BMA press office have released a statement accusing the New Statesman article as being misleading. Needless to say I absolutely reject this and will show why. The statement does not say how Council members voted on the motion to ‘disavow’ the Cass Review 🧵
Instead, the BMA press office say:
“The BMA will continue with further work in this area to contribute positively to the provision of care and services to this often neglected population and will be setting out the BMA’s stance in due course.”
More to come …
The Head of the BMA press office has confirmed: "The outcome of the discussions are not being made public"...
EXCLUSIVE: in one of the final actions of Parliament, just before dissolution, the Government had legislated to ban private prescriptions (originating in UK or abroad) of puberty blockers for under 18s. NHS prescriptions will be restricted - legally - to official trials.
Under 18s already receiving puberty blockers from the NHS will not be affected. Those receiving from abroad will no longer be able to. NHS prescriptions of GnRH analogues (blockers) NOT for treatment of gender incongruence for under 18s, are unaffected.