Smart piece from my friend @MatthewJFranck pushing back on the "Make A Deal" cabal (of which I'm a member). I'm saving my responses for a longer piece but 2 quick points.... thedispatch.com/p/vote-on-pres… 1/4
First, I actually don't think McConnell is being a hypocrite (certainly not on the scale of Graham). He was always more careful and surgical in his statements (As far as I know, maybe I'm missing some quote). and .... 2/4
Second, I don't think "fairness to the nominee" is a particularly powerful argument. I'm all for fairness, to be sure. But it can't be the primary determinant in confirmation battles, can it? I mean "fairness to the nominee" isn't in the constitution either. 3/4
It feels bootstrappy to say this fairness - 40-odd days to the election - is the 1 institutional principle that compels quick action. But maybe I'm misreading. Regardless, he makes many points that have me thinking. And it's great to have him writing for us. 4/4
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Okay so I’m finally up to speed on Noem killing her dog. I was open to the idea there was more to the story, farm life is hard, etc. But this seems indefensible to me. If I had that attitude about my Carolina Dog, I would have shot Zoë a dozen times over when she was young.
1/
Cricket was not, from Noem’s own account an irredeemable dog and there were plenty of alternatives available to her. But at the risk of taking Noem more seriously than she deserves, I think it’s worth thinking more about why she tells this story.
2/
Noem wants to be VP. Noem is close to Corey Lewandowski who is a thuggish guy who thinks talking tough is a core part of MAGA and essential to impressing Trump.
Indeed, Trump, famously wants Roy Cohn types willing to go as dirty and ugly on his behalf as possible.
3/
I know young activists want validation and to feel heard. I can meet them half-way. I hear what these kids are saying, but I can't validate it because they are indefensibly moronic, silly, and morally deformed. 1/ wsj.com/us-news/educat…
If, say, grad students wanting better pay butchered babies, murdered and raped civilians, and took the children of their professors hostage, you know what we would call them? Butchers, murderers, and rapists. 2/
You certainly can think the *Palestinian* cause is just, but that doesn't require endorsing Hamas' *means.* To say you're pro-Hamas is to say that any means are justified for your desired end. You're saying you are pro-murder, rape, and hostage-taking. MLK you ain't. 3/
So last night I watched the @AlbertBrooks documentary. It's great, especially the first hour. This thread isn't about that, tho.
Like Brooks, it's very Jewish, in some of the main ways I love and identify with Jewishness: humor, guilt, loving nostalgia for family. 1/
It's all build on a conversation/friendship between @robreiner and @AlbertBrooks. They met in high school and had famous funnymen as parents.
To say I disagree w/Reiner on politics is an understatement. But I also feel like he could be a cousin or uncle. Which got me thinking 2/
While watching interviews with Jon Stewart, Jonah Hill, Steven Spielberg, Ben Stiller, Judd Apatow, Larry David, Sarah Silverman -- all Jews -- it dawned on me that if any of them had been on the ground on 10/7 Hamas would have killed them too. 3/
I think this article gets the causality almost perfectly backwards. It wasn't the right's defeat that launched the trans stuff as a political issue, it was the left's success and need for a new cause, which in turn invited the conservative backlash. 1/ nytimes.com/2023/04/16/us/…
Just as a chronological fact, the issue didn't start with the GOP opposing trans athletes in sports. The issue started with .. the issue! -- pushing trans athletes in sports. You can say that's good, bad, or mixed. But you can't start with the right's *reaction* as the start. 2/
This is a pattern going back decades. Progressives -- sometimes rightly, sometimes not -- push an idea forward (it's inherent in the label "progressive" ffs). And when they meet resistance from conservatives, progressives & the media declare "look what the right is starting!" 3/
The news is now out there. So, I should say something here. My beloved mom, Lucianne Goldberg, passed away yesterday. She died peacefully at home, surrounded by people – and pets! – who loved her. 1/
My daughter insisted on flying here from California to be with her, which gave grandma great joy. It gave me that mix of pride and anguish you feel when your child endures pain for being courageous and kind. 2/
My mom lived the most incredible life. She was wildly accomplished before most people ever heard of her during the Clinton brouhaha. Tough, brilliant, incredibly funny, she was many things to many people. But for me, she was just my mom. 3/ commentary.org/john-podhoretz…