One of the things I want readers to know about the Cyborg Manifesto is that it's mostly about mundane technologies and modes of organizing work + family that hugely predate the 1980s
The paper is often taken up as being about futures, acceleration, new modes of technological enhancement and achievement and the dangers they pose.
But also!
It's about being a feminized secretary and vulnerable to a boss's lewd gaze; about the re-establishment of gender roles in the home among white, US engineering elites; about women and girls oppressed by global capital + intimate patriarchy doing hazardous industrial work by hand
None of these things are new! C3I provides new tools for enforcing the power dynamics that make patriarchy, racism, and uneven distributions of wealth + capital seem *natural*. But it didn't invent these ideologies.
The language she is trying to invent about how to talk about technology without falling into binary thinking about male/female, self/other, god/man, material/immaterial, etc, is confusing and I think that often leads to a reading that the paper is just about novel technology
I think that reading is supported by paying more attention to how she outlines the stakes at the very beginning and end of the paper and less to the examples -- sketchy though they sometimes are -- that come in the middle sections, where there is less sexy language
But I find it most useful as a "plus ca change" story that points to material and embodied histories that cyborgs should know for getting by in the world today.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
In some personal, post-writing cyborg thoughts, I’m more than halfway through this pregnancy so I think I’m now authorized to say this:
I really can’t believe this is how we are making new people still!!
Like, why? My experience is totally fine and uneventful, but it seems like there should be a technological alternative by now
My mom is horrified that I don’t feel thrilled to be the embodiment of the divine feminine by now 😅
It’s cool when the kid kicks sometimes (though other times annoying), but generally pregnancy is just a mildly annoying and bizarre, temporary medical quirk to me still
Ok so, more bad COVID math and uncritical reception of "science" on the tl today: that COVID risk calculator map is interesting, but remember that due to politics, racism, economic policy, and American refusal to act in solidarity, COVID + COVID risk IS NOT evenly distributed.
And very specifically in relation to attending family Thanksgiving gatherings: if you are the type of person thinking it's a good idea to travel and/or visit with 10+ family members right now in the first place, you're probably exposing yourself way more than me to begin with.
Plus, we know that risk isn't evenly distributed due to racism (Black, Latinx, Filipino people more likely working in healthcare and other essential jobs) and classism (low-paid jobs don't offer paid sick leave, health insurance, and are the ones mostly classified as "essential")