Let me explain why I believe the SNP have taken the Indy poll to around 50%

IMHO this is multi faceted

There has been a nationalist movement in Scotland for years. It gained traction in the 80’s due to two events. Oil and Thatcher

The oil revenues in the 80’s pointed

towards a possible different future for Scotland. The money generated was enormous but the money went south

This created a sense of anger that somehow we had been cheated

The other was Thatcher. The deindustrialisation of Scotland began in the early 80’s. The blame, and

some of that blame was correctly attributed, was all put on the Thatcher Government

The main beneficiary though wasn’t the Nationalists, it was Labour

Nationalism subsided again until devolution arrived. Labour wanted to cement their stranglehold of Scottish politics.

Unfortunately all they did, as Tam Dalyell predicted, was hasten their own demise

The hatred that the Labour movement had, and continues to have, for Tories was simply coopted by the Nationalists

Add in the 800 years of unwarranted grievance towards the English et voila

You have the perfect storm

This only explains parts of the rise of the Nationalists. Hate can only carry you so far

The next trick was finance. We had been cheated and cheated big time

Anyone who has ever been cheated out of money knows that the scars run deep

You never forget it. Money is hard to earn. Being cheated out of it burns your soul

This was the Nationalists Trump card

We’ve been cheated. We’ve been robbed. It cut deep in the already damaged Scottish psyche

If only we hadn’t been cheated we would be better off and

richer. We’d all be much much happier. Think of all the things Scotland could have had if we hadn’t been cheated

Unfortunately for the Nationalists it never happened. We weren’t cheated and we weren’t robbed

It’s a great myth and one the Nationalists continue to use to this

day, but it never happened

The explanation as to why it never happened is too long for this thread. You can find a good gist of it in my blog. edwardthomasblack.blogspot.com/2021/01/lies-d…

We can’t undo 800 years of myths, grievance and legends overnight but one thing we can do is expose the

very lies that the Nationalists continue to promulgate

I’ve said this many many times

Every single nationalist I know, without exception, truly truly believes that England is stealing our money

Even the super smart ones that I know also believe this. You’d think that it

would be easy to just have a look at the accounts to check but all they then say is that the accounts are false

We’re never going to change this around big time by trying to convince that Nationalists that England isn’t stealing their money

The only way to do this is to

confront nationalist politicians. Put them on the spot. Don’t let them get away with prevarication or sidestepping the issue

Hammer them on the finances. Even when we’ve hammered them, hammer them even more. And when we’ve got them on their knees with nowhere to hide,

hammer them again

In my personal opinion the blood and soil nationalist vote is no more than 25-30%. These people are gone. They have to come to their senses in their own good time. Many of them would live for decades in mud huts and gruel if only Scotland could be


That’s not our target. Our target is the low paid worker who thinks riches lie around the corner for them if Independent

The School teacher who believes they’ll get a massive salary increase and a great pension if Independent

The public sector worker who

thinks that services will massively improve if Independent

In the last 7-8 years I haven’t seen a single interviewer, in print, tv or radio challenge the SNP ruthlessly on finance

I’m not talking about a 2 minute sound bite but a full 30-60 minutes of non stop financial

analysis of Scotland’s finances

That’s where the battle will be won. This presumes that the SNP doesn’t self implode

No amount of scandal or cheating or lying has effected their vote


Because they’ve convinced enough people that we’ll all be rich if Independent

This is only going to happen, in my opinion, in two ways

Either an interviewer/journalist manages to hammer away at the SNP (I’ve seen scant evidence of any journalists that have the financial knowledge to do this) or the opposition politicians

They have even less financial nous than the journalists, which is saying something

We can never out nationalist the Nationalists so there’s no point in trying

Scots will never willingly vote to be poorer but they’ll only ever know that if the journalists or politicians

manage to get through to them. You have to put the nationalist politicians on the spot and paint them into a corner so that they have nowhere else to go but to admit what we already know

They’re slippery people but if we’re to succeed it needs to be done and done now

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh

Keep Current with 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿🇬🇧Edward Thomas Black

🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿🇬🇧Edward Thomas Black Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!


Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @edglasgow59

6 Feb

Just remember this

We all know Nationalists. They’re our friends, partners and family

From personal knowledge, every single one I have ever came across or know base their Nationalism on two precepts

1: That WM is corrupt and we can do things better

2: England/rUK is stealing our money and if we were independent we could keep all that money for ourselves

Firstly, no one comes close to the corruption in the Scottish Gov. They have totally corrupted all the organs of Gov

The civil service has been co-opted into the

Nationalist family. The judiciary has been corrupted to the level that it need to be de natified

The Schools have been corrupted to the degree that they push Nationalist propaganda

The media has been cowed to the degree that they rarely criticise the Scot Gov
Read 5 tweets
26 Jan

Corruption in Scotland

Scotland is corrupt. There’s no two ways about it. The SNP have blurred the lines between the Party, the State and the Judiciary and the Media

All four are supposed to be separate but in Scotland they’ve almost merged into one thing

All at the behest of the most corrupt politician in Europe

Nicola Sturgeon

She has blatantly lied to Holyrood about when she first heard of the allegations against Alex Salmond. She said it was the beginning of April 2018 when she first heard. Geoff Aberdein, under oath

at Alex Salmond’s trial said that he met with Sturgeon 4 days or so earlier to discuss the allegations. Read the piece by Craig Murray. There are witnesses that contradict Sturgeons view

That she lied in Holyrood isn’t in doubt. That the crown office is covering up for her
Read 4 tweets
25 Jan

How Scotland spends England’s money and lies about it!

Ask any leftie journalist in London

Who runs their economies better. Scotland or England?

I’ll bet that the vast majority of them say Scotland does


Because they’ll point to free Uni tuition, baby boxes etc etc

Unfortunately they’ve been had. They’ve been taken in by the best propagandists since the Third Reich and what worse. They’re happy to be taken in by the SNP

As far as they’re concerned. Any anti Tory is good by them!

Unfortunately none of it is true

None of it

How can I prove that none of it is true?

Easy. All one needs to do is read the ONS Country and regional accounts

It details the revenues and expenditures for all four UK Countries 👇


And what does it say?
Read 17 tweets
23 Jan

The SNP versus the Law

The SNP is in trouble. They know it and we know it. It’s almost certain that Nicola Sturgeon will need to resign for lying to Holyrood

This explains the frantic calls for another referendum

Brexit is done and the sky didn’t fall in

This removes their number one Bête Noire. A Disastrous hard Brexit

They were banking on that happening. There will be, and are, difficulties with the new trading arrangements but these will play out over years and will be sorted one way or another

The Law

As it stands, the SNP cannot call another referendum without the permission of the UK Parliament

Some people dispute this, including many in the SNP

So. What’s the alternative?

The could call a non binding non legal referendum but what’s the point

Unionist will
Read 20 tweets
23 Nov 20

The missing Scottish Referendum of 2021

Every day we hear Nationalists and their politicians go on about another referendum in 2021

It’s not happening. It’s never going to be happening and Sturgeon knows it’s not going to be happening

Why not?

Well. That’s easy

For one thing, the SNP simply cannot call a referendum. Sure, they can hold a non binding referendum, but even that would be subject to legal challenge

They simply can’t have a legal referendum because legally, they don’t have the power to call one

That power resides in WM

and only WM. Referendums are reserved and a Section 30 order is needed in order to have one

Boris Johnson is not going to allow one. He’s already said so and stated that the referendum in 2014 must be respected. Not only because it was the biggest turnout in British History
Read 8 tweets
21 Nov 20

Although this is over 4 years old it should terrify every single person in Scotland


Nicola Sturgeon has decided, that for her, her teenage dream of destroying the British state is more important than just about anything in her life Image

And many Scots also agree with her

If you look to Africa you will find Poverty, corruption and third world countries. The reason why most of Africa is still poor is because they do not have developed advanced economy

Without a developed advanced economy you simply cannot

have good health care, good education or decent welfare. All of these come from having a good economy. We all look to the Scandinavian countries and admire their systems. Their excellent health, education and welfare systems. They only have these because their economy
Read 7 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!

This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!