1/ Brilliant thread by 007 explaining why the educated, young, white-collar Indians support the regressive right-wing!

"A large section of the India's so-called educated middle-class is socially regressive and shows support for demagogues and opposes progressive
2/ values. People wonder why this is so.

I however, wonder why this is surprising. It's clear as day. It's all in our education system.

The other day, on a Whatsapp group, a software engineer - a school friend - shared a meme that pretty much said that rising petrol prices
3/ are okay because at least the bjp is saving us from Bangladeshis and Rohingyas and suchlike.

Before that, a doctor - another school friend and a trained psychiatrist - said that I had violated his freedom of expression by blocking him on Facebook. I had blocked him because
4/ even after multiple warnings, he had been spamming my comment threads with the defence of a rapist.

When I told him that freedom of expression is something that exists between him and the state and not between him and me, he didn't get it. He didn't understand that freedom
5/ of expression didn't mean he was free to spew vile bilge on other people's social profiles.

I want to try to explain this lack of understanding. And this is not just a lack of understanding. It's a full on denial, not just of facts, but of the ways of thinking that the
6/ humanities teach.

These boys were science students. They spent their school lives focusing on science and math and did reasonably well there. They targeted technical careers and got through. They worked towards building "stable" futures for themselves as defined by our
7/ middle-class sensibility.

They are products (and supporters) of a system that looks down upon the arts and the humanities. They devoted themselves to technical skills in a society where arts students were destined for failure. They studied math and physics and medicine and
8/ became doctors and engineers.

They made it. They won. Their families demanded large dowries for them because they had that much social capital on account of being doctors and engineers. They weren't failures like arts students.

And what did the arts kids do? They resigned
9/ themselves to "second rate" lives.

Lives that society had assigned to them. They studied history, sociology, political science, and economics. The broad view - the disciplines that form the foundations of human culture - were all that was left to the arts students.

10/ out of nowhere, the internet happened. It was the early 2000s and blogs and an infant social media universe came into being. It wasn't tech heavy. The arts students liked it. For the first time since school, they had a playground.

They had avenues to explore their subjects
11/ with a level of depth their schools had never provided and their colleges couldn't care less about. And because many of them couldn't afford a liberal arts education abroad (this is small town India), they made the best of the internet.

They studied, read, communicated with
12/ experts, and even began to use the web to publish their own work and find their voice. They started getting what had been denied to them by our education system - a sense of self worth, and even the right to consider themselves intelligent.

There was no roadmap for them to
13/ follow. So they taught themselves and went into journalism, advertising, writing, and law. They became web publishers. They started websites. They began to mould a kind of heaven from the hell that they had been condemned to.

Now, the science students - the ones who had
14/ been too good for the humanities once, want a piece of this pie. The public discourse pie. The place where much of the talk is about politics, economics, history, and media. Many of them find they can't. They lack the education for it.

And they JUST CAN'T DIGEST IT because
15/ their lives have been lives of educational privilege. They have always been the top rung of Indian society. They were brought up on the lie that they are better than everyone else. They have always been the ones destined for "success".

For the first time in their privileged
16/ lives, they find themselves having to contend with the fact that they might not actually be good at everything. On an average day, it is hard to get these people to shut up about their houses and their salaries and their houses.

On days when the talking point is politics or
17/ economics or some other matter that they threw away because only girls study arts, they are positively sick with FOMO. They feel left out.

So is it any surprise that our "educated" middle-class is raging against "media" and "intellectuals" and "experts" and "stars" and
18/ "writers" and "artists"?

Make no mistake. This is the cream of India's educational caste system fighting back against its lost privilege.

So it's not surprising at all that an alternate ecosystem has popped up to cater to the insecurities of the "science stream caste". It
19/ tells them they are victims. It feeds them sweet nothings from morning till night over WhatsApp.

Remember that the Right Wing was the first to start waging war on the tech and social media fronts. They started the first blogs and had the first IT cells. They were the ones
20/ with armies of software engineers.

Cut to: 2018. Tell a software guy holding forth about politics and economics on a WhatsApp group that he is wrong about something and you'll get called an "elitist" or a "liberal".

Tell a doctor that what he has written makes sense on
21/ neither the logical level nor the grammatical one and he will ask you what makes you an expert and the fact that correct grammar is just a way for liberals to establish their superiority.

Now flip it. Imagine an arts student lecturing them about their areas of expertise -
22/ engineering or medicine. They would be justified in calling it out because the boy who studied economics and literature is not qualified to comment on these topics. He simply lacks the education.

Why is it then, that privileged members of the science caste consider
23/ themselves capable of holding forth on humanities subjects even though they never had that education? They literally rejected that education. They were applauded for not being interested.

I'll tell you why.

The doctors and engineers I am talking about didn't value the
24/ humanities when they were in school and college. And they don't value them now.

You will have to physically restrain them to keep them from boasting about the fact that they WON the race of life. But when it comes to things that the arts kids do, they seem to be of the view
25/ "ye sab toh koi bhi kar sakta hai".

In the present political and social climate, intellectuals, liberals, media persons, and artists are not being vilified because of the things they are saying.

They are the villains because in the eyes of the science caste, they were
26/ never supposed to amount to anything. They were supposed to be amusements, sources of entertainment, and cautionary tales for them to scare their children with so that they never choose the arts.

In many ways, this "ye sab toh koi bhi kar sakta hai" thinking permeates our
27/ entire culture. People don't think art is worth money. People tell designers to work for free because it "can't possibly be that hard".

But the worst possible consequence of our attitude towards the humanities is currently playing out in the political and social arena. Our
28/ "educated middle class", thanks to a lack of education, is screwing us over."

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh

Keep Current with RAVIKANTH S

RAVIKANTH S Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!


Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @RavikanthS_

21 Sep
From the wall of Musa Sayyed;

"Please Note Very Important Notice :
If someone in a close relative / friends circle has *died* due to Covid-19 or *for any reason*, ask the bank for an account statement or passbook entry from *01-04 to 31-03* of the financial year. Image
Seeing the entry of Rs. 12/- or Rs. 330/- *, mark it,*.
Go to the bank and Claim for Insurance.
*My Humble Request to All of You is that if such cases happen around you,* immediately inform the family who may have Closed the Account after Death.
Even if the premium has been Deducted in that period.
*In the Year 2015, the Government of India provided Two Insurance Schemes with Least Premium to the Savings Account Holders of All the Banks :
*Pradhan Mantri Jeevan Jyoti Bima
Read 6 tweets
21 Sep
When the government is saying it has freed the farmer to sell to anyone at any price, what it is essentially saying is that although it will still announce the MSP, it will not be under any obligation to buy anything other than what it wants. Image
Essentially what that means is citing shortage of storage spaces and over flowing storage silos of FCI, government may not buy anything.

This will leave the farmers in the lurch. That is why they have hit the road.
All the farmers want is that government announce an MSP and then buy 100% of their produce at a plus/minus 10% of that price. They are completely comfortable with that. What the government can do is implement this and then let the Adani's and Ambani's
Read 8 tweets
21 Sep
1/ 007


Sometime ago friend, a well known strategist, called to ask about the clandestine activities across the Himalaya's and in particular our IB and later RAW's co-operation with the CIA. I told him what he needed to know. But I
2/ also dusted up this review of the book "Spies in the Himalayas" by Kohli and Conboy. (Harper Collins). India's co-operation with the CIA, that till 1965 gave it permission to fly U-2 spy planes from Charbatia in Orissa, was the begining of the Aviation Research Centre of the
3/ RAW that continued with the aerial snooping of China in Tibet and Xinjiang.

Prior to the 1962 war, the CIA was training Tibetan Khampa fighters in Colorado and begab para-dropping them into Tibet from 1957 to wage war on the Chinese occupiers. The US aircraft were flying
Read 44 tweets
21 Sep
Where do the poor go from here?

There are poor and then there are poor. There are poor who are farmers, they have been lured into producing cash crops and getting hard currency which they never needed. They have been sold a dream, a life where cities shine in the Image
distance, where people live in luxury, eat chocolates and have shining expensive cars, where houses have air-conditioning and life is such a breeze. They aspire for such a life, if not for themselves at least for their kids.
They use the cash crops to put their children into expensive schools, forgetting that they themselves went to government schools. They forget that the education system is not designed to create thinkers but only mediocre clerks that will have a poor life in the cities.
Read 10 tweets
21 Sep


Opportunity cost or just another Opportunity to defame?
2/ Opportunity cost is the cost of any activity measured in terms of the value of the next best or available alternative that is not chosen. The CAG, Vinod Rai, has used this concept to arrive at his estimate of an Rs.176, 000 crores loss in allotting the 2G spectrum. To arrive
3/ at this huge figure, there can be little doubt that Rai used the pithy logic of Benjamin Franklin explaining the cost of an action: “He that kills a breeding sow, destroys all her offspring to the thousandth generation.”

But the problem with this logic is that the State is
Read 22 tweets
20 Sep
1/ Himanshu Pandya brings this good news of a long fought battle ....

"At the time of the Atal Bihari government, the disinvestment ministry was created and government properties were sold at a quarter to a million. Don't know how much the sellers ate in it. It was a
2/ misconduct.

Vedanta Group bought Hindustan Zinc in Udaipur. Legend has it that he had recovered the purchase amount by selling only junk of the purchased plant. Hindustan Zinc Limited was not only in profit but it was a hen laying a golden egg for the government which was
3/ converted.

Only then, another valuable property was sold in Udaipur - Lakshmi Vilas Hotel. His estimated value was 250 crores (his estate included an entire hill on the banks of Fateh Sagar). Then how much of that property was sold - only seven crores! Yes, only seven
Read 7 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!

This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!