In France, mid 70s preceding & after PM Desai & FM Vajpayee’s visits there were several docufilms & TV discussions on India which made me dread school the following morning.
Both teachers & classmates would accost me wide-eyed with a variety of incredulous questions on
-Caste system
Was I allowed to take water from the well ? Or was I upper caste & kept myself segregated from lower castes ?
-Dowry system
Would my father buy me groom ?
-Arranged marriages
Would I be condemned to a loveless transaction?
-Astrology
Did we plan our day accordingly ?
-Fetish for sons
Was my being educated the norm ?
-Cows
Did we get down from our cars & bow to passing bovines ?
The fact that my father didn’t have a bodhi like the Hare Rama Hare Rama guys was also a matter of great surprise.
I won’t even go into the horror of their reaction to news channels flashing trucks loaded of bewildered men being taken away for sterilisation in 1975.
And yes, according to them all Indians were Red & in US reservations. Poor things !
Whereas India had only Hindus & we were
known as such -Les Hindous.
This by the way was not some hick school in the back of beyond but bang in the middle of 16 arrondissement,Paris.
In the late 80s & early 90s we travelled for business & leisure & faced the same curiosity about caste, cows, riots in varying degrees
So this lament of India cutting down casteism in 70 years is a bit misplaced when thats all they knew of us.
By mid 90s we stopped travelling as much for work with our European principals choosing to visit us - & that’s when a definitive change in a few became obvious because
they had their own experiences to go by & were not entirely dependent on media coverage.
IMO, when it comes to India, the Western media by & large has been comfortable mostly with cliches & caricatures.
It was so then & it remains so now.
It tends to ignore anything positive, feeding the Confirmation Bias & hence should be treated with the contempt it deserves - unless of course, one enjoys self flagellation !
What is more worrying, is that some of our political leaders only seem to scour for opportunities to exploit our problems, keeping them on a constant boil for electoral possibilities.
These are the people who should be called out, rendered irrelevant, if we want to stride ahead
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Dear #Dharavi
We havent met but I’m sure you’ve heard of us.
Amethi! Amethi from Uttar Pradesh.
We bore the brunt of being the Gandhi Family’s bastion for 42 years and we forfeited
the future of our children to Sub Saharan standards.
We could have been that model constituency!
We could have been that opportunity for Rahul Gandhi to show case his abilities - to be replicated and held up as his vision for the country. But alas it was not to be.…
Our health center 👇🏼
The West it seems doesn’t give a hoot for the Uyghurs. Those forsaken, forgotten people of the Muslim faith in some corner of China and neither do the international media, NGOs, or activists.
Does anyone recollect a Western nation having recalled their Ambassador or imposed sanctions on the country which ruthlessly decimates the culture and faith of these people?
The West also chooses to ignore Muslim on Muslim atrocity and violence.
Not a flicker of reaction to the two Palestinians hanged, quartered and thrown into the trash just last night by their own.
Or for that matter the Yemenis bombarded to smithereens by the Saudis or the Baloch systematically butchered by the Pakistanis.
Class - Privileged
First Language - English
Religious Denomination - Iffy about this Sanatan Dharm, Hindutva business.
Thankfully recently discovered my inner spirituality.
Status - We are British (at least we’d like to be…please, please) in summer when we head out to London.
Portuguese .. erm Goan in winter when we soak in the sun in Goa which mind you is looking more and more like GK.
Opinion - Bharat?!?
You can’t do this!!! There will be international repercussions!! You know, don’t you that Mountbatten’s granddaughter is called India? Imagine their trauma!
Can say without hesitation that there was very little or non existent talk of ‘brothers separated by the British’ among people, in the 40’s and 50s after the bloodletting of Partition and the raider attack on Kashmir.
In the 60-70s we fought two wars and in my childhood Pakistan was definitely, enemy.
The 80s witnessed Khalistani insurgency in Punjab which we all knew where it emanated from.
In the 90s came Benazir with her chop-chop Jag-Jag, the Kashmiri Pandit exodus, Bombay bomb blasts, Kargil, Hijacking IC814…!
Then in 2000s, Parliament attack, Mumbai train blasts…
A 14yr old boy had been left with relatives in Lahore to complete his FSc exams while his family had made their way earlier to the hills of Joginder Nagar, as was their norm at that time of the year.
The young boy wrote to his father that his last paper had been postponed indefinitely and the educational institute was shut due to uncertainty and tensions in the city.
He was advised to take the first possible train out, to Jullundur or Kapurthala with their driver Gulab.
By now riots had broken out across the city but even then, neighbours were dissuading each other from leaving. Send the women and children away they said. The able bodied must stay back to protect home and hearth...and before long things would return to normal as they always did
Beginning to understand why Pakistan finds favour with the West…
Why they don’t get lectured on their shredded state of democracy even though their Army claims they are one.
Why they don’t get told off on Minority Rights even though they openly, shamelessly decimate theirs.
Why isn’t there even a murmur on Press Freedom when their journalists are bundled into car boots and taken away to undisclosed locations.
Not even get a raised eyebrow when they ethnically cleansed millions of their own compatriots in what was once called East Bengal.
No mention of the Idea of Pakistan as they slice and dice their own, differentiating between Shia, Sunni, Ahmadiyya’s..
There is nothing like the triumphalism of I told You So and Pakistan proves them right everyday, offering comfort when things dont look so good at home.