On the Feast of the Exaltation of the Cross, I promised a thread summarizing a scientific refutation of John Calvin's haughty and presumptuous claims against the authenticity of relics of the True Cross. A little late, but here it is.
First, you've probably heard Calvin's argument, even if you didn't know the source. In Calvin's 1543 "Traité des Reliques" ('Treatise on Relics') he writes the following, which has achieved a tired and unexamined memetic repetition, like so many arguments of the Reformation:
"There is no abbey so poor as not to have a specimen [of the Cross]. In some places there are large fragments, as at the Holy Chapel in Paris, at Poitiers, and at Rome, where a good-sized crucifix is said to have been made of it...
"In brief, if all the pieces that could be found were collected together, they would make a big ship-load. Yet the Gospel testifies that a single man was able to carry it."
Modern research and the application of scientific reason proves this assertion laughably wrong.

Charles Rohault de Fleury (1801–1875), a French architect and engineer who dabbled in Christian archaeology in his later years, put the claim to the test.
You can find the results of his research in his 1870 book, "Memoire sur les instruments de la passion de N.-S. J.-C." ('Memorial of the Instruments of the Passion of Our Lord Jesus Christ'): archive.org/details/Instru…
The work contains an erudite summary of all we know, from ancient and medieval sources, of the discovery of the Cross and the diffusion of its relics around the world.

You'll also find some very interesting diagrams summarizing the relative size and format of these relics.
De Fleury's first task was to estimate the volume of the original Cross. He supposed that it would have been perhaps 10 to 13 feet in height, with a cross branch of 6 ½ feet wide, proportions reasonable for the gruesome task of crucifying an adult man.
This also happens to be the size of the cross at the Basilica of Santa Croce in Rome, identified as the Cross of the Good Thief.
Figuring the weight of the Cross would be a little more difficult, as it depends on the type of wood. De Fleury figured that it was pine wood (based on his examination of some of the relics), but also made a guess based on factors recorded in the Gospels.
He reasoned that Jesus, as a fit carpenter, could carry 220 pounds of lumber on his shoulder 150 feet before stopping to rest.

Thus he concluded that the Cross may have weighed about 220 pounds, but since it was probably dragged, it would have *felt* like 55 or 60 pounds.
Nonetheless, in his weakened condition after the scourging, even this modest weight would have been too much for Jesus, and so the Roman guards compelled Simon of Cyrene to help carry the Cross.
Once he had estimated the weight of the Cross, Fleury calculated its size, or more accurately, its volume, which came to 178 million cubic millimeters, or 10,862 cubic inches.
But the total volume of known relics of the True Cross, according to his thorough catalogue (which I encourage you to examine in the scanned book, linked above), amounted to a mere 3,941,975 cubic millimeters, or 240.5 cubic inches.
This number surprised him, so he made a generous allowance for fragments that were in private hands or otherwise had not come to his attention, as well as fragments that had been lost over the centuries or destroyed in war or during the vandalism of the Reformation.
Thus he multiplied his original number by *ten* and arrived at a new figure: perhaps 2,400 cubic inches — still not even a fifth of the estimated size of the Cross upon which Christ was crucified.

And hardly a ship-load.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh

Keep Current with Fʀ. A. J. D. Sᴄʜʀᴇɴᴋ

Fʀ. A. J. D. Sᴄʜʀᴇɴᴋ Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!


Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @frajds

14 Aug
"Holy Mass at Auschwitz" (Jan Baraś-Komski, undated). Komski was an inmate at the camp. Image
"Masses were secretly celebrated in the camp... I know that they began to be said late in the autumn of 1941: in November and early in December 1941. […] I also had an opportunity to celebrate the Mass, and this was at 4 o'clock on the first day of Christmas 1941.
"I celebrated it in my striped uniform in the attic of Block 3 in the presence of several inmate-colleagues I knew and trusted. I had hosts and wine, and an ordinary glass had to make up for the chalice. Those present at the Mass received Holy Communion."

—Fr. Władysław Puczka
Read 14 tweets
17 Jul
Let's take a look at what I believe to be the finest and most beautiful pew missal produced in the US before the Council — the 1957 Maryknoll "Daily Missal of the Mystical Body."
As you can see above, it's bound in supple Morocco leather. More than sixty years later and it's not deteriorating at all. The endsheets are a robust watered black fabric (silk?) and the gilding is high quality (though admittedly not of the highest possible quality).
For ease of use, the very first page you see contains the prayers before Mass. These are put even before the title page.
Read 13 tweets
4 Jun
Never forget Otto Wagner's Kirche am Steinhof, the glorious triumph of ecclesiastical Art Nouveau.
The high altar is encircled by a partial ciborium and the apse decorated with a mosaic of Christ in majesty. St. Leopold, surrounded by an entourage of saints, offers a votive image of the church, as the building is consecrated in his honor.
The metal canopy over the altar can be lit, as it has been fitted with electric light. This provides a spectacular effect when the church is darkened.
Read 21 tweets
9 Mar
Wondering how our ancestors in faith responded to epidemics? It helps to look at a period of history that had some knowledge of what communicable disease is and how it spreads. This is what the parish of St. Augustine in Washington, D.C. did in 1918:
What was happening in Ontario?

Source: books.google.com/books?id=8xAVA…
Read 7 tweets
8 Mar
A protective cross against the plague, given the approbation of the Council of Trent
+ O Cross of Christ, save me.

Z. May zeal for your house free me.

+ The Cross conquers; the Cross reigns; the Cross rules; by the sign of the Cross free me, O Lord, from this plague.
D. God, my God, drive this plague away from me, and from this place, and free me.

I. In your hands, O Lord, I commend my spirit, my heart, and my body.

A. Before heaven and earth God was; and God is able to liberate me from his plague.
Read 23 tweets
3 Mar
St. Aloysius Gonzaga died at the age of 23 caring for victims of the plague in Rome.
When the plague broke out, the Jesuits opened a hospital for the stricken, and Aloysius volunteered to work there. After begging alms for the victims, he began working directly with the sick, carrying the dying from the streets into the hospital.
He washed and fed the victims, preparing them as best he could to receive the sacraments. Though he threw himself into his tasks, he told his spiritual director, (St.) Robert Bellarmine, that he was revolted by what he saw. He had to work hard to overcome his physical repulsion.
Read 8 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!

This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!