( THREAD )
There has been a question posed to us, actually it's a set of questions. You can call it the "Muslim Question" (MQ in short).This question was first posed to us when Bin Qasim converted the first Hindu to Islam in Sindh.Ever since then,this question has only deepened.
There has been a question posed to us, actually it's a set of questions. You can call it the "Muslim Question" (MQ in short).This question was first posed to us when Bin Qasim converted the first Hindu to Islam in Sindh.Ever since then,this question has only deepened.
So what are these questions ?
These questions are :
1. Who are Indian Muslims ? Whom do they descend from ?
2. What place should they have in the Hindu society ideally ?
3. What relation should Hindus have with them ?
4. Are they part of us or are they separate ?
These questions are :
1. Who are Indian Muslims ? Whom do they descend from ?
2. What place should they have in the Hindu society ideally ?
3. What relation should Hindus have with them ?
4. Are they part of us or are they separate ?
5. What is our plan for their future ? Will they forever stay Muslims or will they change their religion ?
6. What place will they have if we form a Hindu state ?
7. Can they be ever assimilated fully while still following Islam ?
8. Are they friends or enemies ?
6. What place will they have if we form a Hindu state ?
7. Can they be ever assimilated fully while still following Islam ?
8. Are they friends or enemies ?
These questions have been begging for an answer since more than a millennia & I am very disappointed saying that we have not answered even one of these questions properly.
The Marathas defeated numerous Muslim powers but even they couldn't answer this question properly.
The Marathas defeated numerous Muslim powers but even they couldn't answer this question properly.
The Pratiharas, the Rashtrakutas, the Sangamas, the Sisodiyas, the Marathas all fought against Muslims powers but failed at the MQ. Shivaji was probably the only Hindu medivial king who answered some questions substantially and worked accordingly. Everyone else just ignored it.
Coming to modern age, the Arya Samaj answered some questions properly & worked accordingly. Savarkar & Bharatendu answered most of them. Gandhi, Nehru & Bose completely ignored that these questions even existed. Golwalkar answered them well. Tilak could have answered but didn't.
I am asking these questions to you as a Hindu not as the citizens of India. The Republic fails to see these questions. For it, India was formed in 1947 & everything before that is totally ignorable. Hindus & Muslims are both after all just Indians & that's all what it cares for.
The answers to all of these questions will decide what is the future of the Hindu civilization. We aren't becoming a superpower without answering them. We aren't becoming even a Hindu Rashtra without answering these questions. It is easily the biggest external threat for Hindus.
These questions have not just a single correct answer but numerous correct answers.
So next time you meet your Right Winger friend & they're in that zone when they speak their totally honest opinions, ask them these questions and see how you can improve their answers.
So next time you meet your Right Winger friend & they're in that zone when they speak their totally honest opinions, ask them these questions and see how you can improve their answers.
