Thread by @travisdon1981

@WhoWouldWin13 Though Tick is invulnerable, Avacyn is technically indestructible. I say technically, because in one book, A sorcerer finds a way to destroy her using magic. However, in the game, she cannot be killed, while Tick could, if confronted by a powerful enough opponent. And Avacyn is

@WhoWouldWin13 indeed powerful, so much so that she is a major figure in at least one Dominarian religion. Indeed, one might be so bold as to consider her even a god. Also unlike Tick, she can fly. Her powers are so great that, if she fought three hill giants, she could kill two and seriously

@WhoWouldWin13 injure the third in the battle. Her magical capabilities must be awesome. Also, unlike Tick, Avacyn is intelligent. Indeed, she is highly intelligent. She also brings an angelic spear into battle, and with its magical properties, combined with her own, she might even be able to

@WhoWouldWin13 physically cut or injure Tick despite his invulnerability (in a similar manner to what Doomsday did to Superman). However...I have some doubts as to whether she could do that. Indeed, Tick has no doubt fought magic-based opponents before, and to my knowledge, his invulnerability

@WhoWouldWin13 has never failed (though he does, oddly enough, feel pain). Though his strength in the comics and cartoon is not fully quantified, in the latter he's claimed to be the strongest hero. In the live action TV show he's seen nearly crushing the hand of his world's equivalent of

@WhoWouldWin13 superman in a handshake. Considering its the comic book version we're using here...I would be so bold as to say that Tick is probably in the 100 ton range or more. However, his strength increases when events become more dramatic (His so-called "Drama Power"). Thus, Avacyn will

@WhoWouldWin13 find herself confronting an opponent whose powers will increase throughout the battle.

But who would win?

While Avacyn could theoretically hurt Tick with her magic, Tick cannot hurt Avacyn. No matter how powerful her opponent is in the land of Dominaria, Avacyn is

@WhoWouldWin13 indestructible. It would take something with ungodly power to overcome that aspect of her. Tick is strong, but doesn't have what it takes to pull it off. However, he does have what it takes to take her attacks and come back to tell the tale. Indeed, there are few, if any beings

@WhoWouldWin13 in Dominaria that have his kind of invulnerability. Thus, we could potentially see a stalemate here, which happens often in Dominaria.

Thus, I must conclude...

@WhoWouldWin13 ITS A TIE!!!!!!!!!

@WhoWouldWin13 @threadreaderapp unroll