Here's the real story of Isro 'spy' case that rocked the nation in 1990s
Rs-50-lakh award 2 former ISRO scientist S. Nambi Narayanan for being “unnecessarily arrested & harassed” by Kerala police will go some distance in providing a closure to the so-called ‘ISRO spy case’.
There will probably never be a real closure – there are too many loose ends to the case that rocked India in the mid-1990s.
It began with the arrest of Maldivian woman, Mariam Rashida, in Oct 1994, on charges of overstaying her visa that led to the surprise arrests of Narayanan,
the director of cryogenic project lab of Indian Space Research Organisation (ISRO), his deputy and several other persons.
The story emerges from the murky confluence of two separate underground streams. The first was Narayanan’s connection to the cryogenic engine project at ISRO.
Having perfected PSLV, Indian space scientists took aim @ the next target — that of a more powerful rocket that could hoist payloads 2 the geosynchronous transfer orbit. This Geosynchronous Satellite Launch Vehicle (GSLV) would be capstone of India’s launch vehicle technology.
With the PSLV, India had exhausted the limits of the older Vikas engine which, in turn, had been developed from the French Viking engine.

What was needed now was a cryogenic engine that would power the third stage of the rocket.
In 1990, India signed a deal with the Russian agency Glavkosmos for the engine, which included the transfer of technology.
Following the Soviet collapse, however, the United States began an effort to block India’s nuclear and missile quest.
Globally, it pushed for the extension of the NPT “in perpetuity” and begin negotiations on the Comprehensive Nuclear-Test-Ban Treaty. With regard to India, it sought to tie India into a “freeze, cap and roll back” arrangement with Pakistan.
They succeeded in ensurin lease for INS Chakra nuclear submarine was not renewed & finally, it arm-twisted Russia 2 scrap cryogenic engine deal. So, ISRO had to strike out on its own & it did so by initiating a project in April94 with its star liquid propulsion scientist, 👉...
Nambi Narayanan
Also read…
The second stream was always devious politics of Kerala. Among the more enduring rivalries, there was the one between Congress leaders K. Karunakaran and A.K. Antony. In 1977 👉...
Karunakaran’s stewardship of the chief ministership came under a shadow because of the Emergency. He was replaced by the new boy wonder – 37-year-old Antony. After a brief second term, Karunakaran became chief minister for 3rd time in mid-1980s & then for 4th time.
in June 1991. The Antony faction chafed at this and was always on the lookout for ways to undermine him.
Before Rashida’s arrest, S. Vijayan, inspector dealing with foreigners, had allegedly approached her for sexual favours & eventually arrested her because she turned him down.
In a vindictive act, he decided 2 frame her for espionage. In meantime, some Sr & ambitious Kerala police officers, close to Antony & Oommen Chandy, Congress leader who had fallen out with Karunakaran, saw Rashida’s arrest as a means of embarrassing the IG police close to 👉👉👉
Karunakaran: Raman Srivastava.
So case was given a sinister twist. Within a month of Rashida’s arrest, Narayanan’s deputy D. Sasikumaran, K. Chandrashekhar, the representative of Glavkosmos, the Russian space agency, S.K. Sharma, a labour contractor,& Fauziyya Hassan, 👉👉👉
Maldivian friend of Rashida, were arrested. 2 weeks later, on November 30 94 Narayanan was arrested.
In media, police wove fanciful net of fiction & innuendo alleging at Narayanan & Sasikumaran had been trapped in a sex racket involving Maldivians & given them secret ISRO papers.
Intelligence Bureau (IB) played a controversial role in leading Kerala police down the espionage route & the latter tamely followed. It was only when the CBI looked at the evidence in December 94 that they found the whole case was a concoction & that the people were being framed.…
Within a month of their arrests, it was clear via the CBI investigation that there was nothing to the case. Yet the case dragged on because of entanglement with Kerala politics. Even as Narayanan & Sasikumaran got bail in January, 👉👉👉
Karunakaran came under pressure from the Antony faction & was forced out of office in March 95.
The others languished in jail much longer; Rashida was only released in 1998. In May 1996, CBI finally filed a report before the chief judicial magistrate 👉👉👉
saying that the espionage case was false and that there was no evidence to back the charges. The court accepted the report and discharged all the accused.
But the CPI(M)-led government that has just come to power decided to play its own game and ordered further investigation 👉👉
till finally, in May 1998, the Supreme Court quashed the Kerala government’s move for a fresh investigation.
Kerala governments have since protected rogue police officers & have dragged their feet in paying compensation ordered by High Court & National Human Rights Commission.
So in April 2017, Narayanan filed a petition to initiate criminal proceedings against the police officers who allegedly fabricated evidence against him. The Supreme Court decided instead that it would be better to order a compensation to Narayanan to restore his reputation.
No amount of compensation can do justice to Narayanan and the others arrested in the case. But the question that lingers is: Why? Why were he and the others put through such an ordeal?
There are no easy answers. One is that such things are not uncommon in India.. 👉👉👉
where police often fabricate cases on a whim and act with impunity. In this case, interests of various parties — Vijayan, IB Joint Director Matthew John, R.B. Sreekumar, Dy director D.B. Sreekumar, IPS officer Siby Mathew – also seem 2coincide, though perhaps not for same reason.
The charge easiest to dismiss is of espionage. As for cryogenic engines, India clearly did not have that technology. The effort to get it from the Soviet Union had collapsed under US pressure. And Narayanan had just been appointed head of a group to develop it.
The second important point is to note that there is little “secret” in ISRO technology. It has, for example, widely distributed the designs of the Vikas engines to its contractors. To sidestep restrictions like Missile Technology Control Regime& promote foreign collaboration, 👉
India had deliberately made ISRO a transparent organisation, while the military missile programme was handled by the Defence Research and Development Organisation.
Now to the sinister part. We can understand the motives of Mathew: 👉👉
he was interested in tripping Raman Srivastava (who eventually rose to become DGP of Kerala and Director-General of the BSF), who he perceived was his rival. But what of the IB personnel Matthew John and R.B. Sreekumar?
There is no clear answer. 👉👉
CBI report on the case makes it clear that the investigation was led by the IB, and state police played along because their own vested interests were being served. CBI said that no “secret” documents were leaked nor did anyone arrested receive any money.
Legally, IB can neither arrest nor frame charges so the actions on allegations, including perhaps their concoction, was done by the IB. report says, “The IB had already come to conclusion regarding involvement of the accused in espionage case even before the case was registered.”
What could have been the motive of the IB joint director, Dy director? Incompetence cannot, of course, be ruled out.
But there are always wheels within wheels where IB is concerned. This was evident in a subsequent (and false) espionage case IB sought 2 foist on innocents, 👉👉
which is now known as NSCS spy case of 2006. At the time IB’s corporate interests may have been involved: they wanted to block NSCS from taking over what subsequently emerged as the NATGRID.
So last possibility is that US did indeed play a role, via rogue elements within the IB.
They played a visible role in blocking the sale of cryogenic technology to India. But once ISRO determined to go ahead, they decided to undermine Indian efforts by disrupting the Indian programme. Nambi Narayanan, it may be noted, had no links with Rashida, 👉👉
Fauzia or anyone other than Sasikumaran, who however may have known the women. Yet he was framed as the key figure in the drama. And he was, of course, the top Indian specialist on liquid propulsion.
What could have been the US motive?
The US thinks in the long term. That is why it created the Missile Technology Control Regime, whose existence was only revealed shortly after India conducted the first Prithvi test in 1987. Even if cryogenic technology is cumbersome and has no real military applications,👉👉
it is capable of powering missiles that can reach the continental United States.
Abundant caution has made the US what it is. Note that the US only got serious about North Korea after the latter demonstrated its capability of a missile that could reach the US in July 2017.
What concerns the US is capability, not who possesses it.
Manoj Joshi is a Distinguished Fellow, Observer Research Foundation, New Delhi.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh

Keep Current with Abhi Athavale🇮🇳🇮🇳

Abhi Athavale🇮🇳🇮🇳 Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!


Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @athavale_abhi

29 Jan
Very Well Written..

100% factual aspects are brought out in this text. Circulate this to as many people as you can...

*Dear CJI* & fellow Justices of Supreme Court of India,

1. A party Wins Lok Sabha elections, gets 303 seats with massive 46% vote share.

2. Then it wins state after state to get majority in Rajya Sabha.

3. It passes Kisan Bills in both the Houses, gets President's approval & the Bills become Laws.

4. Some 20-25 K of 1 state sits on road for a month, then you stay the LAWs.
5. What a mockery of the democratic process..!!!

6. Where are our protectors of democracy now ?? Those who were screaming that democracy is being murdered, not so long ago ??

7. The Supreme Court today said, "We are trying to solve the problem in accordance with the Law."
Read 19 tweets
10 Dec 20
I heard a very interesting analogy today,
A 10 floor building did not have a lift, so people had problem climbing up and down. Specially the elderly and the kids, so the society started exploring options.
Finally they got some donkeys, who could carry people up and down.
The donkey owners would charge people for carrying them up and down for a fee and would also pay 10% to the society from the revenue they earned. It was a very happy situation for all involved.
After sometime the society management changed.
the new management decided to install a lift for carrying people up &down.
All hell broke loose everyone started protesting, this is not fair, society will loose revenue, donkey owners will be jobless and no food for them (human rights issue), donkeys will be worthless
Read 5 tweets
2 Dec 20
Death of the Muslim PM of India


*…and meanwhile wondering how come there are more farmers protesting on social media than on the streets, here are a few point of views, a few stray thoughts & a few random observations (all my own work) :*
*That it's been such a tumultuous week for Bharatvarsha, that our first defacto Muslim PM died & very few noticed.*

*Muslim PM?*

Yup, the 90s saw the rise of a certain Ahmedbhai Mohammedbhai Patel - a shifty-eyed & a shifty-morals MP from Gujarat...
who'd cunningly realized that with his dishonest visage, he could never become the poster boy of Congress & hence moved to the proverbial backroom. But all that almost ended with Rajiv Baba's assassination...
Read 37 tweets
30 Nov 20
```👉In April 2013, Punjab government passed the Punjab Contract Farming Act to provide a legal framework to contract farming. The Punjab Act did not have a provision mandating that sale cannot be below the MSP. 14 states already allowed contract farming before Farms Bills.
Then why are Punjab farmers protesting now?

👉The problem is not MSP its the Inter state purchase and sales that can now be made bypassing Mandis...
That's what changed.And MSPs only cover few produce. Even Milk is not under MSP, neither are fruits and vegetables.
👉This farmers agitation is manipulated by the "Adhatis ( Money lenders)" who will stand to lose Rs 2000 crore per year during wheat & paddy procurement season. Centre's FarmLaws have rendered them irrelevant as farmers are free from the clutches. Biggies in Punjab are rattled.
Read 28 tweets
30 Nov 20
Shift grain bowl status from North to other regions of India

Balwinder Singh Sidhu, agriculture commissioner and chief conservator of soils in Punjab, is known for giving his opinion in a frank and forthright manner.
He has ruffled many feathers in the political establishment of Punjab and in Krishi Bhawan, the agriculture ministry's central office in Delhi. But this doesn’t stop this gold medallist water engineer from Roorkee University from apprising his bosses of ground realities.
He is With just three years more in service, Sidhu has only one aim—to leave a legacy of at least a water-sufficient Punjab, if not surplus. In an interview to Jyotika Sood, he talks about challenges with India’s food bowl states—Punjab and Haryana.
Read 19 tweets
30 Nov 20
My humble request to all. Please watch the video before you read this thread.

Powered by TubeMate (
@Rahulshivshankar will you apologise to Mr Arnab Goswami for your India upfront telecast on the 8th October, just after the press conference by the Rogue commissioner convicting him for his so called involvement in the TRP scam even before the charges could be proved?
Next day it was apparent that the name mentioned was of some other channel and not Republic TV.
The way you were speaking and making accusations on Arnab and Republic TV seemed to me that you considered yourself as the Demigod of the TV media.
Read 26 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!

This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!