Why Hasn’t Biden Fired These Three Terrible Trump Holdovers?@POTUS @vp @SenatorDurbin @SenSchumer @SpeakerPelosi

Last summer, the Supreme Court’s conservatives handed down a 5–4 decision against the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau that was hailed as a conservative victory. In retrospect, it was also a huge gift to Joe Biden.
The court’s decision gave Biden unquestioned authority to oust Trump’s corrupt CFPB director, which he did on Day One. It also pretty clearly gives him the power to fire three other
Trump holdovers leading federal agencies—Mark Calabria, Andrew Saul, and David Black—who will continue to pursue the former president’s policies if allowed to remain in office. Curiously, Biden has not yet sacked either official.
His restraint will allow both men to undermine his agenda from within the executive branch—exactly what the Supreme Court gave him the tools to prevent. Biden should remove these three officials immediately.
Unlike the CFPB, most independent agencies are run by a multi-member board, which gives the president greater control over their leadership. Indeed, there are only two other regulatory agencies led by a single director who was previously shielded from termination by the president
: The Social Security Administration, which runs the biggest government program in the country, and the Federal Housing Finance Agency, which regulates the mortgage market.
These job protections, though, are no longer enforceable. In his opinion for the court in Seila Law, Chief Justice John Roberts indicated that his reasoning doomed the independence of these agencies’ directors. Roberts described the SSA’s single-director structure as
“comparatively recent and controversial,” noting that it was established in 1994 and that President Bill Clinton “questioned [its] constitutionality,” even inviting Congress to issue a “corrective amendment.”
The chief justice also cast side-eye on the FHFA, describing it as “essentially a companion of the CFPB,” whose “single-Director structure is a source of ongoing controversy.” He pointed out that the agency’s structure “was recently held unconstitutional”
That precedent plainly gives Biden the ability to terminate Calabria, the FHFA director, and Saul, the SSA commissioner, on Jan. 20—just as he ousted Kathleen Kraninger, Trump’s CFPB director.
Start with Calabria, who was confirmed in 2019 to a term set to end in 2024. His agency, the FHFA, regulates the mortgage giants Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, as well as 11 government-sponsored banks. He formerly served as chief economist for former Vice President Mike Pence
Calabria’s chief goal has been to end the government’s conservatorship of Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, which allows his agency to manage both companies. By privatizing them, he would disrupt the housing-finance system, substantially raise the cost of mortgages
Under Calabria’s leadership, Freddie Mac also provided a huge loan to the Kushner Companies on unusually favorable terms. ❗(Jared Kushner, Trump’s son-in-law, ran the Kushner Companies before Trump’s presidency, and retained almost all of his interest ‼
If the Kushner Companies default, taxpayers may wind up footing the bill.❗ (The agency denied any wrongdoing.) This act alone should be reason enough to get rid of Calabria straightaway.‼❗
Turn next to ❗Andrew Saul, commissioner of the Social Security Administration, as well as his deputy commissioner, David Black. ❗❗Trump appointed both men in 2019 to terms that won’t end until 2025. ‼Their rein over the agency has been nothing short of catastrophic.
Saul previously served on the board of the ❗Manhattan Institute, a conservative group that advocates for severe cuts to Social Security❗. Together, Saul and Black have launched an all-out war against the agency’s nearly 60,000 employees, attempting to sabotage its union‼
They abolished the agency’s ❗innovative telework program, which had dramatically increased efficiency, and forced employees to work in-person even as 😡the pandemic surged last spring. At the end of 2020, ‼the SSA’s staff overwhelmingly voted no confidence in Saul or Black.
😡Trump’s men at the SSA haven’t just targeted their own employees they’ve also made it more difficult for qualified Americans to receive Social Security benefits. ‼❗
‼Currently, Americans who wish to claim disability benefits are guaranteed a hearing before an administrative law judge—an independent arbiter who cannot be pressured by the government to rule against claimants.
‼Saul and Black want to let “attorney advisors,” who answer to the agency’s political appointees, hear disability cases instead. ‼These “attorney advisors” have no guaranteed independence and, unlike administrative law judges, receive annual bonuses
This unprecedented move, which may well be illegal‼, would effectively deny due process to people who have a right to these benefits by allowing political appointees ‼to manipulate the adjudication of claims. It is past time for Biden to fire both of these officials.
Seila Law obviously spelled doom for each man’s job protections, SCOTUS has not yet applied its decision to their agencies.
That leaves Saul and Black. On his second day in office, Biden put Saul on a list of “acting” agency officials who will soon be replaced by Senate-confirmed appointees.
This designation is puzzling, because Saul is not “acting” as SSA commissioner, but serving a term that expires in 2025. The decision suggests that Biden views Saul as “acting” because he intends to replace him with a progressive in the near future.
It’s safe to assume that Biden would simultaneously replace Black, who has consistently supported Saul’s destructive policies.😡
Progressives in the new administration may hesitate to wield Seila Law against Trump holdovers. ❗ Roberts’ opinion in Seila Law transformed the very nature of the presidency, whether Biden likes it or not‼
The chief justice’s watchword was ❗“accountability”: Executive officials must be accountable to the president, he wrote, for the president, in turn, is accountable to the people. ‼
The people elected Biden on a liberal platform that leaves no room for reckless deregulation, devastating assaults on unions, or cuts to crucial government benefits. ‼‼If he refuses to fire officials implementing these policies, he will bear the blame in the public eye. ❗

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh

Keep Current with James Mitchell Ⓥ🐬

James Mitchell Ⓥ🐬 Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!


Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @MesMitch

24 Feb
A Target employee in California broke his arm after trying to remove two customers refusing to wear masks. In Flint, Michigan, a security guard at a Family Dollar store was shot and killed after a dispute with a disgruntled customer over wearing a face mask.
“The nurse asked him to put his mask on if he wanted to be seen,” the urologist said. “He got verbally aggressive with her, saying he had a right not to wear a mask, and that we were denying his constitutional rights.#COVIDー19
At that point, the patient called 911 to complain he was being denied medical care. “We’re a private property, not an emergency room. “We’re not required to treat him, and he was not having an acute emergency. I think he just had a very poor understanding of what his rights were
Read 6 tweets
23 Feb
#YandasaSefaMilleteCefa After four years of Trump, who declared the EU an enemy of American interests, one can understand the relief in Europe over Biden and his foreign policy course. duvarenglish.com/from-virtual-m…
For Biden, the world is at a crossroads between autocracy and democracy. He is counting on allies in Europe to strengthen the democratic bloc. “We have to prove that our model isn’t a relic of our history.” The major competitors against the West for Biden are China and Russia
German chancellor Angela Merkel also spoke of a new chapter in transatlantic relations, but was not specific on the topics of Russia and China. Especially with regard to chin China, Germany's position is not as clear as the U.S. would like it to be.
Read 9 tweets
22 Feb
Anadolu Kültür, a nonprofit cultural organization founded by jailed philanthropist Osman Kavala, has rejected the Trade Ministry's “unlawful” lawsuit seeking its closure.
“For the first time in the history of the Republic of Turkey, a lawsuit is filed against a company on the grounds that it 'carries out its activities without profit, similar to associations and foundations,'” Anadolu Kültür said in a statement on Feb. 16.
The company said that it has carried out all its operations legally and transparently since its establishment in 2002 and no crime has been detected in the investigation of Turkey's Financial Crimes Investigation Board (MASAK).
Read 7 tweets
22 Feb
In recent times, everyone has been talking about Generation Z, and rightly so! People who are in their teens and twenties today are transforming the country: from the students at Boğaziçi University and elsewhere fighting for academic freedom to the millions of young people
Not so long ago, however, it was millennials (those born between 1980 and 2000) who were seen as both the promised generation of social change and, for conservatives, the destroyer of all things holy.
The hysteria around millennials began in the United States in 2011, around the time of Occupy Wall Street. Research by think tanks had just reported that millennials in the US were on the path to be the first generation economically worse off than their parents’ generation.
Read 20 tweets
21 Feb
This comes as a second #Khashoggi moment in Turkey. A Iranian dissident called Habib Chaab came to Istanbul to meet with a woman - said to be his ex-wife - only to end up back in Iran. He was last seen blindfolded on Iranian TV channels.
Chaab’s abduction was like a scene from a spy movie. Chaab’s ex-wife invites him to Turkey and offers to hand him some money when they meet. But as Chaab arrives in Istanbul and as gets onto a minivan to meet his ex-wife, a group of mean kidnap him and take him back to Iran.
Turkey has detained 11 people involved in Chaab’s abduction and his smuggling to Iran. Those 11 men are believed to be working with Zindashti, who is an infamous drug lord in Turkey.
Read 6 tweets
21 Feb
More than six decades after a 1,705-acre patchwork of meadows, wetlands and timberland in southern Oregon was taken from the Klamath Tribes, the Native American community has found its way back to the territory – by way of the real estate market.
Although another buyer nearly swooped in, the tribes’ purchase more than doubles their current holdings, and extends their territory to the base of Yamsay Mountain, an important site for prayer and spiritual journeys for the community.
Willa Powless, Klamath Tribes’ council member at large, said it was major step toward piecing together a “broken heart”.

“Our people are born with a spiritual connection to the land that we all feel and we all know and our elders teach us about,” she said.
Read 6 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!

This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!