This Manusmriti is a very big tool which is used by non Hindus to show Vedic hinduism as casteist !! I have debated with a lot of the anti hindus and challenged them to show me instances from Vedas, Puranas, Itihasas which they could not. However they simply throw passages.
Now the problem is I am yet to see a genuine Manusmriti. People show translated Manusmriti, abridged ones and shady versions.

They quote some random verses from Manusmriti about all kinds of random punishments to be given to lower castes.
For eg. they say Manusmriti said lead should be poured in ears of Shudras who hear Vedas. If this were true, we should have such incidences reported in at least one of the other religious texts, which there is no mention.
Therefore this cannot be true as none of the other Hindu books even hint at such discrimination from Vedas, Puranas, Itihasas. Except for the concocted story of Sambhuka in a added 7th Khanda in Ramayana.
How is it possible that rest of Vedas, Puranas, Itihasas dont talk about any kind of discrimination or cruelty but Manusmriti according to these guys has cartload of such things.?? They are using some totally concocted Manusmriti.
Where is the real Manusmriti ? What does it actually say ?

If it is so casteist then why are Vedas and other books are almost free of them with no birth based Varna system or blatant caste based discrimiation ?
If someone comes up with a copy of Manusmriti how do we know it is the actual one?

If it has been totally distorted, then how do we get the real Manusmriti.

Can we dispel this confusion once for all.

Original post :…

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh

Keep Current with Indu Makkal Katchi - இந்து மக்கள் கட்சி ( Off )

Indu Makkal Katchi - இந்து மக்கள் கட்சி ( Off ) Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!


Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @Indumakalktchi

23 Sep
"புரட்சி என்பது மரபுகளை மாற்றுவது இல்லை மரபுகளை பலப்படுத்தல்" என்று ஒரு பதிவின் மறுமொழியில் ஒருவர் எழுதுகிறார். ஆகா பிரமாதம் என்று மற்றொருவர் அதை ஆமோதிக்கிறார். அட, நல்ல சூப்பர் தத்து(பித்து)வமா இருக்கே என்று சிலர்.

மரணக் காமெடி என்றால் இதுதான்.
"புரட்சி" என்ற சொல்லையே பாரதியார் தான் உருவாக்கினார்.

அதற்கு முன்பு அந்தச் சொல் தமிழில் கிடையாது. புரள் என்ற வினைச்சொல்லிலிருந்து அது வருகிறது - புரட்டுதல், தலைகீழாக்குதல், புதுமை, மாற்றம், upsetting, overturning என்பதே அதன் பொருள்.
Revolution என்ற ஆங்கிலச் சொல்லுக்கு இணையான ஒரு சக்திமிகுந்த சொல்லாக பாரதி அதைப் பயன்படுத்தினார். அதற்கு இப்படி 180 degree முற்றிலும் நேர்மாறான ஒரு பொருளைக் கற்பனை செய்து இந்த நண்பர் கூறுகிறார்.
Read 5 tweets
23 Sep
Monitoring Foreign Funds - NGOs

India’s Foreign Contribution Regulation Act ( FRCA ) , which was formed in 1976, is felt by officials as out dated in present day situs. For years India has known that foreign funded organisation have been indulging in subversive activies.
Following Kargil , Shri Vajpayee appointed a group of ministers to review national security system. Observing that foreign funded activities was THE major threat to internal security and realesed in 2001 a revision
It wants Ministry of Home Affaires to monitor to control the flow of funds into the NGOs

Yet taking action against these NGOs has still not been realised cause it was framed as “ religious persecution “ by the global nexus of Christianity operating in India.
Read 13 tweets
19 Sep
Most youngsters born in the 21st century wouldn't even be aware of this brand, let alone trying or using it. But this is a legendary product which ruled the roost throughout the 20th century, and kept all dental ailments at bay. Image
The origins of it lies in the vision of the Wodeyar Royal Family of Mysore Kingdom who promoted ancient Indian Sciences including Yoga & Ayurveda.

Way back in the 1890s, Wodeyars, as part of their long term plans to revive Hindu traditions,
had established Mysore Ayurvedic College which produced several Practitioners and Entrepreneurs who brought Ayurveda closer to the masses. BV Pundit was one such Scholar who graduated from the very first batch of Mysore Ayurvedic College and
Read 12 tweets
19 Sep
*To Understand the colonial mind game first understand history*

British had three entry points in Bharat. They cleverly used a social fault line in all three places to create long term breaking Indic momentum. It was a genius move that works as pays dividends till today!
*1. Bengal Presidency*: Created Brahmo Samaj & subtly admonished idolatry & promoted atrocity literature. Highlighted one off crimes as a endemic nature of Indic society. This was useful to showcase themselves as cultured and Indics as barbarians.
*2. Madras Presidency:* Created Aryan-Dravidian theory using completely fake science and Max Mueller. Even after modern science has made serious dents in this theory it’s still taught formally and is a source of divisive politics in South.
Read 8 tweets
13 Sep
How many of you have heard of the Jesuit Filipino Priest SAM Lourdu Samy?

Did you know that he is 82 years old and has lived in Jharkand, Ranchi for many, many years and that the Samy in his name has morphed into Swamy?
Sam Lourdu Samy, Filipino Jesuit Priest is also one of the accused in planning to assassinate PM Modi..He is Accused of treason ,terrorism and complicity with Maoists Guerillas and Naxals amongst other crimes.
Now why would a foreign Jesuit Priest, a so called man of God...want to interfere with the governance of this country? Why would he want to assassinate a sitting PM? Who is empowering him in these seditious activities?
Read 21 tweets
4 Sep
In the early 60s, Intelligence agencies & the Calcutta Police arrested a spy of Pakistan. A diary was recovered from that spy and the name registered in the diary was of a film star. The Calcutta Police went to his home in Bombay but due to the intervention of some people
nothing was reported and the conclusion drawn was that the spy was just a fan of that film star. The surprising fact is that the Calcutta Police did not receive this divine knowledge during the enquiry.
But the talk does not end here. Intelligence agencies in Bombay had intercepted some signals of a radio transmitter in Bombay with a contact with Pakistan. The transmitter was active in Bombay only. The house where the device was recovered from belonged to the same film star.
Read 7 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!

This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!