D31 HS Aaron asks re students getting no live instruction re remote blended learning; parents feel duped, as they were promised. Also some classes still don’t have teachers.
Chancellor: no vested interest in duping parents. I don’t get a bonus for this.
Chancellor: I know some districts started remote learning and in-person w/ cameras in classrooms. This is the most horrible form of pedagogy I can think of. We could have done that and called that synchronous learning but we decided not to.
Chancellor: We finally landed at about 6,000 additional teachers as goal to staff a model we can stand behind. In order to do that, we need to ramp up to that. It will continue to get better every week.
The Mayor has given us additional resources, incl 2 SAMs to hire additional teachers; reached out to over 20K student teachers, over 10K teachers previously applied&students with BAs and MAs eligible to be substitute. CUNY recruiting adjunct professors to be used at HS level.
Chancellor: We know from D75 & preK students that some moving to remote learning creating more space to offer 5 days a week in-person learning.
My goal is that we will do such a good job that in Nov. we will have more families moving to in-person.
.@ItsShidaB: explore option not having family opting into remote learning at any time? readjustments are difficult and more work and chaos for schools to manage constant changes.
Carranza – 1 way to get me killed is to take away choices from families. I’d be kicked into street
Q to @DOEChancellor: Will DOE issue class size reports as required Nov. 15 – disaggregated by in-person, PT & FT remote? & Many parents saying live remote very large class size.
.@DOEChancellor ignores 1st Q & says: It is possible a particularly good teacher will be providing a remote lesson for 100 students. But then students will have another teacher that follows up with them, w/ more feedback. [Really - is this happening parents/teachers?]
Chancellor then compares this model to college lecture classes; with grad student leading smaller sections. It's a staffing challenge to get content level out & then provide more personalized feedback to students. This will become "more robust" as we move later through the year
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
2/I wrote NYT 2 times why no disclosure of this conflict but got no response. Then in Aug. 2020 @timothywschwab wrote about Gates influence over media in general & @soljourno
lack of disclosure in their @nytimes columns when promoting Gates-funded projects cjr.org/criticism/gate…
Phil Wong CEC24 says parents are concerned Catholic schools are open for 5 days/wk in-person learning but not public schools & some leaving for these schools; Robert Holden asks: also heard kids are finished w/schoolwork in 10 min? Phil Wong says yes, not enough instruction.
.@MarkTreyger718 we know many kids going into schools only to learn online; today we find out over 72,000 open requests for device; only until July the admin started planning for the fall. When you fail to plan you plan to fail
Council does have power to shine light on problems. If we had gotten info we asked for fr/ DOE back in May & summer, or showed up for hearings in Sept., we could have learned this earlier. No one going to lecture us about ground rules.
Andrea Ortiz @thenyic- abrupt shift to remote learning hit immigrant students hardest & w/o devices & DOE system made parents sign on w/ DOE directly to request devices & NOT via schools.
.@randi_levine@AFCNewYork Some parents think they've sign up for devices but DOE says not/ no one is taking ownership of this issue to check w/parents what's going on.
.@MarkTreyger718 some families sharing devices & didn't realize they could ask for each child; @randi_levine says: DOE told families originally they could only get one. Technical asst. also needed to help them use it. Treyger: also Chromebooks are needed w/internet access.
.@StephenLevin33: Why is 0.2% positivity rate fr/random testing in schools so much lower than citywide positivity rate? Dr. Varma - city positivity rate higher b/c more sick testednot same as actual prevalence -- we estimate actual citywide prevalence last week about 0.1%-0.7%.
(this is one of most interesting stats we've never heard before from Mayor or anyone else.)
What statutory authority for mandated Covid testing asks @JoeBorelliNYC - & if they forced to remote, does that constitute sound basic education? Carranza:we'll get the legal authority for you. We are all choosing from portfolio from imperfect solutions including remote learning
We don't take issuing subpoena lightly; astonished that we couldn't get attendance data from DOE says @NYCSpeakerCoJo . Chaos is tremendous and no individual's fault; our stress nothing compared to anxieties families are facing with little info & rules changing day by by.
.@NYCspeakerCojo says getting education right will determine future of our city and how we handle this challenge will determine whether parents can go back to work & kids will get their education; excuses no longer acceptable
.@JumaaneWilliams says the planning for reopening schools could have been done better; it couldn't have been done worse. Blames it on incompetency of @nycmayor. Delays caused by Inadequate staffing while he was warned by principals of teacher shortage months in advance.