These chuds were parading around a noose and chanting "Murder the Media" - by which they mean him and his colleagues! - and he's so deep in his bubble of privilege and security he feels the need to dole out humanizing anecdotes

Like it makes any goddamn difference to them
I actually mean it when I say people have a duty to push back on the relentless humanizing of the right wing

That's the whole asymmetry here - they *start off more humanized*

The definition of being right wing is being the kind of person people reflexively think of as authentic
Normal, decent folk

Salt of the earth

Everyday old-fashioned red-blooded Americans

People with a picture postcard version of how the country should look in their heads, based on what they think is the country's history since its founding, and hate to see it change
You can't imagine someone passing anecdotes to try and show a human side to a foreign terrorist

The Nigerian "underwear bomber" from 2009 was much more of a farce that was much less likely to hurt anyone than this

No one told cute stories about his childhood
I think the media does this kind of thing on a deep unconscious level

Even if they know people on Twitter will drag them for it

It *feels wrong* to define some blonde Christian white woman by her crime, to just say "Welp a terrorist rushed the Secret Service and got shot"
It *feels* to them like going out of their way to "dehumanize" the subject, it feels like cruelty, even when it's just reporting the news the way it's reported normally about other people

They feel like they *have to* find some "humanizing" detail "for the sake of your own soul"
They aren't even aware of the discrepancy

When they just report "Two Black gangsters were killed in a gunfight" or "Six suspected Iraqi militants were killed in a drone strike" or whatever

That's normal, that's just giving the facts
That realization "That could be my son, that could be my daughter" never kicks in because, well, it couldn't

It's perfectly natural

It's also infuriating and it will destroy us
This isn't even a real story! She put his bags on her tray table! Just before she tried to open the door for an angry mob to seize control of the election proceedings!
Wow, I guess the other person on the plane who didn't help their seatmate with their bags because they didn't want to catch COVID, but also didn't participate in a fascist coup, is about as good a person as her
If I really want a gold star I've got to help people with their bags AND not try to rush the door to a secure area of the Capitol
This is the thing about people going "Oh, how ironic, you're dehumanizing Nazis the way Nazis dehumanize their victims"

It's an "irony" that goes back to Sartre's "Anti-Semite and Jew"
When their whole power, their whole advantage, is being the person who naturally belongs in society as it's presently constituted, and you're in the position of always being the outsider who's there on sufferance

You cannot win the game of humanization
It does not matter what they do or what you do, the reasonable people in the middle will find a way to humanize them and dehumanize you

There'll always be some cute story about the people putting up the gallows and how nice and polite they were to the people they wanted to hang
You have to deal with Nazis *based on what they do* - in this case violently storm the Capitol building and try to steal the election

If you don't keep your gaze laser focused on that you can see the conversation drifting around in real time to humanizing them again
That crazy-pills feeling of people talking about togetherness and reconciliation *directly in the aftermath of a coup*

Deciding to just go ahead and move forward with a Congress that *went ahead and seated the elected officials who openly supported sedition*

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh

Keep Current with Arthur Chu

Arthur Chu Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!


Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @arthur_affect

9 Jan
I think constantly about how there's right-wing bias built into the media - fundamentally built into our culture - and this is part of it

To many people fascists *feel* strong, their brand is built on these symbols of strength, no matter how weak their actions actually are
I've been thinking a lot about this, about how the whole left/right conservative/liberal whatever-you-want-to-call-it divide is built on this

People the culture just says intrinsically belong here, deserve to be here, are the kind of people who live here

And people who aren't
The big tough manly dude and his pretty innocent housewife and their adorable kids

The good Christian family, "all-American", blonde hair and white skin and Anglo names, red white and blue

Everyone unconsciously defers to them, gives them extra credit
Read 10 tweets
9 Jan
Laws can always help fascists if they get in a position to exploit them

*Lack* of laws can *also* always help fascists if they get in a position to exploit that

The only actual solution is that you have to always fight fascists

The upshot is really just that you can't leave anything on autopilot and expect that institutions and norms will protect you from fascism in and of themselves

The simple existence of hate speech laws is no reason to relax and neither is the existence of a "free market of ideas"
I would actually be fine with the First Amendment fetishists' demand that state action always be off the table if they actually kept their promise to always oppose Nazis by every other possible means (public shaming, deplatforming, ostracism)
Read 4 tweets
9 Jan
The name of the book isn't actually 1984, even though a lot of people write it that way and a lot of book covers use the numerals

It's #NineteenEightyFour (look at the first edition book cover I pasted) Image
I hate to be the gatekeeper but there's so many fake Orwell fans these days
I hate people calling 1984 a "big tech" dystopia

The only real Big Tech is the telescreens and they play a really small role in the plot - the point of the book is everyone is very poor and aside from the telescreens people live like it's the Great Depression still
Read 4 tweets
9 Jan
If you know ANY history it's really really fucking hard to find anything funny about the Capitol attack, even with inherently hilarious self-owns like the dude accidentally tasing himself
The anti-Chinese riots in LA in 1871, the Wilmington insurrection of 1898, the Tulsa Massacre in 1921
Scenes that at least some of the rioters were deliberately evoking

Symbolically attacking the Capitol building is the ending of The Turner Diaries

Running all the Black elected officials out of the state house is the ending of Birth of a Nation (based on the 1898 uprising)
Read 4 tweets
7 Jan
@JARKH87 @iburs17 The crowd was this close to breaching that door and actually getting access to the legislators so you know what no

I'm relieved as hell that someone actually took that shot and I'm still terrified it got that close and could've easily gone further
@JARKH87 @iburs17 I am angry beyond reason that the institution supposedly safeguarding our system is so weak and filled with so many sympathizers that the fascists even got indoors

I have seen how fragile the infrastructure protecting us from them is and I can't unsee it
@JARKH87 @iburs17 What happened yesterday is proof that we hang by a gossamer thread above the pit, that we are always one hesitant security officer away from being ruled by these fucks

They will always be seen as more human, more legitimate, more worthy of life and liberty and voice
Read 4 tweets
5 Jan
I took a playwriting class a long time ago where the teacher talked about how in music "the rests are just as important as the notes" and how it's the same when writing a script
What we call "compression" tends to involve sucking all the empty space ("ma") out of "content" and it sucks

Cf. the "loudness war" when it came to music, i.e. "dynamic range compression" -- trying to make every second of a track equally loud so it "stands out" on the radio
I keep thinking back to that viral video of those kids discovering Phil Collins' "In the Air Tonight" for the first time

And how that beat drop is totally meaningless if the song doesn't start out mellow and quiet and then build up
Read 4 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!

This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!