I am seeing a lot of what seems like tension and chatter about aerosols vs. airborne and disciplinary differences in how the latter is defined.
a lot more ...
2/ My "go to" source for all things aerosols is WC Hinds' great text - Aerosol Technology: Properties, Behavior, and Measurement of Airborne Particles.
Anyone who studies aerosols should know of Hind's text. I am old enough to have a tattered copy of the (cough) 1st ed. more
3/ Note the title of the book carefully.
Please also note that aerosols are a binary system consisting of particles AND the gas in which they are suspended. Aerosol particles refers to the particle (liquid or solid) phase of aerosols.
more
4/ On page 1 an aerosol is defined as a "solid or liquid particles suspended in a gas" (obviously - in the case of indoor air that gas is air). Hinds then writes that "Aerosols are also referred to as suspended particulate matter, aerocolloidal systems, and disperse systems."
5/ The term "aerosol" was coined 100 years ago (in 1920 - right after the 1918 flu) as the air analogy to hydrosol, a stable suspension of particles in a liquid.
more ....
6/ Take note. A key word in all of this is "suspended"
Aerosol particles are dynamic. They can shrink by evaporation and grow by coagulation (particle collide and adhere) and condensation.
7/ Their chemical composition of aerosol particles also changes by adsorption and absorption of gases as well as condensation onto particle surfaces and chemical reactions on and in the particles.
more ...
8/ Aerosol particles do NOT stay suspended forever. While aerosol particles remain in air far longer than large droplets (what many are referring to as ballistic droplets), some fraction does deposit on indoor surfaces, often very far from the source.
more ...
9/ Indoors, some fraction deposits onto surfaces by a combination of gravitational settling, inertial impaction, interception, Brownian motion (for very small particles), electrostatic attraction, and thermophoresis.
more ...
10/ These particle removal mechanisms lead to some removal to floors, walls, furniture, and even people inside buildings. Think of the very large surface area associated with clothing and hair of 25 high school students in a 600 sq ft classroom.
more ...
11/ But how much deposits on indoor surfaces? I have combined bldg meta data with best-available peer-reviewed and published decay rates for particles of different sizes to estimate fractional deposition of aerosol particles in high school and university classrooms.
more ...
12/ Using only aerosol particles of 0.5 to 4 microns, I estimate fractional collective deposition of less than 3% to over 20% by number of particles depending on degree of ventilation, mixing conditions, and appropriate surface area adjustments.
13/ Given uncertainties in human exposure and dose estimates, as well as source and particle size distributions, mixing conditions, etc., it is slightly conservative but reasonable to neglect such deposition losses for the size range I have modeled.
more ...
14/ I hope this provides some useful information for discussions on social media about definitions, provides a reference to a valuable text on aerosols, and also opens eyes to the dynamic behavior of aerosol particles. There is so much more. Pick up a used copy of Hinds' text!
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
The Corsi-Rosenthal Foundation is a tax-exempt 501(c)3 nonprofit organization (EIN: 35-2779639). Our goal is to provide cleaner air in school & other public buildings with particular interest in underserved and/or vulnerable communities.
We do this largely through financial grants, materials, or a combination of the two to build Corsi-Rosenthal boxes (CR Boxes). The Corsi-Rosenthal Foundation is run by consensus of a Board of Directors.
All Board members are volunteers and receive no salary. As such, 100% of donations go directly to grantees for cleaning the air for their communities. No donations are used to purchase materials from companies affiliated with any Board members.
The "Sources" chapter of @theNASEM
report on "Health Risks of Indoor Exposure to Fine Particulate Matter & Practical Mitigation Solutions" is approx 60 pages and full of source-specific details. Check out the report here: (some highlights in thread)
Cooking is a very large source, whether heating w/ natural gas, propane, electric. Emissions specific to natural gas for cooking & other heating processes considered in (2)
The "Sources" chapter of @theNASEM report on "Health Risks of Indoor Exposure to Fine Particulate Matter & Practical Mitigation Solutions" is approx 60 pages and full of source-specific details. Check out the report here: 👇 (some highlights in thread)
Cooking is a very large source, whether heating w/ natural gas, propane, electric .. Emissions specific to natural gas for cooking & other heating processes considered in (2)
(1) Americans spend the vast majority of their time indoors. Prior to the pandemic, on average Americans lived to be 79 yo (now lower) & spend almost 70 of those years indoors, 54 years insides residences.
(2) Most fine particulate matter (particles with diameters of 2.5 microns or less) are inhaled indoors. This is true for fine particles of both indoor as well as outdoor origin. (more on sources of fine PM in a future tweet).
(3) There is ample evidence that exposure to fine particulate matter causes a range of adverse health effects (will summarize in a future tweet).
1/ This CR Box (the one on the right!) has now totaled operational time equivalent to an entire in-classroom school year. Both it and its cohort of three other CR Boxes continue to perform with a high level of effectiveness across a wide range of particle sizes.
2/ Four CR Boxes were placed in different indoor settings on the UC Davis campus, from a relatively clean 4-person office suite w/ VCT flooring to a particle-challenged soils lab.
3/ Each CR Box consists of four 20" x 20" x 2" MERV-13 filters (3 boxes w/ filters from the same manufacturer and the 4th from a different manufacturer). A 20" x 20" box fan was used to draw air through each CR Box.