“The Electoral College, in short, is organized on precisely the same principle as the United States Congress, and for precisely the same reason. Neither institution recognizes population alone as the exclusive measuring rod for democratic legitimacy...americanmind.org/essays/as-the-…
Because the presidency is connected to the rest of the constitutional system, candidates must think about the unique structure of the nation they seek to lead. And because the states, whether small or large, are the principal presidential battlegrounds, candidates accommodate...
interests that might otherwise be ignored if the size of the popular vote were the only criterion for election. It is argued that, as the president represents ‘all the people,’ he ought to be elected by the people considered as a single national mass...
But that conclusion conveniently ignores the federated nature of the American republic. Campaigning in New Hampshire is very different from campaigning in California, and representing ‘all the people’ means representing them no less as Texans or New Yorkers than as citizens of...
an undifferentiated whole. Once the states are removed from the presidential election system, these important and celebrated features of political locale will lose much of their significance. Voters in the less populous states, indeed in any area that cannot be readily subsumed..
in a mass media market, will be of decidedly secondary importance to presidential candidates. As John F. Kennedy said in defending the Electoral College in the 1950s, changing the mode of presidential election affects not only presidential candidates...
but the whole solar system of our constitutional and political arrangements—in ways that are difficult to predict but unlikely to be beneficial. With a national plebiscite, the customary ties that bind state and local party units to national campaigns will necessarily dissolve.”

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh

Keep Current with The American Mind

The American Mind Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!


Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @theammind

25 Sep
“Our Intel agencies are the deep state’s deepest part, & the most immediate threat to representative govt. They’re also not very good at what they are supposed to be doing. Protecting the Republic from them requires refocusing them on their proper jobs...americanmind.org/essays/abolish…
Intel officials abuse their positions to discredit opposition to the Dem Party, of which they are part. Complicit w/media, they leverage the public’s mistaken faith in their knowledge, competence, & patriotism to vilify their domestic enemies from behind secrecy’s shield...
Pretenses of superior knowledge have always tempted the Administrative State’s officials to manipulate or override voters. Hence, as Justice Robert H. Jackson (who served as chief prosecutor of the Nuremberg trials) warned, they often turn their powers against whomever they...
Read 7 tweets
5 Sep
“Democrats are laying the groundwork for revolution right in front of our eyes. As if 2020 were not insane enough already, we now have Democrats and their ruling class masters openly talking about staging a coup.” Michael Anton explains. americanmind.org/essays/the-com…
Recall, “over the summer a story was deliberately leaked to the press of a meeting at which 100 Democratic grandees, anti-Trump former Republicans, and other ruling class apparatchiks got together (on Soros’s dime) to ‘game out’ various outcomes of the 2020 election.”
“One such outcome was a clear Trump win. In that eventuality, John Podesta, playing Biden, refused to concede, pressured states that Trump won to send Democrats to the formal Electoral College vote, & trusted that the military would take care of the rest.” americanmind.org/essays/sleepwa…
Read 7 tweets
1 Sep
"It is time to stop pretending that BLM and Antifa are anything other than domestic terrorist groups led by radicals who seek to rip America apart." - @docMJP americanmind.org/features/the-r…
"The big foundations in America have been funding violent leftist radicals for a long time, and they too are now doubling down—not in denial, like many well-meaning but ignorant or cowardly Americans are, but in their payments to those willing to foment civic unrest."
"Most Americans still do not realize that what is now occurring on American soil is not an organic civil rights movement, but an elite-funded effort to destabilize the American way of life as we’ve known it: the complete overhaul of the principles of our justice system...
Read 4 tweets
31 Aug
If President Trump loses the election, what will America become? Michael Anton answers this question and more. americanmind.org/essays/a-tyran…
“Most plausible outcome would be a return to the ‘neoliberal’ consensus & trajectory circa 2015. Meaning, a governing ideology that is top-down, bureaucratic, & anti-democratic, committed to social engineering and grievance politics, while undermining virtue & promoting vice.”
“Neoliberalism elevates as a matter of ‘principle’ the international over the national; it rejects the latter as narrow, particular, cramped, even bigoted, and celebrates the former as cosmopolitan and enlightened.”
Read 14 tweets
24 Aug
The outrageous irresponsibility of the Democratic party in partnership with domestic terrorist activists is leading directly to more violence, looting, & arson in yet another American city...this will be the new normal unless the Right puts its foot down. americanmind.org/post/riots-are…
Another tragic but incomplete video—this time of police shooting an uncooperative criminal w/a warrant out for his arrest after he lunged into his car—is being shamelessly used by the Left to inflame the populace. Another cowardly Dem Governor has thrown police under the bus...
Sunday night in Kenosha, Wisconsin, activists tried to burn down a courthouse. Bricks were thrown at officers, a car dealership was looted, vandalized, & set ablaze. And that was just the beginning, although most Americans did not hear about it from the press on Monday...
Read 5 tweets
22 Aug
To the @GOP: If you care about the American people, and winning the election on their behalf, here are four points to consider between now and the #RepublicanConvention. americanmind.org/post/to-war-go…
First, you need to announce you are mounting a counter-revolution against the Left & acknowledge the stakes. Enough defense. Enough capitulation on matters great & small. Rather (in broad outline): attack the Democrats’ militant message of Potemkin multiculturalism at every turn.
Loudly & utterly reject political correctness/identity politics & embrace freedom of thought & equality under the law instead. GOP alternative cannot be vapid/bob flotsam-like on the surface level of policy. It needs to go deeper. Create an overall theme. americanmind.org/features/prese…
Read 7 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!

This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!