Sayed Tabatabai, MD Profile picture
Sep 12, 2020 22 tweets 5 min read Read on X
((For part one of this story, please see below.

When we left our dynamic duo, they were investigating the disappearance of Lord Simon Byron.

Sherlock seemed convinced of foul play, but was stunned when the Lord appeared safe and sound...))
Forgive me, dear reader. I have committed that most egregious of errors in story-telling.

The mistake that drives Holmes mad with irritation.

Even now, I can hear his voice in my head, “Watson, start at the beginning! How can I deduce anything without a complete picture?” 1/
So let me start at the beginning.

The year is 1890.

My name is John H. Watson, and I am a physician and former army man. A bullet in the Battle of Maiwand a decade ago gave me a limp, and an honorable discharge.

Sherlock Holmes is my friend.

Together, we solve mysteries. 2/
This case, which I shall refer to as The Invisible Army, begins simply enough.

Sherlock and I are screening potential cases at 221B Baker Street, our flat.

Mired in the depths of boredom, without an interesting case for weeks, Sherlock is insufferable.

“Watson, I’m dying.” 3/
I set down the newspaper I’m reading and look at him, “Sherlock, you’re bored.”

This seems to vex the Great Detective, and he sinks lower in his seat until half his body is out of it.

“You’re a doctor, Watson. Surely you can see my intellect withering away. I’m DYING.” 4/
Dealing with Holmes when he’s like this is like dealing with a child. Distraction is helpful.

“Holmes, what about that interesting case that woman brought to us? Her husband gone missing?”

Holmes snorts derisively, “Boring.”

“Yes but it seemed mysterious and-“

“BORING!” 5/
I exhale deeply, summoning every last ounce of my patience, “Well, what about the theater manager and the disappearance of his acting t-“

“Watson. This is London. People go missing every day. That’s why we have Scotland Yard. These aren’t worthy of me.”

“But-“

“BORING!” 6/
“Fine, Sherlock, if you want to wallow in self-pity, you’re welcome to it! I, on the other hand, would rather not waste my time.” And I fold my newspaper under my arm and rise to my feet, grabbing my cane.

Holmes grunts something unintelligible, his face in his hands. 7/
As I reach the door, it opens to reveal Mrs. Hudson.

“Dr. Watson,” she smiles, and I can’t help but smile in return, “I’m so glad I caught you. There’s a letter that just arrived, addressed to you and Sherlock.”

“Thank you Mrs. Hudson,” I take the envelope with a nod. 8/
Turning to Sherlock, I raise the envelope, “Interested Holmes? It says “urgent” on it.”

Sherlock sighs exaggeratedly, “Everything is always urgent, Watson. God, why is life so DULL? I need a challenge! And some cocaine.”

“No! No cocaine, Holmes, someone needs you.” 9/
Sherlock quirks a brow, getting up to snatch the envelope from me before I open it, “I swear Watson, if this is another waste of my talents I will do something entirely unreasonable!”

I watch Sherlock’s face as he reads the letter, and something familiar starts happening. 10/
His eyes narrow, his aquiline nose twitching as his nostrils flare. I’ve seen this look before, many times.

Sherlock is deep in a deduction.

He rubs his chin pensively for a long moment, before handing me the letter.

“Here, you read it Watson, tell me what you observe.” 11/
I look at the piece of paper first before I read the writing.

It is thicker, of a finer quality than the usual low grade stock of most notebooks.

Bringing it to my nose, I sniff. A faint floral scent lingers, barely there at all, strongest at the rightmost edge.

I read it. 12/
“Mr. Holmes. Your presence is requested urgently at Chatsfield Manor. Things are not what they seem.”

The handwriting is lovely, tightly lettered with a flowing script.

The only flaw is the occasional smudge, smearing towards the right.

No signature, no address, no date. 13/
“Well Watson,” Sherlock is sitting up now, his entire demeanor transformed by the thrill of the mystery, “Your thoughts?”

“Written by a woman, most likely, a wealthy one. Seems to be left-handed, and she wrote in a great hurry as the smudges seem uncharacteristic of her.” 14/
I feel rather proud of my deductions, but Sherlock quickly dashes my pride.

“Yes, quite elementary. What did you think of the message itself, Watson?”

“Well. Not much to go on.”

“Exactly! It seems to say so very little. And in doing so, it actually speaks volumes!” 15/
I quirk a brow, and wait for Sherlock to elaborate, which he can never resist doing.

“You see Watson, if it was so urgent, why not just send a telegram? Why gamble on a letter I might easily have tossed aside? And why make no mention of the issue at hand? Why hide it?” 16/
I shrug, “Perhaps she knows your love of mystery and didn’t want to bore you with the mundane?”

Sherlock nods pensively, “Perhaps she knows me. But I believe whoever wrote this is in danger herself. She couldn’t trust a telegram, and she can’t trust those around her.” 17/
Sherlock trails off, and the silence in the room grows, punctuated only by the light tapping of his heel against his chair.

Finally, he rises to his feet.

“Come Watson. This shall be our case. Before we go to Chatsfield, we must research the manor and its Lord.” 18/
I frown, feeling a twinge of disappointment in my old friend, “Why Sherlock? Is it because they’re wealthy? Why wouldn’t you accept any of the other cases? Do the problems of the common man hold no value? Only the rich?”

Sherlock pauses, as if contemplating my words. 19/
“No, Watson. Quite the opposite. Our society follows a rigid class system, to the point that nobody truly sees anyone for who they are. We only ever see the roles they play, according to their class. I see no class, Watson, I see people as they are. Always, as they are.” 20/
I repeat my question, “So why this case?”

He smiles faintly, “Because it needs me to solve it. The others can be handled by Lestrade. This one is for me.”

“How can you be sure?”

“In time, all will be revealed. For now, grab your things Dr. Watson! We leave at once...”

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Sayed Tabatabai, MD

Sayed Tabatabai, MD Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @TheRealDoctorT

Oct 31
Sometimes I like to look at the people on the other side of the glass.

I watch them as they live their lives.

Trusting in the world around them, trusting that the sun will rise.

I used to trust too. But trust can take you places.

Places you never wanted to go. 1/
It’s 2004. I’m an intern, fresh out of med school.

So far the experience of being an actual honest-to-goodness bonafide doctor has been a mixed bag.

Some days are encouraging. But I’m struggling with imposter syndrome.

I didn’t know the M.D. stood for “Mostly Depressed.” 2/
I don’t know that I really believed in imposter syndrome before. The idea seemed silly. After all the work I’ve put in, how can I doubt myself?

Turns out it’s not that hard.

Every nurse seems to see right through my incompetence. Patients want to see the “older doctor.” 3/
Read 25 tweets
Sep 23
I glance down at the paperwork my patient has filled out before his visit.

Occupation: Retired harbour master.

Two things: I’ve never met a harbor master before. And “harbour” with a “u.”

Interesting.

It’s the little everyday mysteries that I love most. That reveal us. 1/
He’s almost 100 years old, and yet he springs up from his seat when I enter the room. He shakes my hand so firmly I can feel the sting in my knuckles.

His smile is ear to ear, and his eyes are bright.

“Doctor, how are ya? Good to see you!”

I can’t help but smile, “Hello!” 2/
As I take a seat, I instinctively pull my seat closer to his.

With my patient population, I’ve learned to sit closer, to speak slower, and louder. Be direct.

Sometimes I forget to switch this off. Sometimes younger patients wince and tell me to stop yelling at them.

Sorry. 3/
Read 17 tweets
Nov 14, 2023
To all those students who’ve had a question, but worried that it’s too obvious, or unnecessary, or worst of all, stupid…

Ask.

As someone who answers questions for a living, let me tell you something about questions.

They’re more than just questions. 1/
Every question asked is a spark. A sign. That wheels are turning. That thoughts are following a thread.

Even if it’s the wrong thread, you won’t know until you ask.

Questions give us pause.

Questions give us chances.

Chances to review. To reframe. To re-evaluate. 2/
Wrapped up within every question is an opportunity.

An opportunity to see things through different eyes.

An opportunity to do better, to be better.

It’s the ones who don’t ask questions that I worry about.

It’s the ones who don’t ask questions who make me nervous. 3/
Read 6 tweets
Oct 31, 2023
I went into medicine to help people.

No, really, I did. I know it sounds corny now, or fake, I suppose. But there was a reason for this.

At least once.

I have to keep telling myself that. Keep remembering that.

Because I’m running out of time.

And I want you to know. 1/
Anyways, backtrack. I’m a radiologist. I spent years training to be able to look at imaging and see a vast variety of problems.

I’m not one to boast, but I’m pretty good at what I do.

You might even say I’m gifted.

But some gifts… well, they come back to bite you. 2/
Be systematic. That’s my mantra. Be systematic, always. It’s the discipline of the thing.

I will never meet most of the patients whose studies I review, but I still feel a certain… attachment.

A responsibility to do my best.

Being systematic means I don’t miss anything. 3/
Read 22 tweets
Apr 24, 2023
On the morning of his 95th birthday, Joe woke up at exactly 6AM.

This small irony never failed to irritate him: he had never been a morning person, but the more the years passed, the earlier he woke.

“Well, this is it!” He said, to no one, as he swung his legs out of bed. 1/
He brushed his teeth methodically, a small timer telling him when it had been exactly three minutes.

Rinsing out his mouth, he couldn’t help but smile as he thought of the day ahead.

The last day.

Joe had made up his mind years ago that his 95th birthday would be his last. 2/
He wasn’t suicidal, mind you, he enjoyed life and had no intention of killing himself.

He was just tired. He had no friends left, no family. And he had always been a sociable man.

Life just didn’t excite him anymore. He’d seen it all, done it all.

He missed his wife. 3/
Read 24 tweets
Feb 20, 2023
I have only ever known you within the confines of this exam room in my office.

Years ago, you were sent to me for a consultation.

Understandably nervous, you had all your questions written out on a notepad in your spidery handwriting.

You believe in being organized. 1/
As we go through each question, one by one, you cross it off your list.

I have questions for you too. For one, I want to know where you got your glasses. I need new frames.

It makes you smile for the first time in the visit.

As if perhaps things might be okay.

Maybe. 2/
The years pass. I only ever see you when you come to my office for a followup.

You still write your questions down, but with the passing of time, there are fewer and fewer.

I know you exist outside this exam room, as a whole person. And that’s who I try to get to know. 3/
Read 10 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us!

:(