Thread by @doctorow

In Olden Days, people who worked for an employer got a pension. The pension would pay $X/month (a percentage of your salary), maybe indexed to inflation. That was a pension you could depend on, surety you could use to plan your old age.

1/

Today we call it a "defined benefits" pension but back then, we just called it a "pension."

In the 1970s, these gave way to "market-based" pensions, AKA 401(k)s.

2/

The theory was that instead of knowing how much you'd have to live on when you were retired, you'd take some of your wages and put them into a stock market that you didn't understand and were unqualified to participate in and cross your fingers.

3/

This was always going to end badly, but it was sold with sweeteners that gave it a veneer of plausibility in the 1970s (they were big on veneers in the 70s!).

4/

401(k)s came with massive tax breaks, so every dollar you put into your pension automatically earned 9.2% in annual savings, an incredible ROI.

5/

But over the years, these tax advantages have vanished. Today, the 401(k) tax break is 0.6% - and your fund manager takes 1-2% out of your savings for managing this money, leaving you in the hole before you make your first transaction.

bloomberg.com/opinion/articl…

6/

All of this is kind of moot anyway. In reality, almost no one has any excess income to put into a 401(k), because of decades of wage stagnation. Those people who DO have retirement savings are likely to raid them and incur massive tax penalties once the stimulus runs out.

7/

I've low-key suspected that part of the GOP program of coronavirus denial was a tacit desire to head off the political challenges of a massive cohort of retirees with no savings and anemic Social Security.

8/

Those people weren't going to dig holes, climb in and pull the dirt in over them. Nor would they consent to starve quietly on the corner after they got evicted.

9/

They would become a new, grey Bonus Army, successor to Occupy, demanding mass-scale redistribution from the sharks who stole their futures. Old people vote like crazy, after all, and there's a limit to how long you can blame their all-Alpo diet on Jina and racialized people.

10/

Remember in March when Texas Lt Governor Dan Patrick said that old people had a patriotic duty to commit suicide so they wouldn't burden the economy?

vanityfair.com/news/2020/03/d…

11/

Talk about saying the quiet part out loud!

Image:
Tom Woodward (modified)
flickr.com/photos/bionict…

CC BY-SA
creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa…

eof/