"The world is perishing from an orgy of self-sacrificing." Ayn Rand had identified the fact in 1943, through The Fountainhead's Howard Roark. How much greater the orgy today. How much higher the mountain of the sacrificed.
The pandemic has provided a perfect stage and setting for the altruists, for those animated and driven by altruism's standard of morality. The pandemic is practically a heaven-sent opportunity to demand and justify the sacrifice of anyone and anything to "the greater good"
-- for as long as those being sacrificed can bear it, to the extent they can bear it -- and beyond, past the point of any bearability. To the altruist, no sacrifice is too great and all sacrifice is justifiable, if made to the chosen god.
The strangulation and suffocation of ten thousand businesses on the altar of the Greater Good, hundreds of thousands of livelihoods -- it's all expected, demanded -- passingly sad and unfortunate perhaps, but required yet, at the end of the day,
if it means the possibility of saving even one more life from the virus. Ask an altruist what rate of Covid mortality would be acceptable to him before he would stop approving and supporting the enforcement of further sacrifice. If he's honest, he'll tell you zero.
By the time we've reached zero, he'll have found a new altar, or will have returned to an old one.
From yesterday's @sfchronicle article on Yelp's estimate that at least 2,000 businesses have closed permanently in the Bay Area alone -- so far. "An orgy of self-sacrifice" indeed. sfchronicle.com/business/artic…
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
It was a year ago today that officials of the State of California and the County of Napa issued the shelter-in-place order that prohibited us from opening our gallery's doors, a condition that would come to be extended indefinitely. The forced closure posed a threat to our lives
a threat that would worsen with each passing day of the lockdown, as there can be no art gallery without art buyers, no artists without art sales, no art without artists, no consumption without production, no life without livelihood, no being without doing. No us without ours.
As the quiet days turned into silent weeks, it would become increasingly evident that officials had found themselves in the position of high priests overseeing and orchestrating an orgy of self-sacrifice to the "greater good."
Penned it in July, 2017. It's as true, and even more important today. "Check your emotions: if you find that your hatred of the left or of the right is more strongly felt than your love for individualism, and if your life is your standard of value,
1/
consider reexamining your premises and your approach. If your political thoughts, words, and actions are essentially reactive, driven primarily and most often by emotions of loathing or fear—you've conceded to playing your enemy's game, and by his rules.
2/
That's a game you'll lose, even if you destroy him, for with destruction comes a vacuum, and while nature may abhor a vacuum, evil adores one. Evil is ever reborn where innocence is left unprotected, where freedoms are left poorly protected.
3/
"Existence is not a negation of negatives. Evil, not value, is an absence and a negation, evil is impotent and has no power but that which we let it extort from us. ... a zero cannot hold a mortgage over life.
1/
"You seek escape from pain. We seek the achievement of happiness. You exist for the sake of avoiding punishment. We exist for the sake of earning rewards. Threats will not make us function; fear is not our incentive. It is not death we wish to avoid, but life we wish to live. 2/
"You, who have lost the concept of the difference, you who claim that fear and joy are incentives of equal power - and secretly add that fear is more 'practical' - you do not wish to live, and only fear of death holds you to the existence you have damned.
3/
We were right to reopen the gallery when we did. Our survival depended on it. "Nearly half of California Wine Country businesses closed in the coronavirus pandemic won’t reopen, says Yelp" #notdyingisnotlivingnorthbaybusinessjournal.com/article/indust…
"Based on the number of business owners who checked “closed” on their Yelp pages, about 3,000 San Francisco Bay Area businesses closed permanently from March 1 to July 10 as a result of the government shelter-in-place orders during the coronavirus pandemic. ...
"All together in Napa and Sonoma counties, 488 closed temporarily or permanently because of the shelter orders. ...
The San Francisco-Oakland-Hayward metro area experienced 5,048 total business closures during the pandemic, with 2,065 labeled permanently, according to Yelp. ...
"Observe the snarling, hysterical hatred with which they greet any suggestion that sacrifice is not necessary ..."
We've observed it -- we've been the target of it -- from the day we announced we were reopening the gallery.
We’ve observed it from neighbors, complete strangers, even from formerly close friends. Altruism's moral standard of sacrifice runs much deeper and wider in the culture than many realize or most would want to admit openly.
The only real disagreement, politically and ideologically, is over the what and how of the sacrifice, over which collective entity is the rightful recipient – the nation, all of mankind, a particular race, tribe, sex, the elderly, the poor, those susceptible to a disease, ad inf.
"When we say that we hold individual rights to be inalienable, we must mean just that. Inalienable means that which we may not take away, suspend, infringe, restrict or violate—not ever, not at any time, not for any purpose whatsoever.
"You cannot say that “man has inalienable rights except in cold weather and on every second Tuesday,” just as you cannot say that “man has inalienable rights except in an emergency,” or “man’s rights cannot be violated except for a good purpose.”
"Either man’s rights are inalienable, or they are not. You cannot say a thing such as “semi-inalienable” and consider yourself either honest or sane. When you begin making conditions, reservations and exceptions, you admit that there is something or someone above man’s rights,