0/25. Lying about disease kills us and our democracy. Quotations from "Our Malady: Lessons in Liberty from a Hospital Diary," published this week. #OurMalady
1/25. "In January, (the federal government) failed to do what was so obviously necessary: acquire a test for the new coronavirus and apply it on a massive scale in the United States." (#OurMalady, p. 85)
2/25. "As the year began, Americans were denied the basic knowledge they needed to make decisions on their own, or to press their government to take action." (#OurMalady, p. 86)
3/25. "(In January and February 2020), Mr. Trump praised himself while ignoring the warnings he was given." (#OurMalady, p. 86)
4/25. "On February 24th, Mr. Trump insisted that the coronavirus was under control. This was not true." (#OurMalady, p. 88)
5/25. "In early March (Mr. Trump) said that anyone who wanted a test could get tested. That was a lie. By the end of February the United States had only tested 352 people." (#OurMalady, p. 88)
6/25. "The time lost in stupefaction and mendacity, the first two months of 2020, could never be regained." (#OurMalady, p. 88)
7/25. "In any catastrophe, especially one of their own making, tyrants will find a mixture of blaming others and excusing themselves that includes an enticing element of what we want to hear." (#OurMalady, p. 89)
8/25. "In early 2020, people naturally wanted to hear that there was no coronavirus in the United States. But we cannot be free and deluded." (#OurMalady, p. 89)
9/25. "People lose life and liberty if they cannot identify a threat and make preparations." (#OurMalady, pp. 89-90)
10/25. "Not wanting to know means asking for oppression." (#OurMalady, p. 90)
11/25. "Not wanting to know about disease means asking politicians (...) to manipulate you with the emotions that accompany mass death." (#OurMalady, p. 90)
12/25. "It would have taken just a bit of effort, and just a bit of courage, to admit that there was a problem, and to organize tests and tracing. Since these were lacking, a hundred and fifty thousand Americans died needlessly." (#OurMalady, p. 90)
13/25. "This is how tyranny works: the truth tellers are banished as the sycophants huddle close." (#OurMalady, p. 91)
14/25. "Once Mr. Trump made it clear that his priority was to see low counts of infected Americans, the simplest way to please the tyrant was not to count." (#OurMalady, p. 91-92)
15/25. "Mr. Trump's unwillingness to test did not mean that we were healthy, only that we were ignorant." (#OurMalady, p. 92)
16/25. "China does bear responsibility for ignoring the reality of the outbreak. Yet American policy was to repeat China's mistakes, after China had made them, and for a far longer time. For that only Americans can be blamed." (#OurMalady, p. 95)
17/25. "The fact that we can all be infected, and the consequence that we can all be tested, take courage to face. Mr. Trump lacked courage, and too many of us followed his lead." (#OurMalady, p. 95)
18/25. "Once politicians embrace ignorance and death, their next move is to bluster and blame." (#OurMalady, p. 96)
19/25. "Politicians who summon mass death with their own actions, as Mr. Trump did, will present it as inevitable, not their fault, the work of enemies, and then apportion the death in a way that suits them." (#OurMalady, p. 96)
20/25. "Rather than extending health care to all, a tyrant will watch people die, and try to stay in power by riding the roiling emotions of the survivors." (#OurMalady, p. 96)
21/25. "A tyrant sees malady as opportunity, presenting himself as the rightful arbiter of life and death." (#OurMalady, p. 96)
22/25 "Mr Trump's behaviors followed the authoritarian pattern: denial of reality, the claim of magical immunity, the harassment of reporters, the transformation of a problem he caused into a loyalty test for others, the cultivation of fear as a political resource" #OurMalady p99
23/25. "In the end, authoritarians have little incentive to halt a pandemic, since they can thrive in an atmosphere of manipulated fear. The idea seems to be not to count Republicans who die, nor Democrats who vote." (#OurMalady, p. 100)
24/25. "Democracy is needed for public health, but a public health crisis in a weak democracy such as our own can be used to bring it down." (#OurMalady, p. 100)
25/25. "If fewer people vote in November 2020 this will be a crisis not only for democracy, but also for public health. If lies about illness lead to authoritarianism, we can expect more illness and more lies." (#OurMalady, p. 100)
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
1/5 If Trump wanted Russia to negotiate, he would make the war harder for the Kremlin, not create the conditions for Russian victory. I wish reporters would point this out. cnn.com/2024/12/12/pol…
2/5 Putin has made clear over and over that his goal is to destroy Ukraine as a nation and a state and that he has no interest in peace talks.
3/5 Trump’s proposed policy is to force Ukraine to negotiate by denying it weapons otherwise. But the Ukrainians are not the problem! The problem is Russia, the aggressor.
1/6 Dr. Helen Ouyang in @nytimes: “The country is not heading toward a single-payer system, but that doesn’t mean we have to continue leaving patients and their doctors in the dark.”
Yes, it does in fact mean that, absent some other drastic reform.
2/6 It doesn’t help to write and publish essays like this, which present doctors and patients as good people facing tragic choices in an unchangeable system. How the system works to kill Americans for profit has to be front and center.
3/6 Only the US among comparable countries enables useless middlemen to profit hugely by placing themselves between doctor and patient. We have to be reminded that we are uniquely choosing a senseless system that takes both our wealth and our lives.
1/4. Important work here: Trump is violent rather than strong, and using US troops on protesters would break America. nytimes.com/2024/08/17/us/…
2/4. Crucial point in the reporting: the most radical plans, such as the use of US troops against Americans, actually go beyond Project 2025. nytimes.com/2024/08/17/us/…
3/4. A point not raised here is the effect that orders to suppress American protesters would have on the military itself. Either it resists or it becomes a tool of fascist power.