Erik Torenberg Profile picture
Sep 25, 2020 28 tweets 6 min read Read on X
Deep dive into some of Rene Girard's thoughts on mimetic desire, scapegoating, and Christianity 👇

Previous TLDR:
~All non instinctual desire is mimetic

We want things not because they are inherently desirable, but because someone else's desire for them has made them attractive to us.

We desire not so much someone's car or house as much as the quality of being that seems to belong to the people who have those possessions

Desire is never just a straight line between a subject and an object, but always has some other as its model.

Desire is shaped by imitation
Other animals imitate, but they don't imitate to the degree we do. We don't just imitate on a monkey see/do level. We imitate on a perception level. We imitate what we perceive our neighbor's desires to be. We don't first think & then desire—the opposite.

The more similar we are, the more we'll want the same things

And the more we want the same things, the more we'll tend to fight over the scarce good (or status)

And so we face a permanent threat of runaway violence

Conflict brings convergence, which then brings more conflict.
We want others to love what we love, admire what we admire, but when they do, we suddenly find that they have become competitors, leading to conflict

Mentor/mentee dynamic is a perfect example. Master wants pupil to imitate the master up until the pupil becomes the master.
The first cultures dealt with threat of runaway violence by transferring their violence to a surrogate victim, a scapegoat whose death/expulsion unites and ends violence

The antidote to chaos is the ritual scapegoating of a common enemy

"the foundational murder" / "noble lie"
And because the community owes its entire order to its victim, the victim is worshipped as scared

But at the same time, the victim is also believed to be guilty, and therefore deserving of the collective violence

Scapegoating worked in restoring order, so people kept doing it
People need something to blame to hide from the fact that they are angry out of endlessly imitating each other.

Need a safe space to place all their violence.

Scapegoating is the protection of the community against violence that it could not otherwise control
The scapegoat ritual addresses the threat of uncontrolled violence, which is endemic to human society b/c of runaway mimetic desire leading to conflict.

Rituals of sacrifice averted this crisis by reconciling everyone around a sacrificial victim.

It's a collective release.
However, scapegoating preserves social peace only so long as the scapegoaters think it's justified

That, after all, was the definition of scapegoating: persecution of an innocent victim believed to be guilty

Christianity, of course, inverts this myth. Now the victim's innocent
If you see the truth of that violence, suddenly that violence repels you

Jesus's cross instead of ratifying his guilt, proclaims his innocence

Before the cross, every violence is portrayed as heroic in literature

Now, not anymore. Scapegoating's no longer sacred. Left a vacuum
Jesus says, If you have to imitate someone, imitate me, because I won't imitate others and I won't become your rival. And imitate others who imitate me too.

Instead of eye for an eye, turn the other cheek.

Instead of sanctifying sacrificial violence, sanctify love and mercy.
Jesus introduced a new spirit of self-awareness & self-criticism

More so than anytime in history, we're aware of our faults. The west is the only place where we self-flagellate our own culture to gain status

Ironically, this is Christianity w/o Christ

Today, we see the violence of Christianity, we don't see the violence, Christianity has prevented all through history

Christianity didn't invent violence, but it did contribute to curbing it

Where did we get your sensitivity to violence, after all? Certainly wasn't Oedipus Rex
Eye for an eye today seems primitive, but at the time it was revolutionary. It advocated for reciprocal violence instead of escalation, which used to be the norm.

B/c we don’t want to renounce scapegoating, we keep attempting sacrificial violence, but it doesn’t bind us anymore
Remember, the importance of sacred sacrificial violence in the primordial past was that it bound us together. It prevented us from contagiously envying one another to the point where we’re obsessed with destroying each other rather than just getting on with life.
Ironically, as society became both more egalitarian and meritocratic, and hierarchies were less rigid, mimetic competition skyrocketed.

Where previously people were only competing with their own caste, now they were competing with everyone in the world, & expected to win. Chaos.
Nietzsche knew that Christianity was the reason why that resentment was building to such a deep level that once we killed the idea of a God that kept hierarchies stable, mimetic mayhem would ensue

Resentiment is a begrudging those who you perceive to have things that you desire
We didn't stop burning witches bc of the scientific method, we got the scientific method bc we stopped burning witches

If, say, ppl's crops were dying, & they burned a "witch", & then crops grew, they kept doing it

When they stopped, they could evaluate other reasons (science!)
People will always find scapegoats.

"Experience suggests that if men cannot struggle on behalf of a just cause b/c that just cause was victorious in an earlier generation....They will struggle, out of a certain boredom: for they cannot imagine living in a world without struggle"
Today it's this game of guilt, hot potato, where we're becoming more increasingly haunted by our guilt in collective violence. And we're trying to throw that hot potato onto somebody else

Scapegoating used to literally mean the transferring of sins to the goats. Now we do people
We’re half Christian.

We’re thoroughly within the fishbowl of Christianity, but we’re, only half Christian in the sense that we’re aware of victimization, but we don’t want to fully recognize how it affects what we do today, and so we justify violence in victimization's name
Today, we have new problems.

Jesus popped the scape goat bubble told us to imitate him, but we don't want to anymore.

Mob frenzies and scapegoating are society trying to purge itself of its own demons.
Secular Christianity imports from real Christianity what Nietzsche called “slave mentality”, the glorification of the victim. “The first shall be last and the last shall be first.”
And so if your sense of self identity and morality is all wrapped up in that, then any differential success you or other people may achieve is evidence of evil

And so the source of that evil must be identified and eliminated.
The cycle will repeat until either every possible scapegoat is dead or the movement burns itself out.

We all have the motivation to purge our sense of collective sin, independent of the guilt or innocence of the subject.

And the overpowering need to participate.
In a post-modern world, what's the answer?

Liberalism. Tolerance. Due process. Reason. Free speech.



These are more scattered thoughts than a deep dive, would welcome any follow up analyses or your own takeaways from Girard.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Erik Torenberg

Erik Torenberg Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @eriktorenberg

Jun 8, 2023
I’m excited to (finally) announce the launch of my newest incubated venture: @TurpentineMedia, a network of podcasts, newsletters, and more covering tech, business, and culture, from the perspective of industry insiders and experts.

Think The Ringer or Barstool, for tech.

We… twitter.com/i/web/status/1… Image
There exist practitioners in every vertical who’d make more money & have more fun being a business creator for their niche, & Turpentine is here to help them do it

Think @lennysan @HarryStebbings @packyM, 7-figure biz creators just off podcasts & newsletters

Just the beginning.
Read 17 tweets
Mar 24, 2023
Hey Everybody. I’m excited to finally release my main interview show that I'll host for the rest of my life.

First episode with @pmarca is out now. Next guests include @DavidSacks, @balajis, @ezraklein, @KTmBoyle, @JTLonsdale, & more

Preview of the episodes below:
Check out the podcast episode with Marc Andreessen below. I'm biased, but I think this interview gives the best insight into his intellectual journey over the past decade.

Apple: podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/the…

Spotify: open.spotify.com/episode/0bYfnu…

YouTube:
In the first episode with @pmarca, we discuss:

- Marc's intellectual evolution
- Why billionaires think the same
- @elonmusk as the return to entrepreneurial capitalism
- Larry Page on why giving money to Elon is the best philanthropy
- Effective Altruism's blind spots

clips:
Read 8 tweets
Mar 18, 2023
E13 of MOZ w/ @dwr @antoniogm & @ByrneHobart is up. We discuss:

- Byrne's early warnings on SVB
- How banking works
- Whether crypto will reinvent or merely recreate the existing financial system.
Thanks to sponsor @riversidefm. Riverside captures exceptional audio and video quality and makes it incredibly easy for us to record shows with multiple guests.

Riverside offers a 20% discount with code ZEN
bit.ly/Riverside_MoZ
Read 4 tweets
Jan 2, 2023
What's the best podcast *episode* you listened to in 2022? Here are some of my favorites:
Read 17 tweets
Dec 31, 2022
Here are some of the most interesting books and blog posts that changed my mind in 2022:
Ancient City

TLDR: For 99.9% of our existence, Western society has been a fascist-communist cult that joined ethnicity, religion, and culture.

We can see some similarities today: ancestor worship = identity politics; nature worship = environmentalism

amazon.com/Ancient-City-R…
Zeihan's The End of The World is Just The Beginning

Deglobalization combined w/ depopulation changes everything

The idea of global supply chains goes away; the idea of a single price for oil goes away; the idea that we can feed 8 billion people goes away
amazon.com/End-World-Just…
Read 21 tweets
Oct 31, 2022
What makes group chats uniquely good is partly the privacy but mostly the chemistry of the group

There should be a feature where, if everyone opts in, you can seamlessly publish the part of the chat that's appropriate for public consumption
Talkshow founded by the excellent @sippey tried this in 2016, but perhaps now's a better time for it since group chats are more prominent today given how stilted social networks have gotten

theverge.com/2016/4/26/1151…
This blogpost gives an example of what it's like to read a thoughtful text conversation: aaronzlewis.com/blog/2020/08/0…
Read 4 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us!

:(