Last week we heard rumors that the U.S. Treasury and Secretary Mnuchin were planning to rush out some new regulation regarding self-hosted crypto wallets before the end of his term. I'm concerned that this would have unintended side effects, and wanted to share those concerns.
For those who don't know - self-hosted crypto wallets (also known as non-custodial wallets or self-custody wallets) are a type of software that lets individuals store and use their own cryptocurrency, instead of needing to rely on a third party financial institution.
Self-hosted crypto wallets are important, because they allow anyone to use this new technology to access basic financial services - just like anyone can use a computer or smartphone to access the open internet.
The open nature of cryptocurrency is what makes it a powerful tool for innovation, and it is what levels the playing field globally. It is what is fueling innovation, such as in Defi. It has the potential to bring down the cost of financial services, and improve accessibility.
This proposed regulation would, we think, require financial institutions like Coinbase to verify the recipient/owner of the self-hosted wallet, collecting identifying information on that party, before a withdrawal could be sent to that self-hosted wallet.
This sounds like a reasonable idea on the surface, but it is a bad idea in practice because it is often impractical to collect identifying information on a recipient in the cryptoeconomy. Let me explain why.
Many crypto users are sending crypto to smart contracts to use Defi apps. A smart contract is not necessarily owned by any individual or business who could be identified. It is a new type of recipient that doesn't have any direct equivalent in traditional financial services.
Many crypto users are sending crypto to various merchants online, paying for goods and services. Does it make sense to require customers to help verify the identity of a business before they can buy a product there?
Many crypto users are also sending crypto to people in emerging markets, where it is difficult or impossible to collect meaningful "know your customer" information. Some of these individuals are living in poverty, and may not have any permanent address or form of government ID.
Many crypto users are using their crypto with new types of applications online. Imagine if every time you wanted to upvote some content on Reddit or transfer an item in a game you were hit with a form asking you to verify a recipient.
Finally, many recipients (in the U.S. or abroad) who value their financial privacy, may simply not want to upload more identifying documents to various companies, which could be hacked or stolen.
This additional friction would kill many of the emerging use cases for crypto. Crypto is not just money - it is digitizing every type of asset.
Given these barriers, we're likely to see fewer transactions from crypto financial institutions to self-hosted wallets. This would effectively create a walled garden for crypto financial services in the U.S., cutting us off from innovation happening in the rest of the world.
This would be bad for America because it would force U.S. consumers to use foreign unregulated crypto companies to get access to these services. And long term, I believe this would put America's status as a financial hub at risk.
Just like the U.S. benefited enormously by embracing the open internet, it should embrace the open crypto networks and allow U.S. citizens to move their own money freely in the emerging cryptoeconomy.
If this crypto regulation comes out, it would be a terrible legacy and have long standing negative impacts for the U.S. In the early days of the internet there were people who called for it to be regulated like the phone companies. Thank goodness they didn't.
We sent a letter to the Treasury last week, along with a number of other crypto companies and investors, articulating these concerns and others.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh

Keep Current with Brian Armstrong

Brian Armstrong Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!


Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @brian_armstrong

11 Sep
In the wake of other companies struggling with Apple's App Store restrictions, I want to share a bit about Coinbase's own struggle here.
Many companies are reluctant to speak out on these topics for fear of retaliation, but I feel like we need to continue the dialog in the open.
We've tried discussing this through regular channels with Apple, and I reached out directly to leadership to request a dialog, but we seem to be at a dead end.
Read 19 tweets
27 Jul
One of our teams ran their first offsite in a purely virtual way recently. A few details:
* 110 people, came together for ~5 hrs
* focus was on connecting people/building relationships that wouldn't happen in the ordinary course of business (especially during covid)
* they "met" in a fully virtual world on
* it consisted of 21 different rooms (all hands, break out rooms, secret easter egg room, etc)
* all participants received a physical package in the mail with a special DIY craft (which some then worked on together in the virtual space)

Reception from the team was really positive!
Read 5 tweets
12 Jul
Have seen a few articles talking about Coinbase Analytics - figured I would share my thoughts on it, since I don't think it's particularly newsworthy - and lots of conjecture out there.
Blockchain analytics software is nothing new - has been around a long time - it uses publicly available data to try and track crypto transactions - usually to catch bad actors.
Exchanges that maintain connections into the existing financial system (i.e. ability to connect your bank account, do wires, etc so you can convert fiat to crypto) need to follow AML laws, and this often includes utilizing blockchain analytics software for transaction monitoring.
Read 14 tweets
4 Jun
I want to unequivocally say that Black Lives Matter.
I've been watching the events of the last few weeks unfold - I really did not know what to say about it for a long time, and I'm still not sure I do. But I've been getting educated.
The tragic murder of George Floyd, and broader pattern of racism in the U.S., is a terrible scar on the country. It's something that my experience (and how I was born) has prevented me from experiencing first hand, and I've had to try and understand it second hand from others.
Read 11 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!

This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!