A thread on how the lockdown in Victoria has affected Victoria and Australia.
First to anyone who argues that "lockdowns don't work", objective observations disagree.
We need reasonable discussion about whether lockdowns are justified, but if your starting point is "lockdowns don't work", you've disqualified yourself from reasonable discussion.
We need reasonable discussion about whether lockdowns are justified, but if your starting point is "lockdowns don't work", you've disqualified yourself from reasonable discussion.
What has been gained from lockdown in Aus & Victoria:
The first round of lockdowns successfully eliminated disease from most of Australia. (New Zealand had similar success) It has meant that most states have had much more normal life than most of the world.
The first round of lockdowns successfully eliminated disease from most of Australia. (New Zealand had similar success) It has meant that most states have had much more normal life than most of the world.
Economically and mental health-wise there is no question that most of Australia and New Zealand has been in a better economic/social position than most of the world.
Sweden is often used as an example of a place that "does it right" by no locking down.
Sweden is often used as an example of a place that "does it right" by no locking down.
Sweden's death totals are much higher than Australia.
And anyone who tells you that Sweden hasn't had restrictions either doesn't do his homework, or is lying.
Much of Australia currently has fewer restrictions than Sweden.
And anyone who tells you that Sweden hasn't had restrictions either doesn't do his homework, or is lying.
Much of Australia currently has fewer restrictions than Sweden.
My understand is visits to aged care facilities in Sweden were banned from Apr 1 - Aug 31 (not sure if this has been extended, or if it may have been relaxed early).
Large gatherings in Sweden are restricted to about 1/20 of what Australian football crowds are currently allowed.
Large gatherings in Sweden are restricted to about 1/20 of what Australian football crowds are currently allowed.
Obviously Victoria is currently much stricter. What has that done?
As restrictions ramped up, counts increased, exceeding 700 in a day. After stage 3 + facemasks was introduced, they quickly increased to stage 4. Shortly thereafter counts started falling quickly.
As restrictions ramped up, counts increased, exceeding 700 in a day. After stage 3 + facemasks was introduced, they quickly increased to stage 4. Shortly thereafter counts started falling quickly.
I don't know enough to say whether stage 3 + facemasks might have been enough for a slow decline (I hope so), but it's clear that stage 4 has led to dramatic decreases.
I did not support going to stage 4-like restrictions when the initial stage 3 restrictions came in.
I did not support going to stage 4-like restrictions when the initial stage 3 restrictions came in.
However, with hindsight:
- about a week into July VIC put in place stage 3 lockdowns - case counts were under 200
- 2 Aug VIC had 670 new cases and went to stage 4.
- just over a month later we have about 40 new cases.
- about a week into July VIC put in place stage 3 lockdowns - case counts were under 200
- 2 Aug VIC had 670 new cases and went to stage 4.
- just over a month later we have about 40 new cases.
Had they jumped straight to stage 4 in early July rather than early August, we would have seen similar reductions, and a month ago we would have been commenting on the drop from 200 to single digits, rather than from 700 to double digits.
That's a lesson for the rest of Australia.
What would have happened without lockdown?
No question growth would have continued for quite a bit longer. We would have seen well over 1000 cases a day for an extended period, and the disease would have been seeded in the rest of Australia many times.
No question growth would have continued for quite a bit longer. We would have seen well over 1000 cases a day for an extended period, and the disease would have been seeded in the rest of Australia many times.
The rest of Australia would be in the midst of an outbreak similar to what I'm describing would have happened in VIC.
Lockdowns and border controls combined have kept this away from the rest of Australia so far.
As long as the seeding events are rare, states have had the capacity to respond with aggressive tracing to keep them under control.
As long as the seeding events are rare, states have had the capacity to respond with aggressive tracing to keep them under control.
It hasn't been pleasant in VIC. These restrictions are putting a huge cost on the state. Without these restrictions, the rest of Australia would be facing a large epidemic.
A few more weeks should get numbers down low enough that a long-term return to normal is plausible.
A few more weeks should get numbers down low enough that a long-term return to normal is plausible.
It's a terrible balancing act for the government to face.
There is uncertainty about whether we can control the disease when lockdowns are removed. Our control is much better when counts are very low.
There is uncertainty about whether we can control the disease when lockdowns are removed. Our control is much better when counts are very low.
If we reopen and lose control, the cost to the economy will be much worse than the cost of a few more weeks of lockdown.
When people say "rip the bandaid off", what they are actually recommending is more akin to dropping your hands while in a fist fight to get it over with.
When people say "rip the bandaid off", what they are actually recommending is more akin to dropping your hands while in a fist fight to get it over with.
Last few comments for now: we need to get out of lockdown, but if we get out without a plan to control the disease, that is simply accepting a huge amount of death and massive economic hardship.
The rest of Australia is reasonably normal b/c of the lockdown we went through.
The rest of Australia is reasonably normal b/c of the lockdown we went through.
That's what we want to replicate now.
[got work to do now]
[got work to do now]
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
