I’ve had a few pings about the @kucoincom hack over the weekend, just to save my DMs from turning into even more of a dumpster fire than usual, here are my thoughts. They are my own, and do not represent the collective views of the @synthetix_io community, because obviously lol.
So we heard there were anomalies within a few minutes of the news from a number of people who track on-chain movements closely. It seemed ~500k of the ~1.5m SNX on kucoin was in a suspected hacker address already. Kucoin said they would be making an announcement shortly.
When I heard Kucoin was planning to cover the ~150m loss from insurance I was a little skeptical. I have some experience insuring tail risk from working with a client of @Blueshyft a few years ago. There are not many people out there who will write cover this large and weird.
The cost is also prohibitive, but I mean Kucoin makes a lot of profit maybe it made sense given they have a pretty good track record for security etc.
Next I checked my account on Kucoin, turns out I had some SNX sitting on there from about six months ago when I used to use it to fund bounties and other stuff like kain.eth. So I write this SNX off immediately, if you have funds on an exchange and it gets hacked it is on you…
I really cannot stress this point enough. If you leave funds idle on an exchange for like six months and forget they are there you deserve to lose them. It is like leaving an envelope of cash on your doorstep for months. Maybe it doesn’t get stolen or blow away but if it does…
If you have funds on an exchange they should be there for a reason, and only as long as they need to be. If you get lazy and lulled into a false sense of security you are in for a rude awakening.
So back to the hacked SNX, it was less than half a percent of the supply. So my immediate response was there is literally zero chance we are getting a SIP to pass to try to fork the protocol or something equally dumb. And that was basically the end of it for me.
Someone else could write a SIP to freeze the tokens through a fork but I would have voted against it. When we implemented a SIP to slash frontrunners in 2019 the blowback was not worth it. Even though I stand by the fact that the SIP-6 mechanism was efficient as a deterrent 😬
So now we have a very strong norm in the Synthetix community against any kind of balance modification even if it is implemented at the protocol level. And with the pDAO in control of all upgrades, there was just no chance of a fork happening from my perspective.
The other consideration is that SNX liquidity as not what it was in the @teo_leibowitz era. SNX is on multiple DEXs and CEXs with significant liquidity. I had no concerns about the impact on the token if they were dumped. I figured smart actors would use it for accumulation.
And that is exactly what seems to have happened. The dump candle on the 1 hour tf ended up green 🤯
I have been telling people close to me that the last 2-3 months since we moved to a fully DAO governance framework felt incredibly freeing, and this is a perfect example. I have no power to change this situation, even if I wanted to.
But knowing that even if I proposed a fork or something equally crazy the community would harshly reject it removes any sense of being conflicted. I am now not even in a position to make a bad choice against the will the community, and it feels amazing.
I of course still have a deep responsibility to spend my time thinking about how best to navigate the craziness that is DeFi and advocate for what I believe is the optimal path forward to balancing all priorities, but I have hung up my semi-benevolent dictator hat for good.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
A much needed shakeup in coming to @synthetix_io. A thread on how we got here and what comes next. 👇
The Synthetix project has many firsts to its name. The first yield farm, the first EIP style governance for DeFi. The first governance council. The first DeFi architecture to leverage proxies. The first to deploy to OP. Yet its relevance has declined over the years.
Synthetix was never great at marketing, it’s been good at memeing new narratives into existence though. But it’s been a while since it’s been at the start of a new wave.
doesn’t count as revenue because you basically have a cabal going around robbing small children of their lunch money at gunpoint.pump.fun
Ethena obviously doesn’t count, because it is basically Luna, except not in the way that Synthetix is basically Luna, it is like basically Luna in a different way, but worse. Also it is basically FTX because did you hear that they also uses CEXs, not even DeFi imo.
Breaking the meta is challenging, but there is nothing that excites a degen more than a new mechanism to try to game. This is why yield farming was so effective in creating DeFi summer. Pool 1, pool 2, pool 8?... shut up and take my money.
This is why the points meta created so much excitement, and for the projects that got in early it was extremely effective at driving awareness and attention. Unfortunately as we have recently realised it was not sustainable.
Points were a hybrid of airdrops and yield farming. The problem is that points, unlike tokens, could be infinitely inflated, this allowed projects to farm the farmers. It's not much, but it's honest work.
Man @LayerZero_Labs you’re really gonna make me write up another thread huh…
I had a call last night with one of my favourite projects, they are working on their governance framework. The word I kept coming back to was LEGITIMACY.
This is probably the single most important concept in crypto. This is one of the reasons why almost every points distribution recently has been a dumpster fire.
It’s been a while since I’ve put my theadoooooor hat on, so let’s have a little chat about capital formation incentives in crypto.
Yes there are many bad actors, but not everyone is a bad actor, never attribute to malice what can more easily be explained by misaligned incentives.
People do not realise how much pressure there is to conform to existing meta for new teams. Even, and maybe even especially, the most successful teams are constrained by the current meta if they want to raise big rounds.
This has gotten way out of hand 😂. is the new site for @KengLernitas. A 🧵 on what has happened so far.kenglernitas.wtf
I started playing around with memecoins a few weeks ago, bridged some USDC to Solana and started yoloing on @dexscreener. This was right around the launch of @bodensol. Despite what a lot of overly serious people are saying I find many of these memecoins to be utterly hilarious.
That said I am most definitely not a serious person. I’ve been a fan of @getbentsaggy for a long time, and many of the Dolan memes are incredible. There’s no accounting for taste tho…